[BUG] Unable to build using both TMCStepper and U8glib

[Silverpumax]

Bug Description

If i using the libs TMCStepper and U8glib together the bulding process fails at linktime. Building with TMCStepper alone is Ok Building with U8glib alone is Ok

I tested this behaviour also with Arduino 1.9beta and eclipse arduino cdt For testing i set the Arduino path , the TMP path and the Marlin path short as possible to the route of the filesystem. I tested this behaviour also with the last branch bugfix.2.0x.

_By using a older bugfix.2.0x. with STRING_DISTRIBUTIONDATE "2019-08-08" and by using the new libs i can build and run the system with no problems !

My Configurations

The only change in Configuration.h and Configuration_adv.h

#define MOTHERBOARD BOARD_MKS_GEN_L 
#define X_DRIVER_TYPE  TMC5160 
#define MKS_MINI_12864
#define X_CS_PIN            59          

configuration.zip

Steps to Reproduce

Build with: Last branch: 2.0x or last branch bugfix.2.0x. Arduino: 1.8.11 (Windows 10), Board: "Arduino Mega or Mega 2560, ATmega2560 (Mega 2560)"

Actual behavior: Error at:

Linking everything together...
avr-gcc: error: CreateProcess: No such file or directory
Bibliothek U8glib in Version 1.19.1 im Ordner: C:\Users\Becker\Documents\Arduino\libraries\U8glib  wird verwendet
Bibliothek TMCStepper in Version 0.6.2 im Ordner: C:\Users\Becker\Documents\Arduino\libraries\TMCStepper  wird verwendet
Bibliothek SPI in Version 1.0 im Ordner: C:\Program Files wird verwendet
Bibliothek SoftwareSerial in Version 1.0 im Ordner: C:\Program Files wird verwendet
exit status 1
Fehler beim Kompilieren für das Board Arduino Mega or Mega 2560.

I notice also errors at compile time with no consequence to the build if i use the libs alone

Error while detecting libraries included by C:\Temp\arduino_build_763872\sketch\src\feature\tmc_util.cpp
Error while detecting libraries included by C:\Temp\arduino_build_763872\sketch\src\module\stepper\trinamic.cpp

Additional Information

ArduinoErrorOutput.zip

[ellensp]

The error is avr-gcc: error: CreateProcess: No such file or directory Your a windows user and your hitting the windows command line limit, You need to remove unused src/HAL directories and if not using it remove Marlin/src/lcd/extensible_ui

[Silverpumax]

Thanks for your answer. I found some issues for that but no conclusion. Evidently the toolchain must use sh.exe instead cmd.exe !??! But I haven't a clue.

Therefore my solution has been prove satisfactory. By installing Ubuntu Linux with Arduino in a Windows Hyper-V enviroment for the only benefit to build marlin.

[Protean-Man]

removing src/HAL does not compile. I agree that removing Marlin/src/lcd/extensible_ui does work.

Has anyone had any results on this compiling u8glib & tmc2130 together with boxed Marlin? Out of the box compiling is preferable to searching the internet for days to find that removing Marlin/src/lcd/extensible_ui is the only viable option.

[sjasonsmith]

Have you tried switching to Visual Studio code with Platform I/O? That doesn't have the same issue with command line length that Arduino has. I can build the posted configurations with no issue in VS Code.

[sjasonsmith]

removing src/HAL

You can't just remove all of src/HAL, you can only remove sub-folders that you do not need. Since you presumably build for AVR, you could remove all the HAL_* sub-folders except HAL_AVR.

[Protean-Man]

I have not used Visual Studio yet but will now. Thank you. So far it has been a Marlin issue in my head, it being a Arduino IDE problem is helpful.

[Silverpumax]

Yes i can remove HAL_* sub-folders except HAL_AVR and except HAL_DUE. But the problem maintains.

I'd like try switching to Platform I/O with eclipse....

Until now i build marlin with Arduino in a Ubuntu Linux which is installed in a Windows 10 Hyper-V environment.

[thinkyhead]

PlatformIO in Visual Studio Code with the Auto Build Marlin extension will be the recommended build method going forward. Configuration tools will be integrated into the ABM extension bit by bit.

[thinkyhead]

As pointed out, Arduino can't filter project files in the way that PlatformIO can. So to get Arduino IDE to complete the build, the solution is to delete the HAL sub-folders that you are not using. This is not something we can address without a big re-architecting of Marlin.

[github-actions[bot]]

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.