search

Micalobia / Full-Slabs

Adds vertical and mixed slabs to Minecraft
GNU General Public License v3.0
8 stars 2 forks source link

Slabs don't let redstone signal pass through #44

Closed SplendidAlakey closed 2 years ago

SplendidAlakey commented 2 years ago

MC 1.17.1 Fabric API 0.40.1 FullSlabs 3.1.4

  1. Place a single slab vertically anywhere you want
  2. Put a button/lever/any other redstone activator on it
  3. Try to power something up

Expected result: power goes through

Actual result: power doesn't go through

Having 2 slabs together (even mixed ones) lets the signal pass through.

Will likely be a problem with horizontal slabs too when #15 is complete.

2021-10-08_15 46 53

Micalobia commented 2 years ago

This is actually a feature in Vanilla, putting a lever on a top slab doesn't power the slabs next to it, and the same with bottom slabs. This actually happens with stairs as well, and every non-opaque block in the game, despite being able to put levers and buttons on them.

TLDR; It's not an opaque block so it can't be powered in general, and it shares this property with stairs which feels even weirder.

SplendidAlakey commented 2 years ago

Oh, shame. I didn't think it was vanilla "feature" because I can't put levers on horizontal slabs at all.

Micalobia commented 2 years ago

Yeah, I agree with ya, feels a bit weird that it behaves like that. Patching it would be both way outside of the scope of this mod, and just generally break a lot of redstone, so it's generally just a bad idea even though it'd be neat.