MICommunity / psidev

@Deprecated please use https://github.com/HUPO-PSI Code exported from http://sourceforge.net/p/psidev/cvs/
2 stars 1 forks source link

Lys modification with retinal isomers #532

Open SourceForge-exporter opened 11 years ago

SourceForge-exporter commented 11 years ago

Hi John, after our email exchange, I'd like to submit this request for distinguishing the binding of retinal isomers to rhodopsin during visual transduction process. In PSI-MOD there is Retinylidene (MOD:00129), the conversion of an L-lysine residue by retinal. In the visual transduction process, 11-cis-retinal first binds to rhodopsin then light causes isomerization of the cis form to all-trans-retinal. This causes a conformational change in rhodopsin which then tranduces the signal downstream via G-proteins. For my work, it would be great if the PSI-MOD entry above can be resolved to two, one with 11cRAL modification and one with atRAL modification. See PubMed:12177057 for reference. Thanks

Reported by: beej160

SourceForge-exporter commented 11 years ago

Original comment by: jsgaravelli

SourceForge-exporter commented 10 years ago

Hi John

I think I found the appropriate mod for atRAL-L-lys (MOD:00317). Do you believe this to be the correct one? To update this request, please could a PSI-MOD be created for just 11cRAL-L-lys?

Regards

Bijay

Original comment by: beej160

SourceForge-exporter commented 10 years ago

Sorry about this falling through the cracks. No, MOD:00317 (RESID:AA0312) is a modified form of the rentinal adduct (MOD:00129, RESID:AA0120) with two hydrogens removed to form a second double bond in the six member ring. to look at these, use the new RESID search page (to replace SRS) at http://pir0.georgetown.edu/cgi-bin/resid and those entries are at http://pir0.georgetown.edu/cgi-bin/resid?id=AA0120 and http://pir0.georgetown.edu/cgi-bin/resid?id=AA0312 What you are asking for is a geometric isomer of RESID:AA0120, which does not differ in molecular weight from it and is mentioned in the comment as the "11-cis (4Z) form". So it has the same molecular weight as MOD:00129; it could not be distinguished by mass-spec, and is not formed by direct enzymatic modification of the lysine residue in rhodopsin so cannot get its own entry in RESID. Technically, to create an entry for it in PSI-MOD, it would have to be derived from MOD:00129 with a mass difference of 0, and the mass-spec people do not like it when I make extra entries with identical masses. I will go ahead and make an entry for it in the next PSI-MOD with a fictitious derivation from lysine so that it will duplicate the values in MOD:00129 but have different common ("11-cis") and systematic ("4Z") names. It will not be in the slim, so the mass-spec people will be able to ignore it. (But they will still complain.)

Original comment by: jsgaravelli

SourceForge-exporter commented 10 years ago

Hi John

Good to hear from you! Thanks for helping me with this.

I’m a little confused as to what PSI-MOD I should use for atRAL-L-lysine. I know you say you’ll create a new PSI-MOD for 11cRAL-L-lysine.

Cheers

Bijay

On 20 Mar 2014, at 14:38, "John S. Garavelli" jsgaravelli@users.sf.net wrote:

Sorry about this falling through the cracks. No, MOD:00317 (RESID:AA0312) is a modified form of the rentinal adduct (MOD:00129, RESID:AA0120) with two hydrogens removed to form a second double bond in the six member ring. to look at these, use the new RESID search page (to replace SRS) at http://pir0.georgetown.edu/cgi-bin/resid and those entries are at http://pir0.georgetown.edu/cgi-bin/resid?id=AA0120 and http://pir0.georgetown.edu/cgi-bin/resid?id=AA0312 What you are asking for is a geometric isomer of RESID:AA0120, which does not differ in molecular weight from it and is mentioned in the comment as the "11-cis (4Z) form". So it has the same molecular weight as MOD:00129; it could not be distinguished by mass-spec, and is not formed by direct enzymatic modification of the lysine residue in rhodopsin so cannot get its own entry in RESID. Technically, to create an entry for it in PSI-MOD, it would have to be derived from MOD:00129 with a mass difference of 0, and the mass-spec people do not like it when I make extra entries with identical masses. I will go ahead and make an entry for it in the next PSI-MOD with a fictitious derivation from lysine so that it will duplicate the values in MOD:00129 but have different common ("11-cis") and systematic ("4Z") names. It will not be in the slim, so the mass-spec people will be able to ignore it. (But they will still complain.)

[mod-controlled-vocab-changes:#67] Lys modification with retinal isomers

Status: open Group: Created: Wed Aug 22, 2012 06:58 PM UTC by BijayJassal Last Updated: Wed Mar 19, 2014 01:42 PM UTC Owner: John S. Garavelli

Hi John, after our email exchange, I'd like to submit this request for distinguishing the binding of retinal isomers to rhodopsin during visual transduction process. In PSI-MOD there is Retinylidene (MOD:00129), the conversion of an L-lysine residue by retinal. In the visual transduction process, 11-cis-retinal first binds to rhodopsin then light causes isomerization of the cis form to all-trans-retinal. This causes a conformational change in rhodopsin which then tranduces the signal downstream via G-proteins. For my work, it would be great if the PSI-MOD entry above can be resolved to two, one with 11cRAL modification and one with atRAL modification. See PubMed:12177057 for reference. Thanks

Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in https://sourceforge.net/p/psidev/mod-controlled-vocab-changes/67/

To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

Original comment by: beej160

SourceForge-exporter commented 10 years ago

If by "atRAL-L-lysine" you mean "all-trans-retinal-L-lysine", then that is the MOD:00129, RESID:AA0120. Look at the diagram, the configuration around all of the extended chain double bonds is "trans", now systematically designated as "E", aus deutsch "entgegen".

