search

MariwanJ / Design456

An attempt to create Direct Modeling workbench for FreeCAD
GNU General Public License v3.0
49 stars 6 forks source link

Part Filet #16

Closed wagnerlip closed 3 years ago

wagnerlip commented 3 years ago

Create a cube 10x10x10mm, select one edge and filet 1mm, select a connected edge and filet 1mm, it end up with 3 fileted edges. It filet an extra edge without selecting it. This problem does not happen with Chanfers.

image

The same for Part Wedge image

In the following Part Prism, I just requested filets on bottom left, then bottom right, the vertical was produced without requesting, and it has narrow.

image

MariwanJ commented 3 years ago

I will look at it later. Thanks for reporting

MariwanJ commented 3 years ago

I tried the command on one edge of a cube, I couldn't reproduce the problem you have. Keep in mind that Fillet is dangours if you don't use it with caution you might ends up with invalid shape. Please would you try the fillet in the Part workbench? see if you can get the same issues. If the answer is YES, you should know that the issue is out of my control. Otherwise please update me. Thanks.

wagnerlip commented 3 years ago

A cube generated in PARTS workbench, same size (10mm), same filleting sequence and dimension (1mm), does not present such double filleting issue. I will keep testing.

The only problem (I know) about filleting in FreeCad is when the filleting curve will not fit in the face, like a brick with 3mm wall and trying to filleting with 3.5mm, the object disappears.

MariwanJ commented 3 years ago

Could you pleas look at the console and see what edge(s) are reported to get the fillet? You will see it . View->Panel->Python Console Please keep in mind that you need to update your local repo in daily basis as I am updating in the same manner. So you get an updated version.

MariwanJ commented 3 years ago

Fillet has many bugs. FreeCAD must fix them before anything I can do to it