Magickbase / visual-style-guide

0 stars 1 forks source link

Design a logo for project kuai #23

Closed Keith-CY closed 1 year ago

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

We're going to promote a project named kuai to the community and need an impressive logo for it.


Project kuai: https://github.com/ckb-js/kuai

Overview:

Kuai is an application development philosophy and all-in-one development framework designed specifically for Nervos CKB. It encompasses generic application development patterns, convenient development scaffolding, plug-and-play application architecture, and development manuals to facilitate development processes.

Design element from kuai project proposer

Kuai, the name of the project, comes from the following meanings

  1. speedy: this project facilitates the development of dapp on nervos ckb;
  2. chopsticks:
    1. this project is the best mate for developers on nervos ckb;
    2. developers make life (earn money) by using chopsticks;
  3. block: this project is for blockchain development.

Design style preference of kuai developers

For me, the text "Kuai", "Magickbase", the symbol of "blockchain", "tool set", "speed" should be included. And personally, I prefer a logo of characters on a block, or dice for random possibilities, or a badge for prints.

I prefer colorful logo

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

The following is the LOGO scheme:

image
Daryl-L commented 1 year ago

喜欢第四个

yanguoyu commented 1 year ago

I like the first's shadow design, but not like the word a's style. And the fourth is also good, but I think we can keep the top icon and remove the kuai word.

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

Actually, the second one can be interpreted as using chopsticks to manipulate cells/blocks, but it also reminds me of the kitchen, which may not be so cool as a technical framework.

However, the fashion word omakase can be derived from kitchen, this word is used to describe ruby on rails, which offers the best/opinioned choices to developers so they can focus themselves on business.

Ref:

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

The fourth one looks more coordinated, but lacks uniqueness

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

Ok, I will make adjustments as suggested

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

Adjusted design solution:

image
yanguoyu commented 1 year ago

vote 5

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

@Keith-CY Please select a suitable logo or adjust the comments.

Daryl-L commented 1 year ago

vote 5 too

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

@Keith-CY Please select a suitable logo or adjust the comments.

I also think logo 5 is more dynamic and impressive, but I cannot associate it with the concept of a development framework or toolkit that speeds up the development of a DApp.

As mentioned at https://github.com/Magickbase/visual-style-guide/issues/23#issue-1688041863

Kuai is an application development philosophy and all-in-one development framework designed specifically for Nervos CKB. It encompasses generic application development patterns, convenient development scaffolding, plug-and-play application architecture, and development manuals to facilitate development processes.

It would be great to tell users that kuai is about abstract philosophy and concrete framework/tools by the logo

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

@Keith-CY Please select a suitable logo or adjust the comments.

I also think logo 5 is more dynamic and impressive, but I cannot associate it with the concept of a development framework or toolkit that speeds up the development of a DApp.

As mentioned at #23 (comment)

Kuai is an application development philosophy and all-in-one development framework designed specifically for Nervos CKB. It encompasses generic application development patterns, convenient development scaffolding, plug-and-play application architecture, and development manuals to facilitate development processes.

It would be great to tell users that kuai is about abstract philosophy and concrete framework/tools by the logo

ok, I will adjust again

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

I think that representing specific frameworks/tools in a graphical form within the logo would make it complex and difficult to identify. Therefore, I have chosen to design the logo around the symbol "<>", which best represents development. @Keith-CY

image
Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

I think that representing specific frameworks/tools in a graphical form within the logo would make it complex and difficult to identify. Therefore, I have chosen to design the logo around the symbol "<>", which best represents development. @Keith-CY

image

image is impressive to me because it balances abstract(code <>) and concrete(tool box)

image is a bit similar to another project in CKB ecosystem, axon web3

Which one is your favorite among all above, including https://github.com/Magickbase/visual-style-guide/issues/23#issuecomment-1541471512

@Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu @zhengjianhui

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

I think that representing specific frameworks/tools in a graphical form within the logo would make it complex and difficult to identify. Therefore, I have chosen to design the logo around the symbol "<>", which best represents development. @Keith-CY

image

image is impressive to me because it balances abstract(code <>) and concrete(tool box)

image is a bit similar to another project in CKB ecosystem, axon web3

Which one is your favorite among all above, including #23 (comment)

@Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu @zhengjianhui

Which one would you prefer @Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu

yanguoyu commented 1 year ago

image I would prefer this.

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

image I would prefer this.

It's a bit similar to the axon team's logo at https://github.com/axonweb3 image

Daryl-L commented 1 year ago

I think that representing specific frameworks/tools in a graphical form within the logo would make it complex and difficult to identify. Therefore, I have chosen to design the logo around the symbol "<>", which best represents development. @Keith-CY

image

image is impressive to me because it balances abstract(code <>) and concrete(tool box) image is a bit similar to another project in CKB ecosystem, axon web3 Which one is your favorite among all above, including #23 (comment) @Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu @zhengjianhui

Which one would you prefer @Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu

I prefer the last one.

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

I think that representing specific frameworks/tools in a graphical form within the logo would make it complex and difficult to identify. Therefore, I have chosen to design the logo around the symbol "<>", which best represents development. @Keith-CY

image

image is impressive to me because it balances abstract(code <>) and concrete(tool box) image is a bit similar to another project in CKB ecosystem, axon web3 Which one is your favorite among all above, including #23 (comment) @Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu @zhengjianhui

Which one would you prefer @Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu

I prefer the last one.

Comes out that image image image are preferred by each one

Which one in the whole list(not only 3 above) do you pick @PainterPuppets

PainterPuppets commented 1 year ago

I think that representing specific frameworks/tools in a graphical form within the logo would make it complex and difficult to identify. Therefore, I have chosen to design the logo around the symbol "<>", which best represents development. @Keith-CY

image

image is impressive to me because it balances abstract(code <>) and concrete(tool box) image is a bit similar to another project in CKB ecosystem, axon web3 Which one is your favorite among all above, including #23 (comment) @Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu @zhengjianhui

Which one would you prefer @Daryl-L @PainterPuppets @yanguoyu

I prefer the last one.

Comes out that image image image are preferred by each one

Which one in the whole list(not only 3 above) do you pick @PainterPuppets

Feel great, the first and last style is a bit like Tencent hhhh, I prefer this purple

image
Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

Wow, diversity 🤔

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

We need to select a final logo for the subsequent official website design

Keith-CY commented 1 year ago

We need to select a final logo for the subsequent official website design

I would like to pick image as the final one with my project owner-privilege because each logo got 1 vote equally.

Kirl70 commented 1 year ago

Logo resource link https://www.figma.com/file/6XNoimRDbFTTNm016rbIdU/Magickbase?type=design&node-id=19918%3A41963&mode=design&t=6M6PPoIRoPNHeg80-1

image