Monika-After-Story / MonikaModDev

DDLC fan mod to extend Monika
http://www.monikaafterstory.com/
Other
1.18k stars 685 forks source link

{suggestion} Android but not android? #6834

Closed jack-ship-it closed 3 years ago

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

So I know it is against the rules to make a DDLC APK but we don't need one for use on android an EXE can work instead We can do this because there is an app for exactly that Joiplay with renpy works great and normally works without issue so why not use that?

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

Screenshot_20201226-030929970 2 Screenshot_20201226-174800217 1

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

As seen here it can work with the game just fine

fromulus commented 3 years ago

If I understand correctly how Joiplay works, we'd still need the base DDLC game files on there as a pre-requisite to even make the mod function. That's where we have a problem, because we're not allowed to distribute DDLC in any way, shape or form, nor should we redirect the players towards a version of the game files that might have been uploaded on Joiplay illegally by someone not affiliated with Team Salvato.

On a technical standpoint, it probably would work, but it would still go against the official IP guidelines.

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

But it can still be assembled the same as a modded version

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

so the regular ddlc is the same and just need an adjusted bit of code from the definition script if I'm correct

fromulus commented 3 years ago

No, we need the actual, original DDLC game and all its files as a hard requirement for files added by MAS (or any mod ever) to work.

Distributing the DDLC files anywhere without Team Salvato's permission is illegal, same for making a slightly modified DDLC and distributing it just so that we can then mod it with MAS.

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

It's not the base game that is the problem, it's the definition. It can still be using the base game just needs the mod files changed

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

As seen in the images above regular base games modified by the mod files

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

Screenshot_20201227-101853653

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

Exit music Just the regular mod

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

Also, MAS already modifies that file otherwise half of the stuff MAS has in it already wouldn't function

multimokia commented 3 years ago

As of right now, we have no plans to transfer MAS flat over to Mobile. Even with the ability to port mods to mobile now, we still have no plans to do so.

Reasons as to why are because of the lack of ability to properly interact with the file system and persistents, as these are all locked to within the apk file itself.

If MAS were to move over officially, we'd also not make it the exact same experience as it is on desktop, however, an expansion to the taking you somewhere farewell.

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

Yes but it isn't an APK it's the exact same format as the regular version it runs off an exe or .sh/.py

multimokia commented 3 years ago

Yes, however, we at the moment have no plans to shift to mobile, even if not using an apk. We still need to further evaluate how we intend to do so, and if the solution will give us the flexibility we need, along with running well enough.

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

Yeah, this was mostly a suggestion

ThePotatoGuy commented 3 years ago

use suggestion tag if its a suggestion

jack-ship-it commented 3 years ago

Sorry