Using hardcore mode will break cp ../../ with ohmyzsh directory aliases

[eigan]

Summary

This bug is encountered because of an alias built-in to oh-my-zsh. Using cp ... does not work.

How to reproduce

Test directory:

.
├── file
└── start
    └── level
        └── level

Configuration:

YSU_MODE=ALL
YSU_HARDCORE=1

Commands to execute

$ cd start/level/level

$ cp ../../../file.txt .
Found existing global alias for "../..". You should use: "..."
Found existing global alias for "../../..". You should use: "...."
You Should Use hardcore mode enabled. Use your aliases!

$  cp ..../file.txt .
cp: cannot stat '..../file.txt': No such file or directory

cp .../../file.txt .
Found existing global alias for "../..". You should use: "..."
You Should Use hardcore mode enabled. Use your aliases!

The aliases for "..." is defined here: https://github.com/robbyrussell/oh-my-zsh/blob/master/lib/directories.zsh

[MichaelAquilina]

I'm not entirely certain what the bug is from reading this bug report.

Could you give an example of expected behaviour and actual behaviour? I think the bug is that cp .../../file.txt should be suggested as ..../file.txt but I'm not entirely sure

[eigan]

Sorry, should have made it more clear. This plugin suggest to rewrite the command ( cp ../../../file.txt ) to something that does not work ( cp ..../file.txt . )

It correctly says that .... is an alias, but it cannot be used with cp (as seen in example: (cannot stat ..../file.txt etc))

This could be a bug with oh-my-zsh, I am not sure..

[MichaelAquilina]

ah. Why does .... exist as an alias if it doesn't work?

[eigan]

The aliases for "..." is defined here: https://github.com/robbyrussell/oh-my-zsh/blob/master/lib/directories.zsh

It is sourced here: https://github.com/robbyrussell/oh-my-zsh/blob/master/oh-my-zsh.sh#L31

The aliases are checked in _check_global_aliases().

This code on line 71:. if [[ "$1" = *"$v"* ]]; then will match any commands containing the alias defined. So the alias ...='../..' will match when I type cp ../../ and zsh-you-should-use will complain that I am not using this alias.

Note that whatever command I type which include ../.., zsh-you-should-use will complain:

$ ls ../../
Found existing global alias for "../..". You should use: "..."
You Should Use hardcore mode enabled. Use your aliases!

Edit, using ls ... actually works, so this was a bad example. But mv .../file.txt . does not.

I have solved it by doing this:

@@ -68,7 +68,7 @@ function _check_global_aliases() {
     # Need to remove leading and trailing ' if they exist
     v="${(Q)tokens[2]}"

-    if [[ "$1" = *"$v"* ]]; then
+    if [[ "$1" = "$v"* ]]; then
       ysu_global_message "$v" "$k"
       found=true
     fi

[eigan]

ah. Why does .... exist as an alias if it doesn't work?

It does work.

$ pwd
/home/einar/tmp/test
$ ....
$ pwd
/home

[eigan]

Oh,

$ ls ...

This command actually works. But cp .../file.txt, mv .../file.txt etc does not.

Edit: Sorry for all the spamming :|