Stations listed twice

[sergip76]

Some bike systems like Citibike in New York lists each station twice. I'm using the listed url: https://gbfs.lyft.com/gbfs/1.1/bkn/en/station_information.json

[richfab]

Hello Sergi! Thank you for raising this data quality issue.

I have informed Lyft of this issue.

Please note that the open source online GBFS validator will soon allow producers to identify the case that you mentioned. With the PR #106, the validator will raise an error when station_information.json or station_status.json contain duplicate station_id.

Thank you for your contribution!

[mplsmitch]

@richfab I've noticed when you have a big system like Citibike or Divvy with low data quality there are so many errors that the validator fails because the response is too large: https://gbfs-validator.mobilitydata.org/validator?url=https%3A%2F%2Fgbfs.divvybikes.com%2Fgbfs%2Fgbfs.json Returns: { "errorMessage": "Response payload size exceeded maximum allowed payload size (6291556 bytes).", "errorType": "Function.ResponseSizeTooLarge" }

[richfab]

Hi @mplsmitch! Thank you for flagging this issue.

A response payload size exceeded issue is open on the GBFS validator repo: https://github.com/MobilityData/gbfs-validator/issues/109.

I hope this issue can be resolved shortly. Thank you!

[merjakaj]

@richfab When looking at the data for Citi Bike from NYC, it looks like the duplicate stations started to appear from August 4. Hopefully this will help troubleshooting this situation.

[ArashMansouri]

Thanks for flagging this issue. The problem with the stations appearing twice on the citibike feed has now been resolved.

[richfab]

I confirm that there is no longer any duplicate station in https://gbfs.lyft.com/gbfs/1.1/bkn/en/station_information.json. Thank you @ArashMansouri for resolving this issue so quickly.