Closed bryangeorges closed 1 month ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก No key issues to review |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Compliance |
Address and communicate the legal and regulatory aspects of NFT sales in the proposal___ **Given the project's scale and the involvement of non-crypto natives, it's crucial toensure that all legal and regulatory aspects of NFT sales are clearly addressed and communicated in the proposal. This includes any potential tax implications or regulatory compliance that needs to be considered.** [applications/iindy_fka-twigs_sothebys [71]](https://github.com/Mintbase/Grants-Program/pull/148/files#diff-b005eb30138763cff204843c7d8335c3cb26b2bafc65fcca2772ce1f4640a103R71-R71) ```diff -For Brands and Musicians, we provide them a customer friendly way for them to use digital collectibles to earn new revenue and offer rewards to their most loyal fans. +For Brands and Musicians, we provide them a customer-friendly way to use digital collectibles to earn new revenue and offer rewards to their most loyal fans. We ensure compliance with all relevant legal and regulatory requirements, including tax implications and consumer protection laws, which are clearly communicated to our users. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Ensuring compliance with legal and regulatory requirements is crucial for the project's legitimacy and user trust. This suggestion addresses a critical aspect that could prevent potential legal issues and enhance transparency. | 9 |
Enhancement |
Add a detailed description of the security measures in the "one tap" wallet creation process___ **Consider adding a more detailed description of the "one tap" wallet creation processto clarify how it handles security concerns, especially since a significant portion of the target audience are non-crypto natives. This will help in building trust and understanding among potential users who might be skeptical about the security of web3 technologies.** [applications/iindy_fka-twigs_sothebys [24]](https://github.com/Mintbase/Grants-Program/pull/148/files#diff-b005eb30138763cff204843c7d8335c3cb26b2bafc65fcca2772ce1f4640a103R24-R24) ```diff -Given over 90% of viewers will be non-crypto natives, we propose to enable fans to purchase and claim NFTs using a passwordless **one tap** wallet creation and digital asset minting via instant messaging apps (e.g. WhatsApp). +Given over 90% of viewers will be non-crypto natives, we propose to enable fans to purchase and claim NFTs using a passwordless **one tap** wallet creation and digital asset minting via instant messaging apps (e.g. WhatsApp). This process includes multiple layers of security checks to ensure user data protection and fraud prevention, which are crucial for building trust with non-crypto native users. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion addresses a significant concern for non-crypto native users by adding details about security measures, which can build trust and improve user adoption. It is a valuable enhancement for the proposal. | 8 |
Reliability |
Implement a fallback payment method to enhance the robustness of the purchasing process___ **It would be beneficial to include a fallback or alternative payment method for userswho might face issues with the primary payment gateway. This ensures that the purchasing process is robust and can handle potential downtimes or failures, thereby improving user experience and trust.** [applications/iindy_fka-twigs_sothebys [182]](https://github.com/Mintbase/Grants-Program/pull/148/files#diff-b005eb30138763cff204843c7d8335c3cb26b2bafc65fcca2772ce1f4640a103R182-R182) ```diff -Integrate Stripe payment gateway with iiNDY backend +Integrate Stripe payment gateway with iiNDY backend and implement a secondary payment method (e.g., PayPal) to provide an alternative in case of Stripe downtime or failures, ensuring continuous transaction capability. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding a secondary payment method increases the reliability of the purchasing process, ensuring continuous transaction capability even if the primary gateway fails. This improves user experience and trust. | 7 |
Feature enhancement |
Add a feature for trading or exchanging NFTs directly on the platform___ **To further enhance the project's appeal and utility, consider integrating a featurethat allows NFT owners to trade or exchange their collectibles directly within the platform. This could potentially increase user engagement and provide additional value to the collectibles.** [applications/iindy_fka-twigs_sothebys [72]](https://github.com/Mintbase/Grants-Program/pull/148/files#diff-b005eb30138763cff204843c7d8335c3cb26b2bafc65fcca2772ce1f4640a103R72-R72) ```diff -For fans who are interested in purchasing/owning limited collectibles , we offer them a simple way to purchase them and benefit from the utility/rewards it unlocks. +For fans who are interested in purchasing/owning limited collectibles, we offer them a simple way to purchase them and benefit from the utility/rewards it unlocks. Additionally, we will implement a feature allowing users to trade or exchange their collectibles directly on the platform, enhancing their value and engagement. ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: While this feature could enhance user engagement and add value to the collectibles, it is not critical for the initial proposal. It is a good enhancement but not essential at this stage. | 6 |
User description
Project Abstract
For which grant level are you applying?
Application Checklist
project_name.md
) and updated.How Did You Hear About our grants program?
PR Type
Documentation, Enhancement
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
iindy_fka-twigs_sothebys
Added project proposal for iiNDY x FKA Twigs x Sothebys collaboration
applications/iindy_fka-twigs_sothebys
Sothebys EUSEXUA Livestream Collection.
future plans.