search

MediaArea / MediaConch

MediaConch (funded by PREFORMA)
29 stars 11 forks source link

Files fail in CLI but pass in GUI against same policy file #224

Open genfhk opened 3 years ago

genfhk commented 3 years ago

CLI: mediaconch -p /Users/pamiqc/ami-preservation/qc_utilities/MediaconchPolicies/MediaConch_NYPL-PAMI_videoAnalog_SC.xml /Users/pamiqc/Downloads/testAV/Video/463624/data/ServiceCopies/myh_463624_v01_sc.mp4 fail! /Users/pamiqc/Downloads/testAV/Video/463624/data/ServiceCopies/myh_463624_v01_sc.mp4 -- [fail:MediaConch_NYPL-PAMI_videoAnalog_SC] -- [fail:Video Codec should be H264] -- [fail:Video CodecID is H264] -- [fail:Video CodecID is AVC1] -- [fail:Format is MPEG-4] -- [fail:Format is AVC]

...but GUI output is all ✅

GUI XML report here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lCroUi0MWtzFFSjn022JkO-tA4JYphl9/view?usp=sharing Policy file here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1QnQw1CE6-QgKkYQzo1caEgPqAJpdKbi-/view?usp=sharing

genfhk commented 3 years ago

Oh and mt output here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1iQYK7NDhXoanobwivEW145z4x-njcavS/view?usp=sharing

g-maxime commented 3 years ago

I'm unable to reproduce this problem with a local file.

Can you share the output of mediaconch -mi -fx /Users/pamiqc/Downloads/testAV/Video/463624/data/ServiceCopies/myh_463624_v01_sc.mp4 ?

genfhk commented 3 years ago

@g-maxime testAV_mt_output.txt

g-maxime commented 3 years ago

@genfhk Sorry for the late reply.

The MediaInfo report is correct and pass the policy. Did you tried the --force option to tell mediaconch to re-parse the file ?

Is the policy failing with others outputs (e.g -ft or -fx ?)