search

MaRDI4NFDI / portal-compose

docker-composer repo for mardi
https://portal.mardi4nfdi.de
GNU General Public License v3.0
3 stars 1 forks source link

Property that connects research problem with statistical model (different description of existing property on wikidata) #542

Open OleksandrZadorozhnyiML opened 6 days ago

OleksandrZadorozhnyiML commented 6 days ago

Hello,

this issue is connected to the issue https://github.com/MaRDI4NFDI/portal-compose/issues/541. We would like to have a property which in a KG connects "Research Problem" to a "Statistical model". One option we could use is as described in https://github.com/MaRDI4NFDI/MaRDIRoadmap/issues/40. Another option is to use property "represented by". The latter property has its homonymic analogue on the wikidata , but this property has another concept in mind to that the one that we need (it stays for " ..person or agency that represents or manages the subject" but we need it to be in the sense ".. conveys the information in the subject and enables intelligent-like decision based on statistical model").

It is possible to have the same property "represented by" but with a different semantic meaning as a property on portal/wikidata?

Thank you.

eloiferrer commented 6 days ago

I think it would be better to avoid using the label 'represented by' since this can create misunderstandings with the already existing property in Wikidata. I would suggest just creating one property called 'modeled by'. The same property pointing in the opposite direction (models) is redundant and should not be created. Would that work for you @OleksandrZadorozhnyiML?

Any other thing we should consider @Daniel-Mietchen? Otherwise I would go ahead and create the property.

OleksandrZadorozhnyiML commented 6 days ago

... Would that work for you @OleksandrZadorozhnyiML?

@eloiferrer Yes, I think it is good. Only one minor issue: I would suggest then to use "modelled by" (double "l", British English) instead of "modeled by"( one "l", US English) to keep it somehow consistent (I assume that items/names on portal/wikidata are in British English, however I am not sure).