search

MPEGGroup / OpenFontFormat

Official MPEG repository to discuss issues on Open Font Format (ISO/IEC 14496-22)
32 stars 6 forks source link

AMD2 WD, new subclause 5.7.11.3 "Color table formats" - order of entries in the ColorLine table #32

Closed vlevantovsky closed 3 years ago

vlevantovsky commented 4 years ago

It makes sense to define a specific order of entries in the colorStops array. The suggestion is for entries to be ordered in the increasing stopOffset order - NEEDS REVIEW. This is currently added as an informative note, may need to be converted to the spec proper. Also, a description of color line positioning in relation to the glyph design grid may be needed.

PeterConstable commented 4 years ago

Per ISO procedures, part 2, NOTEs must not include "shall"/"should" statements. In my draft colr_190_draft_201002.pdf (see #20), this statement was not a note.

vlevantovsky commented 4 years ago

Right, it wasn't proposed as a note in your version of the text, but your text was not part of the original submission. Adding a note is within a realm of what project editor can do, this is why I added it as a note with the comment to revise it and make it part of the spec proper. For as long as we all agree that this should be a normative language, we can easily make this change as part of the new submission.

vlevantovsky commented 3 years ago

Resolved as part of the ISO/IEC 14496-22:2019 Working Draft AMD2, closing the issue.