MediaArea / MediaConch

MediaConch (funded by PREFORMA)
29 stars 11 forks source link

Policy check for video also running on embedded attachments #211

Closed aeschweik closed 6 years ago

aeschweik commented 6 years ago

I'm trying to embed sidecar digitization logs in FFV1/Matroska files (using mkvpropedit). When I run the resulting .mkv file through a local FFV1 policy check, the video file passes, but the attachments appear to be parsed out and run through the same policy check, which of course they fail since they're text files.

Is there any way to avoid running a policy check on Matroska attachments? It has been working great otherwise - thanks!

pass! /private/tmp/test32o4u254_ffv1.mkv
fail! attachment:/private/tmp/test32o4u254_ffv1.mkv:test32o4u254_capture_options.log
fail! attachment1:/private/tmp/test32o4u254_ffv1.mkv:test32o4u254_ffmpeg_decklink_input.log
fail! attachment2:/private/tmp/test32o4u254_ffv1.mkv:test32o4u254_ffv1.mkv.qctools.xml.gz
JeromeMartinez commented 6 years ago

Happy to see that the tool is useful. The behavior you are facing was not expected, and definitely not the right way, at least when it is not customable.

JeromeMartinez commented 6 years ago

We don't apply anymore policies to attachments, in snapshots and next official release.

aeschweik commented 6 years ago

Thanks!!