Dot and accid elements change xml:id

MeasuringPolyphony / mp_editor

https://editor.measuringpolyphony.org

5 stars 2 forks source link

Dot and accid elements change xml:id #70

Open martha-thomae opened 4 years ago

martha-thomae commented 4 years ago

When uploading a parts-MEI file, the @xml:id values of the <dot> elements are not preserved, they change when exporting either the parts or the score MEI files. Here is a file to test this.

33v-34r.mei.zip

martha-thomae commented 4 years ago

Same issue with <accid> elements

karend27 commented 3 years ago

Hi @martha-thomae - is this still an issue?

martha-thomae commented 3 years ago

Yes, this is still an issue. It also happens with the ids of other elements. Here is the complete list:

[ ] <surface>
[ ] <graphic>
[ ] <zone>
[ ] <pb>
[ ] <sb>
[ ] <accid>
[ ] <dot>
[ ] <ligature>
[ ] <barLine>
[ ] <verse>
[ ] <syl>

I put in bold letters the ones that are more important to preserve their ids.

martha-thomae commented 3 years ago

Another proposed solution is to go directly into the score editor when uploading a file coming from another application. (@JRegimbal will help me look into this :) )