Reviewer1 tasks (not assigned to other issues) - Githubissues

MengLeZhang / crimeMaps-preReg-code

Code used in the protocol for the estimating the effect of crime maps project (https://osf.io/preprints/socarxiv/9zupw/)

0 stars 1 forks source link

Reviewer1 tasks (not assigned to other issues) #6

Closed MengLeZhang closed 2 years ago

MengLeZhang commented 2 years ago

These are the tasks that are not assigned to other issues (i.e. not simple proofing stuff)

Review one comments
- [x] I find the text a bit repetitive. Try to remove some ideas that are mentioned twice.
- [x] Page 16. In general, confounders are not properly defined. This is unclear.
- [x] Page 16. The definition of "I" and three types of "I" is unclear. How is this used later in the text?
- [ ] The bibliography list is not homgeneous.
- [x] The authors should mention how to cope with the risk of finding errors in the data, having solid data for such a project is not only related the presence of missing data. ~~- [ ] The quality of preparation of this manuscript should increase.~~ see #8

Other:

[x] add section for project status

MengLeZhang commented 2 years ago

Done everything before hols. Sent to other Co-authors to check. Need to sort out biblio style

MengLeZhang commented 2 years ago

Biblo issue in diff #10