search

MarkGotham / When-in-Rome

meta-corpus of and code library for the functional harmonic analysis of music
58 stars 12 forks source link

Haydn analysis corrections #45

Closed malcolmsailor closed 2 years ago

malcolmsailor commented 2 years ago

Some corrections to the Haydn analyses.

MarkGotham commented 2 years ago

Thanks! These seem to be errors in the analysis at source right? @napulen do you agree? Would you like to fix at source and re-convert?

malcolmsailor commented 2 years ago

These seem to be errors in the analysis at source right?

I believe so, yes

napulen commented 2 years ago

Corroborated a few of these, definitely errors on my end! Thanks, @malcolmsailor!

napulen commented 2 years ago

Given the always problematic treatment of /vi /bvii /#vi, etc. in translations. I suggest going with these changes as they are. I spotted wrong inversions already in other annotations around Malcolm's corrections. I'd prefer to re-analyze the set (I think the output by AugmentedNet will help to spot more errors) and follow a more strict convention for inversions/tonicizations.

MarkGotham commented 2 years ago

Ok, thanks @napulen .