Franzformator commented 6 years ago

Maybe that could be an integration project for the future: https://github.com/BaReinhard/Super-Simple-Raspberry-Pi-Audio-Receiver-Install

Having this functionality in the phoniebox we could use it such as a tigerbox (https://tiger.media/tigerbox/). The benefit is to easily stream music or radio plays from the mobile phone to the phoniebox. Especially on a trip that would be nice feature.

Drawback for now – currently it is not working on Stretch

MalteHST commented 6 years ago

If you are using the phatBEAT or phatDAC from pimoroni for this project, you can install easily Airplay to your Pi with a one-line installer of them. But this works only for Apple products. Nevertheless it allows streaming music and any other audio.

ekorn commented 6 years ago

There is a "strech-fix" branch but if you want to use A2DP Bluetooth Streaming to RPI you will probably have to turn of WiFi since one of the new features of SSPARI is "Ability to disable Wifi on Bluetooth Connection. Needs to be enabled, but solves choppy bluetooth playback if no external wifi card is available." Which is pretty much what I heard while streaming Audio via Bluetooth. So my hope would be a Airplay/Cromecast solution. But up to now I could not find a working opensource airplay client or a chromecast server for the rpi. There is the Raspicast App but there is the client part proprietary. So streaming Audio from my Android Phone to me rpi with open source technology is hard...

topas-rec commented 4 years ago

OK i also think a wireless audio receiver would be a nice addition to the Phoniebox.

I tested upmpdcli recently in a VM on Debian buster together with mpd ( which is used in the Phoniebox project) and the YAACC app on android.

That worked out of the box by :

installing mpd ( in VM)
installing upmpdcli ( in VM)
installing YAACC ( on android)
starting a/ the upnp server on my phone in the YAACC app
selecting music from the catalog of the server/ my phone and hit play

Pros for that solution:

works ( in a VM, but should also work on pi)
all participating projects are open source and under active development
A standard protocol is used (upnp/dlna) which should be supported on many platforms
is most likely easy to integrate into Phoniebox ( see commands above)
others use upnp/dlna, too (volumio, List of UPnP AV media servers and clients)
uses WiFi - no other hardware interface needed

Cons for that solution:

security (not sure, but it seems upnp has severe security issues - needs to be sorted out if they apply here)
no streaming of " all sound " ( like every possible app) possible, only files from the server ( which might be a smartphone, though)
no ad hoc connection, WiFi needs to be configured

What do you think?

topas-rec commented 4 years ago

Security for me seems to be not an issue here. As mentioned in the following discussion and security notice links the security of the protocol is not the reason for security issues but the software implementation and configuration of firewalls (routers) and devices behind the firewall and malicious software behind the firewall that exploits uPnP are the reasons for the security discussions.

https://security.stackexchange.com/questions/118918/is-upnp-still-insecure https://www.lesbonscomptes.com/upmpdcli/upmpdcli-manual.html

So far I think that if the Phoniebox is

in a local network behind a firewall to the internet
not infected by malware
and the router is configured to not accept uPnP port openings security is not an issue.

Any other opinions?

topas-rec commented 4 years ago

Another Bluetooth solution: https://sigmdel.ca/michel/ha/rpi/bluetooth_n_buster_01_en.html

I hope I can try this soon.

topas-rec commented 4 years ago

Another Bluetooth solution: https://sigmdel.ca/michel/ha/rpi/bluetooth_n_buster_01_en.html

I hope I can try this soon.

Tested and works. Needs to be automated which seems not straightforward.

topas-rec commented 4 years ago

Read a lot regarding this and I need to note it somewhere.

Another Bluetooth solution: https://sigmdel.ca/michel/ha/rpi/bluetooth_n_buster_01_en.html

I hope I can try this soon.

From this buster explanation to the mentioned older post (https://sigmdel.ca/michel/ha/rpi/bluetooth_02_en.html#streaming) which is based on stretch but includes the complete blueALSA usage description (which is an important part) there is an automated guide linked at the very bottom: https://gist.github.com/mill1000/74c7473ee3b4a5b13f6325e9994ff84c#initial-setup

That seems already a good solution for Phoniebox, because it holds an automated setup for a recently tested (on buster, see my comment before) bluetooth solution and has automated pairing, but there is something even better (see below)! Important note before: The automated solution here already uses the agent from the bluez test scripts. This agent is still maintained and originates from the simple agent. It might help us if we want a fixed PIN for pairing. I think this is not necessary. All noted here: https://stackoverflow.com/a/46690023

In the comments of the mentioned automated guide there is a link to an automated (and now: look at the issue title) Raspberry Pi Audio Receiver (https://github.com/nicokaiser/rpi-audio-receiver). Its description is:

A simple, light weight audio receiver with Bluetooth (A2DP), AirPlay, Spotify Connect and UPnP.

