search

MinkhantEain / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Undocumented functionality in remark #7

Open MinkhantEain opened 1 week ago

MinkhantEain commented 1 week ago

For example, i find Irfan: find n/Irfan which shows:

image.png

Then, I wanted the change the first Irfan to be more handsome than second, remark 1 r/handsomer. After keying in the command and entering,

image.png It shows me the whole contact list. Not stated in the User Guide. It can cause inconvenience when I also want to change the other Irfan as well, having to find him again.

nus-pe-bot commented 4 days ago

Team's Response

Thank you for your response. However, after review, we still believe that this is an invalid bug. When you want to edit someone's info, we provide the find command to help you locate the contact quickly. So after editing, we show you the whole contact list for the convenience of further actions. It would be rare if you want to find contacts with same name and remark all of them as handsome and handsomer. In this case, just find them again.

As such, we do not agree that this is a bug, and we also believe that the bug type is wrong.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue response

Team chose [response.NotInScope]

Reason for disagreement: What if i want to change the remark of David Li and not Roy? I can find both my find n/roy li image.png

Since it is not documented, user may not know and the documentation does not state that it will show all the contacts like edit did in your user guide. And it is unlikely that it might happen again after first occurance, hence I place it as low severity.