LuckySherry / TwitterClient_0.2

COMP3111_Phase1_Team202
0 stars 0 forks source link

Retweeting related bug #13

Open monosite opened 11 years ago

monosite commented 11 years ago

What steps will reproduce the problem?

  1. Post a tweet at own wall at home page
  2. Reply to this tweet just posted 3, Expand these tweet
  3. Click on these retweet button

or

  1. Go to any timeline include your tweet excluding the home page time line
  2. Click on these retweet button of your own tweet

What is the expected output? What do you see instead? A retweet button will be shown of those tweet that posted by yourself which is wrong as twitter does not allow user to retweet self tweet

wangbohkust commented 11 years ago

You can see the requirement for retweet:

  1. Retweeting / Unretweeting a tweet The retweet / unretweet function is a very common functionality in twitter. Therefore, it should also be designed and implemented in the app. 4.1. For a nonretweeted tweet displaying in the app, we should be able to retweet it in one or a few simple and intuitive steps. After a tweet has been retweeted, it should be displayed differentlyfrom nonretweeted tweets, such that it can be distinguished easily. 4.2. For a retweeted tweet displaying in the app, we should be able to unretweet it (making it not retweeted) in one or a few simple and intuitive steps. After a tweet has been unretweeted,it should not be displayed differently anymore.
wangbohkust commented 11 years ago

Is there any word said that we can not retweet ourself?

monosite commented 11 years ago

The problem is that the TweetView display retweeted for own tweet, but its acutaully not retweeted and no Excepetion and Suggestion are given accrodinig to 9.2. For any possible exceptions that may occur (e.g., exceed twitter rate limit), the app should clearly inform its users about the exception reason, and provide suggestions to avoid it.. But its not provided with no clearly inform its users the problem but misleading the user that you can retweet own tweet.

waitingcheung commented 11 years ago

Confirmed. You cannot retweet your own tweet.

Ken