The description does not mention Snapcast which is also included and which I also wanted to include in the phoniebox. I think having snapcast in here too would be a nice addition. The good thing about the work done in this repo is its modular install script which we can tailor to our needs. This repo is also still maintained.

I want to try this and try to get a pull request done with this when it works.

topas-rec commented 3 years ago

There are recent news on https://github.com/BaReinhard/Super-Simple-Raspberry-Pi-Audio-Receiver-Install and I found a lot of forks that could also help.

Wanted to leave these information here for the record.

topas-rec commented 3 years ago

Another interesting hint in an issue https://github.com/BaReinhard/Super-Simple-Raspberry-Pi-Audio-Receiver-Install/issues/159#issuecomment-713588598 at https://github.com/BaReinhard/Super-Simple-Raspberry-Pi-Audio-Receiver-Install

topas-rec commented 3 years ago

Raspberry Pi Audio Receiver (https://github.com/nicokaiser/rpi-audio-receiver)

I tried it (bluetooth streaming only - but this thing includes more, see https://github.com/MiczFlor/RPi-Jukebox-RFID/issues/179#issuecomment-640039060) yesterday, together with an existing Phoniebox installation and that works great. I am really happy. 😀 I can hook up the box to my phone on holidays when my kids don't need it and so on 🎉. And we've already used it for listening to music while playing football with the kids using bluetooth, but always manually paired through SSH. Now pairing is easy and straightforward.

I would like to make some suggestions:

Reopen this issue (@Franzformator, @MiczFlor, @s-martin)
Lets make some tests on other Phonieboxes (@Franzformator?)
Lets add the possibility of adding a bluetooth receiver to the box by using Raspberry Pi Audio Receiver (https://github.com/nicokaiser/rpi-audio-receiver) to the readme (@topas-rec) as an optional installation step using the repos own installation script and mention this addition in the next milestones release notes (@MiczFlor, @s-martin?).
Lets make friends with @nicokaiser and mention him here and let him know the Phoniebox uses his repo (done)

Acknowledged?

topas-rec commented 2 years ago

Raspberry Pi Audio Receiver (https://github.com/nicokaiser/rpi-audio-receiver) still works with the Phoniebox current master branch, when the debian-10 branch of the Raspberry Pi Audio Receiver is used.

Attention: The installer of the Raspberry Pi Audio Receiver will upgrade all packages. One might to remove that line from the installer.

In case there is an error for a missing GPG key like this:

W: GPG error: https://apt.mopidy.com buster InRelease: The following signatures couldn't be verified because the public key is not available: NO_PUBKEY 78FD980E271D2943
E: The repository 'https://apt.mopidy.com buster InRelease' is not signed.
N: Updating from such a repository can't be done securely, and is therefore disabled by default.
N: See apt-secure(8) manpage for repository creation and user configuration details.

one can install the missing GPG key as mentioned in the install description of that repo.

After installation a reboot might be necessary.

s-martin commented 2 years ago

In case there is an error for a missing GPG key like this:
W: GPG error: https://apt.mopidy.com buster InRelease: The following signatures couldn't be verified because the public key is not available: NO_PUBKEY 78FD980E271D2943
E: The repository 'https://apt.mopidy.com buster InRelease' is not signed.
N: Updating from such a repository can't be done securely, and is therefore disabled by default.
N: See apt-secure(8) manpage for repository creation and user configuration details.
one can install the missing GPG key as mentioned in the install description of that repo.

After installation a reboot might be necessary.

1789 and #1792 fixed this at least on develop

s-martin commented 2 years ago

BTW @topas-rec, if you want you can open this issue yourself.

topas-rec commented 2 years ago

A wiki page regarding this topic was created. See Making Phoniebox a Bluetooth Receiver

MiczFlor / RPi-Jukebox-RFID

Wireless Audio Receiver #179

1789 and #1792 fixed this at least on develop