Original comment by: jsgaravelli

SourceForge-exporter commented 10 years ago

Aha, OK, that’s good with me.

Thanks for clarifying.

When could you make the 11-cis form? I only ask as it’s the only outstanding PSI-MOD we don’t have for our modifications in Reactome.

Cheers

Bijay

On 20 Mar 2014, at 15:44, "John S. Garavelli" jsgaravelli@users.sf.net wrote:

If by "atRAL-L-lysine" you mean "all-trans-retinal-L-lysine", then that is the MOD:00129, RESID:AA0120. Look at the diagram, the configuration around all of the extended chain double bonds is "trans", now systematically designated as "E", aus deutsch "entgegen".

[mod-controlled-vocab-changes:#67] Lys modification with retinal isomers

Status: open Group: Created: Wed Aug 22, 2012 06:58 PM UTC by BijayJassal Last Updated: Thu Mar 20, 2014 02:38 PM UTC Owner: John S. Garavelli

Hi John, after our email exchange, I'd like to submit this request for distinguishing the binding of retinal isomers to rhodopsin during visual transduction process. In PSI-MOD there is Retinylidene (MOD:00129), the conversion of an L-lysine residue by retinal. In the visual transduction process, 11-cis-retinal first binds to rhodopsin then light causes isomerization of the cis form to all-trans-retinal. This causes a conformational change in rhodopsin which then tranduces the signal downstream via G-proteins. For my work, it would be great if the PSI-MOD entry above can be resolved to two, one with 11cRAL modification and one with atRAL modification. See PubMed:12177057 for reference. Thanks

Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in https://sourceforge.net/p/psidev/mod-controlled-vocab-changes/67/

To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

Original comment by: beej160

SourceForge-exporter commented 10 years ago

Hi John

Please could you let me know a timescale for when this 11-cis form can be created. Also, where to find it once created! I usually use OLS from EBI.

Cheers

Bijay

On 20 Mar 2014, at 16:18, BijayJassal beej160@users.sf.net wrote:

Aha, OK, that’s good with me.

Thanks for clarifying.

When could you make the 11-cis form? I only ask as it’s the only outstanding PSI-MOD we don’t have for our modifications in Reactome.

Cheers

Bijay

On 20 Mar 2014, at 15:44, "John S. Garavelli" jsgaravelli@users.sf.net wrote:

If by "atRAL-L-lysine" you mean "all-trans-retinal-L-lysine", then that is the MOD:00129, RESID:AA0120. Look at the diagram, the configuration around all of the extended chain double bonds is "trans", now systematically designated as "E", aus deutsch "entgegen".

[mod-controlled-vocab-changes:#67] Lys modification with retinal isomers

Status: open Group: Created: Wed Aug 22, 2012 06:58 PM UTC by BijayJassal Last Updated: Thu Mar 20, 2014 02:38 PM UTC Owner: John S. Garavelli

Hi John, after our email exchange, I'd like to submit this request for distinguishing the binding of retinal isomers to rhodopsin during visual transduction process. In PSI-MOD there is Retinylidene (MOD:00129), the conversion of an L-lysine residue by retinal. In the visual transduction process, 11-cis-retinal first binds to rhodopsin then light causes isomerization of the cis form to all-trans-retinal. This causes a conformational change in rhodopsin which then tranduces the signal downstream via G-proteins. For my work, it would be great if the PSI-MOD entry above can be resolved to two, one with 11cRAL modification and one with atRAL modification. See PubMed:12177057 for reference. Thanks

Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in https://sourceforge.net/p/psidev/mod-controlled-vocab-changes/67/

To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

[mod-controlled-vocab-changes:#67] Lys modification with retinal isomers

Status: open Group: Created: Wed Aug 22, 2012 06:58 PM UTC by BijayJassal Last Updated: Thu Mar 20, 2014 02:38 PM UTC Owner: John S. Garavelli

Hi John, after our email exchange, I'd like to submit this request for distinguishing the binding of retinal isomers to rhodopsin during visual transduction process. In PSI-MOD there is Retinylidene (MOD:00129), the conversion of an L-lysine residue by retinal. In the visual transduction process, 11-cis-retinal first binds to rhodopsin then light causes isomerization of the cis form to all-trans-retinal. This causes a conformational change in rhodopsin which then tranduces the signal downstream via G-proteins. For my work, it would be great if the PSI-MOD entry above can be resolved to two, one with 11cRAL modification and one with atRAL modification. See PubMed:12177057 for reference. Thanks

Sent from sourceforge.net because you indicated interest in https://sourceforge.net/p/psidev/mod-controlled-vocab-changes/67/

To unsubscribe from further messages, please visit https://sourceforge.net/auth/subscriptions/

Original comment by: beej160

SourceForge-exporter commented 10 years ago

Bijay, I have not been able to update RESID on 31 March as I had hoped. However, I will go ahead to make an interim release of PSI-MOD next week. I have reserved these identifiers for that relesae: PSI-MOD:01999 N6-(11-cis)-retinylidene-L-lysine PSI-MOD:02000 N6-retinylidene-L-lysine (unspecified geometric isomer) The entry PSI-MOD:00129 N6-retinylidene-L-lysine will be given a synonym indicating that it is the "all trans isomer".

Original comment by: jsgaravelli