search

MarlinFirmware / Marlin

Marlin is an optimized firmware for RepRap 3D printers based on the Arduino platform. Many commercial 3D printers come with Marlin installed. Check with your vendor if you need source code for your specific machine.
https://marlinfw.org
GNU General Public License v3.0
16.28k stars 19.23k forks source link

GPL Violation #7856

Closed KangDroid closed 6 years ago

KangDroid commented 7 years ago

Hi, I would like to get help/support from Marlin developers, Since I bought CORE200 3D Printer from Korea(Made in Korea as well), I was able to sign up its forum.(Its all in Korean)

On October 3th,(GMT 9+), I was asking the forum moderator about : what is the firmware base, and moderator said, its "Marlin"-based. It basically means CORE200's firmware affected by GPL V3. Also, I have seen that moderator released its firmware by "hex", not source. So I was asking to release the source since I want to modify and improve itself.

First reply from moderator was: "Right now, I am not thinking about releasing code because I am keep editing, and If it gets more stable, then I will think about it." As I am also Opensource developer(AndroidDev) I also knew that if someone released its binary based on GPL V3 affected source, that someone, have to release its source code as well. So, I was linking GPL Site to moderator, and saying you need to open its source by user's request.(For released binary one.) and now, I bet the moderator is ignoring open-source request, even I sent him a private mail about this, and I bet he is keep ignoring.

I know its quite complicated and my English is really bad. Please understand it, and if there is more information needed, I will provide it as much as I can, AND, I would like to post a link about forum, OR a screenshot of its forum, but its forum is in all Korean, and basically, its private who didn't signed-up so the link would not work. I was thinking about report to http://gpl-violations.org ,but it would be right to report main author first. Thanks for reading long-way post.

Roxy-3D commented 7 years ago

Thank You for the information. If they are shipping the Marlin Firmware on the printers they are selling, they need to make to source (especially the Configuration.h and Configuration_adv.h files) available to the customers. They are legally required to do that.

Please send them the link to this thread. And in the mean time, we can probably help you regenerate the Configuration.h and Configuration_adv.h. file so you can use the very latest version of the firmware.

Assuming you are running a recent (in the last 6 months) version of Marlin, M503 will give you most of the Configuration.h settings. If you save the Boot Splash information and do the M503.... Probably you will have enough to reconstruct the Configuration.h file. At that point you will be free from the vendor and able to support your self.

KangDroid commented 7 years ago

Thanks for the clear-reply and some useful information about configuration!.

At this point right now, I am at long holiday so I couldn't test M503 since printers are in laboratory.

Anyway, Thanks in advanced.(Will contact you again if M503 is not working - can't sure whether its running a recent version of marlin.)

Roxy-3D commented 7 years ago

Just so you understand... The main options to setup the printer are in Configuration.h. If you get those setup correctly, the printer will pretty much work. But the fancier settings are in Configuration_adv.h. Probably, you don't need much to be changed in that file. Things like Z-BabyStepping and Double Clicking the encoder wheel to activate it are in that file. Anything in that file you can change over time to match your preferences.

KangDroid commented 7 years ago

Thanks for the info dev. I've been touching configuration.h for delta, prusa i3, but I never touched CoreXY type, I will try best as I can after the holiday is over.

Respectfully, KangDroid.

Tannoo commented 7 years ago

They are legally required to do that.

Umm.. doesn't that only apply to the U.S.A.?

coldtobi commented 7 years ago

Umm.. doesn't that only apply to the U.S.A.?

No.

TiGa-RCE commented 7 years ago

Same thing for the Anycubic i3 Mega. It uses the firmware but distributes it only in hex format. I created a new pins file for their board but I haven't been able to make the TFT screen work, I had to replace it with a cheap LCD.

chrisalbertson commented 6 years ago

Many companies are violating the GPL. It might be worth seeing what can be done. First explain it to them. Point out the terms they accepted.

I might simply be that these companies don't even know what "source code" is. They could be hired out the work and only have access to the binary files.

I don't know the simplest next step. Possibly work with ebay and Amazon to get their product off of those sites.

thinkyhead commented 6 years ago

I've never heard of a product getting pulled due to GPL violation, at least not without first getting sued. But I will look into it and see if there's something like the EFF that would back such a suit.

thinkyhead commented 6 years ago

Since the GPL is backed by copyright, anyone who has contributed code to Marlin has standing to file a DMCA infringement complaint with those who sell printers that are not GPL-compliant. For example, here is the infringement form you can download from GearBest: image

ghost commented 5 years ago

Any updates here other than the Creality release? I am now stuck here not able to add a bl touch or different extruder.

github-actions[bot] commented 4 years ago

This issue has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.