search

MrEliasen / twitch-bot-list

(Deprecated) Whitelist and grey list used by the (scuffed) "Ban Twitch Bots" web app.
https://ban-twitch-bots.sirmre.com
Other
18 stars 5 forks source link

Feedback Requested - Grey/whitelists and the app in general #40

Open MrEliasen opened 2 years ago

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

TL;DR: If you don't want to comment I can provide a few options to choose from, comment on this with an emote:

(I will add more if suggestions comes in)

Edit:

Hi all,

This repository and the accompanied web app have been getting a lot of attention (both negative and positive) lately, so I thought I would try address some of the changes by also ask for feedback on how to proceed.

This repository It has outgrown its original intent and purpose (since release 2 years ago) so it is time to make some changes.

Actioned Changes

  1. I have completely removed the old bot list since it was just not maintainable and also I don't want to be the arbiter of such list. The web app will now directly fetch from Twitch Insights, which I have no involvement in. I am still maintaining a grey and whitelist for the time being, which you can still requests to add/remove accounts from.
  2. The tool allows you to upload a list manually, completely ignoring Twitch Insights.
  3. I have added a lot more warnings and general text to the site in hope it might add a bit more context and information about the tool and how it works.

Possible Future Changes

At minimum I will keep the tool online and just allow users to upload their own lists manually, but without a grey or whitelist. This is also my personal ideal solution as it completely removes this repository/myself from whatever the latest issues are with Twitch users/bots/etc.

However, I would still like to give the opportunity to provide feedback/suggestions.

If you do decide to comment:

Thank you!

EDIT: I will let this vote/discussion run the week out and take it from there.

StygianStyx commented 2 years ago

Can my name please just be removed or added to some other list?

Perhaps a 4th list named IRC Users. Could add Me, Electriclongboard, CommanderRoot, Frw33d, BLKHeroesEverywhere, AcademyImpossible, and metaviews to it to name some real people.

The 4th list option is honestly the best way to go and everyone wins.

as i stated im a Twitch Coil user meaning any chat i do happen to show up in has a chance to get random bit donations from Twitch_Coil_Bot and im pretty sure a few more of these people are twitch coil users considering how Twitch_Coil_Bot went crazy a few months ago and donated like 10+$ in Bits to streamers all over twitch.

https://github.com/MrEliasen/twitch-bot-list/issues/39#issuecomment-927130498

sandtaster commented 2 years ago

My suggestion (again, as it seems to have been overlooked in the last thread) is to keep the current blacklist and whitelist but remove the greylist.

TGxNightshade commented 2 years ago

In addition to my vote, I say @MrEliasen needs to be replaced by someone who has an actual interest in this, both now and in the future. Since you've made it so apparent you don't care, find someone who does.

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

@TGxNightshade Go cancel somewhere else.

BLKHeroesEverywhere commented 2 years ago

I was voted from the admin team to do this.

Styx is actually a really cool dude, he has helped our Facebook group immensely by expanding our socials. Hell we even made him an honorary mod (The only white mod/admin in a group of over 8k Black users).

I would support removing his name. He really is just using it as a networking tool https://github.com/MrEliasen/twitch-bot-list/issues/39#issuecomment-926808400 and helps people he meets, He has all his socials linked on his account also so its not like it would be hard to get ahold of him.

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

I was voted from the admin team to do this.

Styx is actually a really cool dude, he has helped our Facebook group immensely by expanding our socials. Hell we even made him an honorary mod (The only white mod/admin in a group of over 8k Black users).

I would support removing his name. He really is just using it as a networking tool #39 (comment) and helps people he meets, He has all his socials linked on his account also so its not like it would be hard to get ahold of him.

Hey, I don't want to sound disrespectful, but I keep saying.. there is no list to remove anyone from any more.. I don't understand how hard that is to understand. There has been an entire thread about this which devolved into smears because people don't read or don't want to understand what actually is going on.

There is no list, there used to be, but there is no list anymore.

I hope this clears it up once and for all. In case you need to see to believe: https://github.com/MrEliasen/twitch-bot-list/blob/master/list.json

Please keep this thread on the topic. Any comments in this thread which are not related to the topic will be removed from this point out.

BLKHeroesEverywhere commented 2 years ago

What about this? https://github.com/MrEliasen/twitch-bot-list/issues/40#issuecomment-927326919 Atleast Give My Boy and the rest like him to have a option to be moved if asked.

