search

Monika-After-Story / MonikaModDev

DDLC fan mod to extend Monika
http://www.monikaafterstory.com/
Other
1.19k stars 685 forks source link

[Suggestion] - 2D Platforming game. #3833

Closed Gamerboygaming closed 5 years ago

Gamerboygaming commented 5 years ago

Ok. It would be cool to see some kind of 2D platformer featuring Monika. It could be a representation of Monika's realization about how she's trapped in a game. The end goal would be to hug MC. Or something like that. I think it would be cool.

Rai99 commented 5 years ago

First off, I don't think we want to reinforce how Monika is trapped in a game.

Secondly, a lot of people really hate MC, so it's really best not to do anything with MC.

I'm not sure if this would really fit since it's not really a game both you and Monika can play. The levels would have to be created as well, and I personally think that effort could be put towards other things.

Gamerboygaming commented 5 years ago

Alright. Thanks anyways.

AsuraShun commented 5 years ago

Of course everyone hates him, he's a dense idiot who had plenty of opportunities to save the others

CrocWorks commented 5 years ago

If we hate the MC, why not make a 2D fighting game and have Player 1 beat MC up instead?

AsuraShun commented 5 years ago

Ye, a rockem sockem thingamajig

Rai99 commented 5 years ago

Don't know about anyone else, but I'd rather not have to touch MC.

bittercaramel commented 5 years ago

well id say that i dont get this hate on mc... literally he is nothing more but representation of us, he cant do anything on his own so saying that he had plenty opportunities to save the others doesnt make sense

AsuraShun commented 5 years ago

'' Don't know about anyone else, but I'd rather not have to touch MC'' Or he'll make you as dense as he is

Rai99 commented 5 years ago

I think the point is that he's not us, and I'd imagine people hate that he's used in place of us.

I think it's like watching someone else take something you love, for no reason really, MC definitely doesn't deserve more than the player, he didn't do anything special that we didn't do, so naturally, I think he just steals the spotlight right in front of you.

Either that, or it must just be one of those things everyone in a fandom hates. I mean hey, personally, I'd rather the hate go on him than Monika.

bittercaramel commented 5 years ago

well maybe i just treat this whole MC thing the other way.... i kinda agree with ya but you are saying this like MC has his own mind character and stuff for me mc was only a placeholder, how can he steal the spotlight if he is nothing more than your persona in the game

CloakedGhost commented 5 years ago

well maybe i just treat this whole MC thing the other way.... i kinda agree with ya but you are saying this like MC has his own mind character and stuff for me mc was only a placeholder, how can he steal the spotlight if he is nothing more than your persona in the game

He does have his own mind, hobbies, interests etc. so I personally won't accept him as some sort of replacement or persona when he's not like me at all. Yes he's basically mindless since act 3, but that doesn't change the fact that his intended characteristics and his looks are different from mine.

AsuraShun commented 5 years ago

Everything I said was story wise

AsuraShun commented 5 years ago

Including the joke

mosquitoe commented 5 years ago

Of course everyone hates him, he's a dense idiot who had plenty of opportunities to save the others

Could you point out more than one opportunity? All MC did was not to care. Yep, he's an asshole for not caring about his depressed best friend/girlfriend, but he only had one opportunity to save Sayori. Besides by not saving her, he made things easier for Monika. About Yuri. An insane knife-wielding big lady is in front of you, and you think she's probably going to stab you. How would you save her? About Natsuki. There was nothing MC could do about her. Monika would delete her anyway.

People who non-sensibly push all the blame to MC is one of the reasons why anti-Monikans think Monikans are rabid and don't take them seriously. The existence of these kinds of people make it more unlikely for people who don't like Monika to change their minds.

AsuraShun commented 5 years ago

When he saw sayori crying those times, when she ran away crying, visiting her before she killed herself, grabbing yuri's arm and knife before she killed herself and dealing with the bastard of a father natsuki has

bittercaramel commented 5 years ago

just wanted to point out a little thing how could he know she was going to kill herself? he isnt some sort of god to know everything, maybe he didnt visit her because he just didnt want... probably if he knew what was going to happen to her he would visit her grabbing yuris arm? i dont think thats realistic he probably was confused, scared and shocked try to imagine it, someone suddenly pulls out knife u would probs run away because u would think that the person wants to kill ya did he know who was natsukis father? even if he did... how can he deal with him? hes just one of random ppl from college, its not like he is some authority and he will go to her dad and say "stop" and he will stop ... rather natsuki would be in even worse position cuz he would be mad at her for telling others and stuff and last important thing sayori yuri and natsuki werent real :v and whole situation was done so monika could be with us what if monika manipulated MC too? after all he is also a bunch of code that apparently monika can change

mosquitoe commented 5 years ago

These people just take out any excuse they can find to scapegoat MC, trying to take off all the blame for Monika that way. As I said, this is the rabid side of Monikans, and is one of the reasons people don't take us seriously when we actually put in some effort to do some research instead of finding out excuses to shift the blame towards someone else.

mosquitoe commented 5 years ago

And to rant on it

When he saw sayori crying those times

He hugged her when she did cried. What more can you expect him to do?

when she ran away crying

If she ran away, she probably doesn't want to be with him.

visiting her before she killed herself

This is the only valid one, and I asked for reasons except this.

grabbing yuri's arm and knife before she killed herself

"About Yuri. An insane knife-wielding big lady is in front of you, and you think she's probably going to stab you. How would you save her?"

dealing with the bastard of a father natsuki has

No except Monika knows about her family situation.

Like I said, these are just baseless accusations used as an excuse to scapegoat MC and remove all the blame from Monika. And these kind of people bring down Monikans' credibility.

ZeDocktor commented 5 years ago

Going to say this right now, this got really off topic.

ThePotatoGuy commented 5 years ago

[closing until we look into it]