MarkMindCkm / obsidian-enhancing-mindmap

obsidian plugin editable mindmap,you can edit mindmap on markdown file
MIT License
596 stars 51 forks source link

Numeric list support #132

Open ser-j opened 1 year ago

ser-j commented 1 year ago

Hi, thanks for the plugin development.

Have the document structured like this:

# Main node
## Second level node

1. Third level
2. Third level
     1. Forth level
     2. Forth level

## Another second level of node 
1. Third level
2. Third level
     1. Forth level
     2. Forth level
## And another second level of node
1. Third level
2. Third level
     1. Forth level
     2. Forth level

This document was just copied from other place and was NOT originally created from the plugin.

When I render this structure in plugin, I get everything right. But if add some node to whatever location in Mindmap mode, I got a wrong formatting in markup and next time I open a MIndmap mode it has empty Nodes prepending each node. This happens because after adding a Node(or after any editing of text of existing Node) the plugin prepends each Node with dash, instead of understanding that the list is numeric. This results in messing up the structure and, as a result, messing up next display of a such Mind map.

Simpler saying, after editing the Mindmap the structure becomes like that:

# Main node
## Second level node

- 1. Third level
- 2. Third level
     - 1. Forth level
     - 2. Forth level

## Another second level of node 
- 1. Third level
- 2. Third level
     - 1. Forth level
     - 2. Forth level
## And another second level of node
- 1. Third level
- 2. Third level
     - 1. Forth level
     - 2. Forth level

This results in getting empty Nodes prepending in each Node on MindMap, which are named by default: Sub title.

Is there a chance fix somehow? Either working with numeric lists(which is highly preferable since it is easier to reference Nodes) OR at least removing numeric formatting and replacing it with dashes accurately?

MarkMindCkm commented 1 year ago

now not support numer list

ser-j commented 1 year ago

are numeric lists supported in Obsidian-Markmind paid version? if no, will it be in nearest future?

does Obsidian-Enhancing-Mindmap or Obsidian-Markmind supports xmind import? The docs state that it is in Plan. I checked the codebase and it seems Obsidian-Enhancing-Mindmap has importXmind function but it is not available in Obsidian Commands. Please advice how to make the import of xmind format.

MarkMindCkm commented 1 year ago

Markmind rich mode support numer list.

Import xmind zen file:

Create a new mindmap , drag xmind zen file and drop to blank of mindmap

ser-j commented 1 year ago

Thanks for that answers.

It looks like Free version of Obsidian-Markmind doesn't support Numeric lists in rich mode. It is actually doesn't transform markdown with Numeric lists or any other lists to json form which Obsidian-Markmind(rich mode) can understand at all.

Question 1: How should I provide the markdown with Numeric lists, so Rich mode which works based on JSON understands it. Are you referencing a Paid version of Obsidian-Markmind for Numeric lists support?

Question 2 I checked the paid option and there are two of them there:

  1. yearly subscription and
  2. all time, but on your site it says it is just for version 1.0 only? or doest it mean current version(1.8)? or all version of 1.0+ once they are released? or is it life time updates for the product, please clearify?
  3. what exactly does paid version have that free doesn't? The differences between those which are enumerated in docs are not clear enough. Thanks.

Question 3 Is there in Obsidian-Enhancing-Mindmap or in Obsidian-Markmind option to make export in xmind format?

Question 4 Is there a chance to transform basic mind map(with plain markdown) into rich mode(json mode)? Changing in meta-data from basic to rich doesn't automatically transform markdown to json.

MarkMindCkm commented 1 year ago
  1. basic not support numeric lists

  2. Free Catalyst
    Basic mode of MindMap Advanced features in Rich mode of MindMap
    Most features in Rich mode of MindMap PDF annotate
    List mode Support development
    PC and Mobile support PC and Mobile support
    Not support Export mindmap as pdf file
    $0 $12 (forever) Buy here
  3. This feature is currently being studied, but it already supports exporting PDFs and images

  4. This feature is already supported, and basic and rich can be interchanged,in command board of markmind ctrl p