ES8388 - AiThinker - broken

[netmindz]

What happened?

I'm getting silence. Another user is only capturing from mic.

I'm getting no audio passthru

To Reproduce Bug

Linein on AiThinker v2.2

Expected Behavior

Line-in

Install Method

From MoonModules Release Page

What version/release of MM WLED?

B25

Which microcontroller/board are you seeing the problem on?

ESP32

Relevant log/trace output

No response

Anything else?

No response

Code of Conduct

• [X] I agree to follow this project's Code of Conduct

[netmindz]

https://github.com/MoonModules/WLED/pull/48

[softhack007]

@netmindz I think we can close this now?

[netmindz]

Let me just double check with this board as well as the LyraT

[netmindz]

Just checked and no error, but silence and no passthru, need to double check the config is right

[netmindz]

PIN Manager: wire.begin successfull! I2C bus is active. SDA=33 SCL=32. Starting display (I2C HW). AR: ES8388 Source (Line-In) ES8388Source:: initialize(); AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x8, val 0x0). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x2, val 0xF3). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x2B, val 0x80). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x0, val 0x5). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0xD, val 0x2). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x1, val 0x40). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x3, val 0x0). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x4, val 0xFC). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x2, val 0x40). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0xA, val 0x50). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x9, val 0x0). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x10, val 0x40). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x11, val 0x40). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x26, val 0x9). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x27, val 0x50). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x2A, val 0x50). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x2E, val 0x1B). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x2F, val 0x1E). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x30, val 0x1E). AR: ES8388 I2C write failed with error=2 (addr=0x10, reg 0x31, val 0x1E). I2SSource:: initialize().

[softhack007]

Starting display (I2C HW).

This one comes from four line display. It should not cause any problem, but you could check if disabling the usemod makes a difference.

[softhack007]

I2C write failed with error=2

i2c error 2 is NACK when sending the address - either the Es8388 address (0x10) is wrong, or the I2C pins ( SDA=33 SCL=32) are wrong/swapped.

[softhack007]

i2c error 2 is NACK when sending the address - either the Es8388 address (0x10) is wrong, or the I2C pins ( SDA=33 SCL=32) are wrong/swapped.

@netmindz: your I2C config seems to be correct, at least according to information I found here: https://www.pschatzmann.ch/home/2021/12/06/the-ai-thinker-audio-kit-experience-or-nothing-is-right/

So maybe its really some interference with four-line-display drivers. un-checking "enabled" in the fourline-display usermod setting, then reboot, might help.

[netmindz]

If the initialisation fails, we need that to be showing on the info page, not just silence

[softhack007]

If the initialisation fails, we need that to be showing on the info page, not just silence

good point, I'll add a message tomorrow. I'll also check if a "frozen" message (discussed some month ago) can be added easily.

[netmindz]

I just tried the alternative pin combo for I2C on some boards and I get

AR: ES8388 Source (Line-In) ES8388Source:: initialize(); PIN Manager: wire.begin successfull! I2C bus is active. SDA=18 SCL=23. I2SSource:: initialize(). AR: I2S#0 driver without aPLL; fixed_mclk=0. AR: 32 bits, Sample scaling factor = 1.0000 AR: I2S#0 driver installed in MASTER mode. AR: FFT task started on core 0 [prio=1, min free stack=|| loopTask min free stack 4360 AR: sound input driver initialized successfully.

But still then silence and still no audio passthru

[netmindz]

Might be useful

https://github.com/muvox-io/euphonium/blob/e26ee70af16602ae4bed48d94aca14974b988a19/euphonium/scripts/esp32/dacs/es8388_driver.be

[softhack007]

I just tried the alternative pin combo for I2C on some boards and I get But still then silence and still no audio passthru

Looks like a step forward - no i2c errors means that AR could talk to the chip 👍

[netmindz]

I'm annoyed i never took a screenshot of the setting when I had my board working, the notes on the docs are from @troyhacks and this board is notorious for having 3 variants

[softhack007]

Maybe this table helps: https://github.com/pschatzmann/arduino-audiokit/wiki/GPIO-Overview-by-Selected-Board

If SDA=18 SCL=23 works for you, then it seems you have the variant in column 7, with SD=35, WS=25, SCK=5, MCLK=0.

[netmindz]

Ah, great find @softhack007

[netmindz]

[dosipod]

Even if this is closed might be the best place to post about other variant ( not sure what is marked on your board ) but this one is marked as ESP32 Audio kit V2.2 A404