Some addresses are showing orange as FTTC although FTTP is apparently connected (and FTTC->FTTP upgrades generally available in the area)

LukePrior / nbn-upgrade-map

Interactive map showing premises eligible for the NBN FTTP upgrade program.

https://nbn.lukeprior.com/

MIT License

137 stars 11 forks source link

Some addresses are showing orange as FTTC although FTTP is apparently connected (and FTTC->FTTP upgrades generally available in the area) #384

Closed trs80 closed 2 months ago

trs80 commented 3 months ago

Eg LOC000038973474 "reasonCode":"FTTP_CT","altReasonCode":"FTTC_CT","techChangeStatus":"New Tech Connected" vs LOC000058374654 "reasonCode":"FTTC_CT","altReasonCode":"FTTP_SA","techChangeStatus":"Eligible to Order" and LOC000079861379 "reasonCode":"FTTP_CT","altReasonCode":"NULL_NA","techChangeStatus":"Previous Tech Disconnected"

lyricnz commented 3 months ago

You couldn't tell us the suburb?

   "properties": {
    "name": "39 NINGALOO WAY THORNLIE 6108",
    "locID": "LOC000038973474",
    "tech": "FTTC",
    "upgrade": "FTTP",
    "gnaf_pid": "GAWA_146801070",
    "tech_change_status": "New Tech Connected"
   }

Even the NBNco website seems confused about this:

I don't know how we can plot tech=FTTC anything except orange?

lyricnz commented 3 months ago

   "properties": {
    "name": "1 PENDER COURT THORNLIE 6108",
    "locID": "LOC000058374654",
    "tech": "FTTC",
    "upgrade": "FTTP_SA",
    "gnaf_pid": "GAWA_147006557",
    "tech_change_status": "Eligible to Order"
   }

yeah this one is confusing. The colours has always confused me. See https://github.com/LukePrior/nbn-upgrade-map/issues/367

lyricnz commented 3 months ago

   "properties": {
    "name": "12 CAMDEN COURT THORNLIE 6108",
    "locID": "LOC000079861379",
    "tech": "FTTP",
    "upgrade": "NULL_NA",
    "gnaf_pid": "GAWA_146798813",
    "tech_change_status": "Previous Tech Disconnected"
   }

trs80 commented 2 months ago

You couldn't tell us the suburb?

I mean you can get it from the LOCIDs but fair, I was just being lazy

   "properties": {
    "name": "39 NINGALOO WAY THORNLIE 6108",
    "locID": "LOC000038973474",
    "tech": "FTTC",
    "upgrade": "FTTP",
    "gnaf_pid": "GAWA_146801070",
    "tech_change_status": "New Tech Connected"
   }

Even the NBNco website seems confused about this:

Yeah that's an odd result from their side. But I guess the FTTC could still be active and they have another service now on FTTP?

I don't know how we can plot tech=FTTC anything except orange?

I mean, upgrade=FTTP surely means FTTP upgrade is available. I was going to suggest adding another line to https://github.com/LukePrior/nbn-upgrade-map/blob/main/code/main.py#L33 but https://github.com/LukePrior/nbn-upgrade-map/blob/main/code/main.py#L84 only looks at altReasonCode, the differentiator is in reasonCode which isn't checked anywhere at the moment.

LukePrior commented 2 months ago

Hi @trs80 I've pushed an update, please let me know if there are any cases where this is still being incorrectly displayed.

LukePrior commented 2 months ago

Closing due to lack of reply