search

MinestrapTeam / Minestrappolation-2

Minestrappolation - a complete Vanilla Minecraft overhaul!
http://minestrappolation.wikia.com
5 stars 3 forks source link

Modified food and ore smelting recipes don't display in NEI. #328

Closed medsal15 closed 9 years ago

Delocuro commented 9 years ago

Any chance you could tell me exactly which ores/foods have this problem? I know it can't be all of them, since I was just playing 3.3.0 yesterday, and I could cook Potatoes and Coldstone Iron Ore just fine...

Delocuro commented 9 years ago

Closed, since I seem to be able to cook every single ore and food item just fine. Could have been an incompatibility with another mod...

medsal15 commented 9 years ago

It doesn't cook even without any mod!

medsal15 commented 9 years ago

@Delocuro: Reopen this issue now! I have screenshots: 2014-09-21_09 38 15 2014-09-21_09 38 19 2014-09-21_09 38 24 2014-09-21_09 38 30 2014-09-21_09 38 33 2014-09-21_09 38 38 2014-09-21_09 38 41 2014-09-21_09 38 49 2014-09-21_09 38 52 2014-09-21_09 38 55 2014-09-21_09 38 59

Don't tell me it's supposed to happen!

Delocuro commented 9 years ago

Ohh, okay, so the issue isn't that they don't smelt, but that it doesn't display right in NEI. I'll re-open it, but this is a bit lower priority, since it still technically displays the recipes, even if they are glitchy looking.

medsal15 commented 9 years ago

The smelting recipies don't even work without NEI!

Delocuro commented 9 years ago

Really? Well in that case, unless you can find any recorded errors in the Forge log, I'm not sure that there's much we can do to fix that. I've tested just about every Food and Ore smelting recipe in the 3.3.1.1 release, and they all work flawlessly. Without being able to re-create the problem, we can't figure out what's causing it, and thus have no way of solving it...

If you can't find any errors in the Forge log files, try just re-installing everything (including Forge) and see if that fixes it. Other than that, I'm not sure that there's anything else we can do to fix that.

NullMagic commented 9 years ago

As far as I can tell this is actually an error with the Clashsoft Lib, it took me a while to track it down, but it appears to be doing SOMETHING to ores and a few other items (I'm not at all sure what) that's causing them to no longer smelt at all, instead creating a few items with the "No image icon" and a -1 item ID that replace the functionality of things such as Iron Ore and Apples, this unfortunately caused me to remove Minestrappolation from my own build because it requires the Brewing API (which I was also sad to see go since I liked stacking potions) which requires the ClashSoft lib.

NullMagic commented 9 years ago

(sorry for the double post, it won't let me edit the above post)

Edit: Reading the above, I'm not sure it was clear... Iron Ore (this is what I tested with) no longer appears to be registering as Iron Ore in the Ore Dictionary. Thus only mods with hardcoded compatibility (i.e. if item with ID 15 is put in do x) are capable of using it, this does not include base minecraft. Simply having ClashSoft Lib in my mods folder (Without any mod that requires it) causes Iron Ore to become completely unusable without the use of a Railcraft Rock Crusher or a Metallurgy Crusher, both of which require Iron to make, as far as I can tell nothing else will interact with it, not even vanilla furnaces.

However, at the Same Time items will appear in chests with the "NoImage" image, and an ID of -1, that have names such as Apple and Stone Axe, etc. The apples work just fine, but attempting to use the axe will crash your game. Similarly if you use NEI to search recipes to make Iron Ingots, the only Iron Ore it shows capable of doing that has a Missing Image texture and an ID of -1, the regular Iron Ore, with an ID of 15, does not function in this capacity.

Clashsoft commented 9 years ago

I am sorry for any inconveniences caused by Clashsoft Lib. I will fix the issues as soon as I can. However, it will take at least 2 days because of real life reasons.

NullMagic commented 9 years ago

it's alright, take you're time. Real Life Before In Game, as the saying goes. I also totally just figured out how to get to your git Hub, would you like me to post something there? Anyway, thanks for the speedy response, looking forward to when it's all Ironed out and I can add all this stuff back.

Clashsoft commented 9 years ago

Which Forge version are you using?

NullMagic commented 9 years ago

I personally am using 10.0.13.0.1208

sorry for the late post, I got distracted and forgot to check in.

NullMagic commented 9 years ago

I just checked using the latest version of forge (.1219) and the same problem occurs, Iron Ore can't be smelted, and when you look for the recipe in NEI it shows a purple and black checkered square with the name Iron Ore -1 (the -1 being the item ID) which it shows as being oreIron in the ore dictionary, gold ore also behaves this way. A few other items also appear to have Ore Dictionary duplicates with the -1 item ID however they seem to work just fine in any recipe that originally called for them.