MetroCS / redistricting

Experimentation with geopolitical redistricting
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
5 stars 75 forks source link

Images in redistricting program Issue #104 #108

Closed am10nxw closed 2 years ago

am10nxw commented 2 years ago

Created new NewFigure files with red and blue shaded differently so you could see the shade differences when printing on a monochromatic printer. Updated the NewRedistring.md file to point to the new image files. PXL_20211116_191100778

MXHJohn314 commented 2 years ago

All version1 pictures have much more distinct shades of grey than their previous versions. The only thing that concerns me is the redundancy of having the old pictures. I think the old pictures should be removed, and the new images should have the 1 removed from their names, directly replacing the old files. Is there any good reason to keep the old versions?

am10nxw commented 2 years ago

I just have a habit of keeping everything. If you want me to remove the old versions and use the same name I'm happy to make the changes.

jody commented 2 years ago

Is there any good reason to keep the old versions?

Not in this instance. I support using the version control process to update the image files rather than adding new files.

As a counter-example, the image changes made previously did warrant keeping the originals because there were significant changes that potentially conveyed meaning and there was known to be insufficient review prior to merging the changes. Thus we wanted the ability to easily look at both versions simultaneously.

am10nxw commented 2 years ago

When I view NewRedistricting.md locally on my machine the document doesn't find NewfigureA.png or NewfigureB.png. It does find NewfigureC.png, and NewfigureD.png. I figured out it was because there was a / in front of the link to the image on A and B. so I removed the / to view the document.

I realize that is not something this issue is supposed to address, so I removed making that change in this pull request.

jody commented 2 years ago

When I view NewRedistricting.md locally on my machine the document doesn't find NewfigureA.png or NewfigureB.png. It does find NewfigureC.png, and NewfigureD.png. I figured out it was because there was a / in front of the link to the image on A and B. so I removed the / to view the document.

Just need to track the changes. Please file a new issue (bug) for this, indicating how to replicate the error. Thank you!