MegaMek / megamek

MegaMek is a networked Java clone of BattleTech, a turn-based sci-fi boardgame for 2+ players. Fight using giant robots, tanks, and/or infantry on a hex-based map.
http://www.megamek.org
GNU General Public License v2.0
297 stars 287 forks source link

49.19 Direct Fire Flak Attacks not supposed to receive standard Flak modifiers #5329

Closed RaozSpaz closed 6 months ago

RaozSpaz commented 6 months ago

Environment

49.19 MegaMek Windows Java 11

Description

image Was reading various artillery rules for a question on another server and decided to read over the Flak rules on page 153 of the TO:AR. In the second paragraph when it begins to talk about the various modifiers applied to the attack. It states "Apply a +3 to hit modifier. Ignore the regular modifiers for using type "F" weapons or making a direct fire attack" Reading this section I don't think the -2 modifier from the Flak keyword should be applied to the attack.

ADAs specifically seem to state they use the rules for Standard Flak Attacks so I believe they are still supposed to receive the bonus.

Files

This can be replicated by adding various artillery and VTOLs to any random battle so no saves are really required.

Gribbly1 commented 6 months ago

Apply a +3 to-hit modifier. Ignore the regular modifier for making a direct-fire attack; the only other modifiers applied are for using Type “F” weapons, the firing unit’s movement and current damage, as well as woods/jungle, if any are intervening.

Which printing do you have?

RaozSpaz commented 6 months ago

Yeah. Its 4th edition. I failed to notice its an older version and the rule has since been erratad.