MegaMek / megameklab

MegaMekLab is a BattleTech unit modification program. It allows creating and modifying all unit types available in MegaMek from Support Vehicles up to WarShips. It also allows printing record sheets for single or multiple units.
http://www.megamek.org
86 stars 134 forks source link

Laser AMS THB version; numerical/calculational clarity & accuracy #1205

Closed HuntingTarg closed 1 year ago

HuntingTarg commented 1 year ago

Environment

MegaMekLab 49.10 Windows 10 Adoptium Java SDK Runtime Environment version 11.0.17.8

Description

Heat stat for the Tactical Handbook version of the Laser Anti-Missile System is inaccurate. The heat for the two different versions of the Laser AMS (Tactical Handbook and Maximum Tech) are calculated differently in the official boardgame rules ( IDK if it is calculated accurately in MegaMek during play). In any case the MegaMekLab 'Heat' stat should reflect this, however it does not: The highest probability result from rolling 2d6 (Maximum Tech rules) is 7 ; The highest probability result from rolling 3d6 (Tactical Handbook rules) is equal for 10 and 11 according to anydice.com , however the heat listed and calculated is 3 for the THB version. This should be amended in order to reflect the different rules applied to the different systems. Also of note that damage for the two systems (in terms of offensive combat damage) is N/A, because neither of these weapons can be used offensively with an Inner Sphere Tech Base.

Files

No log or bug report files provided; this is (ostensibly) a feature issue, not a functionality or compatibility issue, a design flaw, or a bug.

MML_AMS_Heat_RulesDiscrepancy

(screenshot capture highlighting added for easy readability)

HammerGS commented 1 year ago

Same reasoning as #1204