Unexpected query results on a simple KB with recursive rules.

[liu-cs]

Hi, I am trying to use Problog to build an automatic geometry problem solver. I encountered an unexpected query result for the following simple KB:

is_parallel_to(X, Y) :- 
    X \== Y,
    is_parallel_to(Y, X).

is_parallel_to(X, Y) :- 
    X \== Y,
    is_parallel_to(X, Z),
    is_parallel_to(Y, Z).

is_parallel_to(line1, line2).
is_parallel_to(line1, line3).
query(is_parallel_to(line2, _)).

and the result is:

is_parallel_to(line2,line1):    1         
is_parallel_to(line2,line2):    1         
is_parallel_to(line2,line3):    1   

I couldn't understand how the is_parallel_to(line2,line2): 1 gets into the result as we have X \== Y, in the bodies of both rules. Can anyone please help to take a look and point out where it goes wrong? Thanks!

-Changsong

[rmanhaeve]

Hi Changsong

This is related to the whether the variables are grounded when you compare the check.

Since Y is not ground when comparing to X, the comparison \== is true, as it is just a check that they are not identical, which they are not. The unifcation only happens afterwards. Replace the \== by \= (meaning X and Y are not unifiable).

Try this code in the editor for comparison (link):

a :- 1 \== Y, Y=1.
b :- 1 \= Y, Y=1.
c :- Y=1, 1 \== Y.
d :- Y=1, 1 \= Y.

query(a).
query(b).
query(c).
query(d).

Hope this helps!

[liu-cs]

Thanks, Robin. The explanation and example are very clear. Our problog based geometry solver now works well :-)