Prototype Review

[GoogleCodeExporter]

Please send me your prototype, so that I can review it and give you my 
feedback. I am the assigned reviewer for you.

Original issue reported on code.google.com by shokry....@gmail.com on 3 Nov 2011 at 4:31

[GoogleCodeExporter]

I've sent you my prototype on :
khaled_shokry@hotmail.com

and I've attached it here too!
You can run it using eclipse and it will start automatically on the view of my 
prototype. Just for clarification: The text of "km/minutes" won't be like that. 
It will be only km or minutes depending on the user's choice of the radio 
button.

Original comment by Emy.Mans...@gmail.com on 4 Nov 2011 at 6:34

[GoogleCodeExporter]

I reviewed your Prototype, and here are my comments:

- I understood that the user will enter in the first text box a person and in 
the second one a location. If this is correct, I suggest you put a label 
next/below each text box, to give the user a hint of what he should enter. 
Because, I was confused at the beginning.

- There is no Title for the view. Thus, the functionality of the view was not 
clear for me. I would suggest you put a bar on the top with a title for your 
view, this is common in most of the mobile applications. It could be: 
"Notification request".

- Choosing the time or distance, and then entering a value in the text box, was 
not clear for me. I don't understand if this is the time before arriving to the 
target location or time after starting my trip/movement. And the distance is 
from start point ? or before getting to the target location ? So I would 
recommend some more clarification or changing the way of input.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

* I know that navigating to your view is different than just viewing it 
separably. However, I believe that each mobile view should explain it self 
clearly.

Original comment by shokry....@gmail.com on 5 Nov 2011 at 1:27

• Changed state: restarted

[GoogleCodeExporter]

Concerning your comments:
- To make sure I understand what you mean: Next to the text-field boxes there 
is a "To" label and a "place" label specifying -what should be entered in the 
text-field. You think I should elaborate more?

- Concerning the title: I'll take that into consideration and add it to my view.

- Concerning the third point: It has to do with the context of our application. 
When the user requests a notification from another user he doesn't care about 
the start point. The aim of the request notification is to ask the other user 
to be notified X min or X km before the specified place in the place text 
field. You see a better way of taking the input from the user? 

Original comment by Emy.Mans...@gmail.com on 5 Nov 2011 at 2:34