search

MATPOWER / matpower

MATPOWER – steady state power flow simulation and optimization for MATLAB and Octave
https://matpower.org
Other
414 stars 151 forks source link

improve slack distribution among multiple gens at slack bus #63

Open rdzman opened 5 years ago

rdzman commented 5 years ago

Currently, when there are multiple generators at the slack bus, MATPOWER's power flow considers the first generator at the bus to be the slack generator, taking up all of the slack. However, I'm not sure if this convention is documented anywhere and it is probably not the behavior intuitively expected by most users.

I propose to update MATPOWER's handling of slack allocation among multiple generators at a slack bus in the following way:

  1. If area participation factors (APF column of gen matrix) are provided, split the slack according to the proportions indicated by the relative participation factors.
  2. If area participation factors are not provided (i.e. set to 0), the slack will be distributed according to the size of the generator. I.e. for identical generators it will be distributed evenly.

This also needs to be mentioned explicitly in the documentation.

rwl commented 5 years ago

The output of the slack generator often serves as a convenient way to quickly compare power flow results. For example, in Andes there is an effort to use the output from MATPOWER, via Oct2PYPOWER, to verify power flow results. Both of the suggestions made seem to be worthwhile improvements over the current approach. However, given that this would represent a breaking change for MATPOWER v7 it might be worth starting a thread on the mailing list so that this could be discussed further with the user community.

rdzman commented 5 years ago

Good point. I'll just mention that the motivation for this change is to remove ambiguity in the handling of slack for such cases, in order to enhance the reproducibility of results.

Feel free to discuss on the mailing list (see this thread), or here.