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

For the sake of clearing this up, I will allow this to continue between you and me only for a moment @BLKHeroesEverywhere

What about this? #40 (comment) Atleast Give My Boy and the rest like him to have a option to be moved if asked.

That comments just said to add him to some 4th list. There are 3 lists:

Anyone are welcome to create a PR to add/remove accounts of these lists if there they can argue why.

That is all it is...

BLKHeroesEverywhere commented 2 years ago

This tool lets you 1 click ban him. I can See over 100 names listed.

3 Categories, Why not make a 4th as he asked?

He has asked for his name to not be in the "bot" list.

https://ban-twitch-bots.sirmre.com/

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

https://i.imgur.com/MyooTF2.png

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

Make 4th list to do what exactly? You are asking me to just make a list and put names in it, not what it should do, how it should work.

This is what I am saying, I do not control the list. See above image.

I can add to a gray list, just make a PR. I don't know how many time I can repeat these 2 things.

BLKHeroesEverywhere commented 2 years ago

A 4th List of Opt-In Real users doing whatever he is doing to network, one that does not list them as Bots and have their names auto checked to just ban.

Our account is in that list to by the way.

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

You literally are describing the greylist, and you clearly did not read or understand what I highlighted in the image. This is going in circles. If he wants to be put on a list, that is the graylist. Create a PR, easy.

BLKHeroesEverywhere commented 2 years ago

I don't know what a PR is but he has clearly asked to be added to any alternative. As do we.

We are a black community for gamers, comic lovers, and nerds this man helped us with our community and we wanted to use what he did for us to help other black content creators, instead we have been listed as a bot to just auto ban. Im furious and im trying my best to be respectful. Please look at this from a Community perspective. Its obvious all he is doing is helping people out.

StygianStyx commented 2 years ago

yes plz, i just dont want my name to be a 1 click ban already selected. again i have to speak up for these dudes also https://github.com/MrEliasen/twitch-bot-list/issues/40#issuecomment-927326919

today i was watching one of my favorite streamers i chill to in the morning and when he raided out i was banned from the chat he raided, the streamer had unban requests turned off so the earlier thing about just request unban isnt the best solution.

StygianStyx commented 2 years ago

The Fact that i have to keep begging every day to be removed is sad dude, please remove my name or add it to some other list. Im Going to be DMing this and the other post to twitch support. not sure what they can do but this has to be some form of harassment.

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

The only problem here is you either dp not read or understand what I keep telling you. I will no longer respond to that subject.

StygianStyx commented 2 years ago

you said all i hyave to do is ask to be move, i want my name in the gay list or white list, im tired of being auto checked to be banned

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

Holy crap we have a breakthrough!

No problem, create a pull request with your changes. If you do not know how to do that please create a new issue and fill out the form, stating you want to have your name added to the graylist.

StygianStyx commented 2 years ago

Dude why is it so hard. i been asking. it was the 1st question i asked. no i do not know how.. but i have asked several times.

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

Dude why is it so hard. i been asking. it was the 1st question i asked. no i do not know how.. but i have asked several times.

You have asked to be removed from a list since the start. The list got nuked as it was obsolete and unmaintained. You then asked to be added to any list or for me to create some random other list to add people to without stating wtf how that list would work or what the purpose would be which the Greylist does not already do.

When I did ask you if you wanted to be added to the Graylist you either didnt reply or asked to get removed from the bot list, which I do not control.

It wouldn't have been this hard if you would read what I actually wrote to you, over and over, and yet here we are and you STILL don't

If you do not know how to do that please create a new issue and fill out the form, stating you want to have your name added to the graylist.

That was literally the last half of the sentence I replied to you with just now, and yet you decide to instead reply here and rant.

So. to confirm, you want to be added to the greylist? Because You also didn't confirm that in your last message.

A simple yes/no will do at this point.

StygianStyx commented 2 years ago

Yes i would like to be added to the Greylist.

as should these people https://github.com/MrEliasen/twitch-bot-list/issues/40#issuecomment-927326919

BLKHeroesEverywhere commented 2 years ago

Please add us to the grey list as well.

MrEliasen commented 2 years ago

Please add us to the grey list as well.

What is your twitch name please? To make sure I get it right.

BLKHeroesEverywhere commented 2 years ago

BLKHeroesEverywhere

djwikkid commented 2 years ago

I am having issue with banning the bots. I'm logged in and see my profile Twitch pic in the upper right corner. I select all I want to ban, click the red ban button and nothing. the banned counter still reads 0/106. Refresh and get the same.