Closed rubenmarcus closed 3 months ago
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Key issues to review Code Duplication The logic for setting up the `baseModuleWallet` and `moduleWallet` is repeated in two different sections of the code (lines 80-91 and 106-110). Consider refactoring this to a single function to avoid duplication and improve maintainability. Error Handling There is no error handling for the asynchronous operations within `setupMintbaseWalletSelector`. Consider adding try-catch blocks or error handling callbacks to manage exceptions and provide feedback. |
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible bug |
Correct the logic to set the appropriate URL for failure cases___ **Ensure that thefailureUrl is correctly set to a failure-specific URL or handle appropriately, as currently it mistakenly uses successUrl .**
[packages/react/src/wallet/wallet.ts [90]](https://github.com/Mintbase/mintbase-js/pull/529/files#diff-ef93d4fc45125c35c15776fe7de2174ee8dd53a8392140f750680a68c2ed958cR90-R90)
```diff
-failureUrl: successUrl || window.location.href,
+failureUrl: failureUrl || window.location.href,
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 10Why: This suggestion addresses a potential bug by ensuring that the `failureUrl` is correctly set, which is crucial for handling failure cases appropriately. | 10 |
Maintainability |
Reduce redundancy by using a single variable for repeated logic___ **Replace the repeated use ofsuccessUrl || window.location.href with a single variable to avoid redundancy and potential errors if the logic changes in the future.** [packages/react/src/wallet/wallet.ts [89-90]](https://github.com/Mintbase/mintbase-js/pull/529/files#diff-ef93d4fc45125c35c15776fe7de2174ee8dd53a8392140f750680a68c2ed958cR89-R90) ```diff -successUrl: successUrl || window.location.href, -failureUrl: successUrl || window.location.href, +const resolvedUrl = successUrl || window.location.href; +successUrl: resolvedUrl, +failureUrl: resolvedUrl, ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion reduces redundancy and potential errors by consolidating repeated logic into a single variable, which enhances maintainability and readability. | 8 |
Best practice |
Improve code clarity and reduce redundancy by using parameter destructuring___ **Consider using destructuring forwalletUrls and callbackUrl from the options object directly in the function parameters to improve code clarity and reduce redundancy.** [packages/react/src/wallet/wallet.ts [81-82]](https://github.com/Mintbase/mintbase-js/pull/529/files#diff-ef93d4fc45125c35c15776fe7de2174ee8dd53a8392140f750680a68c2ed958cR81-R82) ```diff -walletUrl: walletUrls[network], -callbackUrl: callbackUrl, +const setupMintbaseWalletSelector = async ({ walletUrls, callbackUrl, ...otherParams }: SetupOptions) => { + const baseModuleWallet = { + walletUrl: walletUrls[network], + callbackUrl: callbackUrl, + ... + }; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Using parameter destructuring can improve code clarity and reduce redundancy, although it is more of a best practice than a critical change. | 7 |
Use descriptive variable names to enhance code readability___ **Use a more descriptive variable name thanbaseModuleWallet to reflect that it contains URL and contract configurations.** [packages/react/src/wallet/wallet.ts [80-84]](https://github.com/Mintbase/mintbase-js/pull/529/files#diff-ef93d4fc45125c35c15776fe7de2174ee8dd53a8392140f750680a68c2ed958cR80-R84) ```diff -const baseModuleWallet = { +const walletConfig = { walletUrl: walletUrls[network], callbackUrl: callbackUrl, contractId: contractAddress, }; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: While using more descriptive variable names can enhance readability, the current name is not misleading, so this suggestion is more about improving best practices. | 6 |
PR Type
Enhancement
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
wallet.ts
Add Bitte Wallet support and refactor wallet setup
packages/react/src/wallet/wallet.ts