MarcKletz / OMR-MeasureRecognition

7 stars 7 forks source link

"System measures" detection poor result quality #6

Open piegamesde opened 3 years ago

piegamesde commented 3 years ago

The detection generalizes rather poorly for guitar tabs, even when the score contains one staff with tabs and one staff with western notation. Some features are detected just fine, but the "measure"-wide detection often confounds which staff belongs to which system.

This is interesting, because tabs are pretty similar to music notation in a lot of ways, especially they share all the interesting features for detection (staff lines, staves, bars, systems). It is also interesting that https://github.com/OMR-Research/MeasureDetector had difficulties as well, and failed in a similar manner.

piegamesde commented 2 years ago

Here's the result of the evaluation of one of the pre-downloaded models for "system measures":

image

So this is likely a more general issue with that mode.