[Bug] Marble Spawns in the Air

[Ghastly13]

Minecraft version

1.20.x

CodeChickenLib version

4.4.0.512

CBMultipart version

3.3.0.146

ProjectRed version

4.19.0-beta+3

What happened?

There is a large marble generation in the air.

Crash log

The mod did not crash.

How do you make it happen again?

Create a new world, look for it to generate.

[vizthex123]

same here!

log: latest.log

[MrTJP]

Can I get some world seeds and locations where these are generating? I can't seem to find any just flying around random worlds.

[vizthex123]

Can I get some world seeds and locations where these are generating? I can't seem to find any just flying around random worlds.

Had to make a new test world since I deleted the old one, but for me it was all around spawn in the seed -8817395866575381316.

Applies to every world I make. I am running my new modpack, so maybe it's another mod causing this issue? If I disable Marble Caves in the config, they don't appear anymore.

Here's the log from the new world I made: latest.log

[MrTJP]

I am still unable to repro this, even with the given seed (-8817395866575381316). Could be an interaction with another mod that is screwing up world-gen.

Can you run the following command in your world and get me the output?

/forge tags minecraft:block get minecraft:overworld_carver_replaceables

Once you run it, you'll see the first page of values. You can then press the chat keybind again and click on the green Elements: # text to copy all pages to the clipboard.

[Sgt1miler]

Una vez que lo ejecutes, verás la primera página de valores. Luego, puedes presionar la chatcombinación de teclas nuevamente y hacer clic en el Elements: #texto verde para copiar todas las páginas al portapapeles.

ad_astra:glacio_copper_ore ad_astra:glacio_iron_ore ad_astra:glacio_stone ad_astra:mars_iron_ore ad_astra:mars_sand ad_astra:mars_stone ad_astra:mercury_iron_ore ad_astra:mercury_stone ad_astra:moon_iron_ore ad_astra:moon_sand ad_astra:moon_stone ad_astra:permafrost ad_astra:venus_sand ad_astra:venus_stone ad_extendra:ceres_copper_ore ad_extendra:ceres_iron_ore ad_extendra:ceres_sand ad_extendra:jupiter_sand adastraextra:adrastea_rock adastraextra:amalthea_rock adastraextra:deimos_rock adastraextra:jupiter_rock adastraextra:metis_rock adastraextra:neptune_rock adastraextra:phobos_rock adastraextra:saturn_rock adastraextra:thebe_rock adastraextra:uranus_rock aether:aether_dirt aether:aether_grass_block aether:enchanted_aether_grass_block biomesoplenty:black_sand biomesoplenty:glowing_moss_block biomesoplenty:mossy_black_sand biomesoplenty:orange_sand biomesoplenty:origin_grass_block biomesoplenty:white_sand botania:dry_grass botania:golden_grass botania:infused_grass botania:mutated_grass botania:scorched_grass botania:vivid_grass deep_aether:aether_coarse_dirt deep_aether:aether_moss_block deep_aether:aether_mud deep_aether:golden_heights_grass_block denseores:dense_copper_ore denseores:dense_deepslate_copper_ore denseores:dense_deepslate_iron_ore denseores:dense_iron_ore deserts_and_dunes:another_coarse_sand deserts_and_dunes:another_sand deserts_and_dunes:coarse_sand deserts_and_dunes:dry_dirt deserts_and_dunes:dry_red_sand deserts_and_dunes:dry_sand deserts_and_dunes:dune_sand deserts_and_dunes:hard_red_sand deserts_and_dunes:hard_sand deserts_and_dunes:light_sand dungeons_plus:granite_iron_ore farmersdelight:rich_soil minecraft:air minecraft:amethyst_block minecraft:andesite minecraft:basalt minecraft:black_terracotta minecraft:blackstone minecraft:blue_ice minecraft:blue_terracotta minecraft:brown_terracotta minecraft:budding_amethyst minecraft:calcite minecraft:coarse_dirt minecraft:copper_ore minecraft:cyan_terracotta minecraft:deepslate minecraft:deepslate_copper_ore minecraft:deepslate_iron_ore minecraft:diorite minecraft:dirt minecraft:dripstone_block minecraft:granite minecraft:grass_block minecraft:gravel minecraft:gray_terracotta minecraft:green_terracotta minecraft:iron_ore minecraft:light_blue_terracotta minecraft:light_gray_terracotta minecraft:lime_terracotta minecraft:magenta_terracotta minecraft:magma_block minecraft:moss_block minecraft:mud minecraft:muddy_mangrove_roots minecraft:mycelium minecraft:netherrack minecraft:orange_terracotta minecraft:packed_ice minecraft:packed_mud minecraft:pink_terracotta minecraft:podzol minecraft:powder_snow minecraft:purple_terracotta minecraft:raw_copper_block minecraft:raw_iron_block minecraft:red_sand minecraft:red_sandstone minecraft:red_terracotta minecraft:rooted_dirt minecraft:sand minecraft:sandstone minecraft:smooth_basalt minecraft:smooth_red_sandstone minecraft:smooth_sandstone minecraft:snow minecraft:snow_block minecraft:soul_soil minecraft:stone minecraft:suspicious_gravel minecraft:suspicious_sand minecraft:terracotta minecraft:tuff minecraft:water minecraft:white_terracotta minecraft:yellow_terracotta mynethersdelight:resurgent_soil mynethersdelight:resurgent_soil_farmland nethersdelight:rich_soul_soil proxima_plus:proxima_b_sand proxima_plus:proxima_b_sandstone proxima_plus:proxima_b_stone quark:jasper quark:limestone quark:shale regions_unexplored:alpha_grass_block regions_unexplored:argillite regions_unexplored:argillite_grass_block regions_unexplored:ash regions_unexplored:ashen_dirt regions_unexplored:chalk regions_unexplored:chalk_grass_block regions_unexplored:deepslate_grass_block regions_unexplored:deepslate_prismoss regions_unexplored:deepslate_viridescent_nylium regions_unexplored:mossy_stone regions_unexplored:peat_coarse_dirt regions_unexplored:peat_dirt regions_unexplored:peat_farmland regions_unexplored:peat_grass_block regions_unexplored:peat_mud regions_unexplored:peat_podzol regions_unexplored:prismoss regions_unexplored:silt_coarse_dirt regions_unexplored:silt_dirt regions_unexplored:silt_farmland regions_unexplored:silt_grass_block regions_unexplored:silt_mud regions_unexplored:silt_podzol regions_unexplored:stone_grass_block regions_unexplored:viridescent_nylium regions_unexplored:volcanic_ash thermal:phytosoil twilightforest:trollsteinn twilightforest:uberous_soil undergarden:ashen_deepturf_block undergarden:coarse_deepsoil undergarden:deepsoil undergarden:deepturf_block undergarden:depthrock_iron_ore undergarden:frozen_deepturf_block undergarden:shiverstone_iron_ore underground_jungle:jungle_grass valhelsia_structures:coarse_dirt valhelsia_structures:dirt valhelsia_structures:grass_block vintagedelight:lush_grass_block xycraft_machines:planter

[MrTJP]

Here lies the problem. Some mod has added air to the list of stuff that cave generators should carve out:

minecraft:air

That tag does not belong on minecraft:overworld_carver_replaceables. We need to figure out which mod is doing that.

The marble cave generator works by first carving the hollow space, then surrounding the exterior walls with marble. This is tricking the carver to think the air surrounding the carved regions is a diggable material that should be replaced with marble.

Additionally, it is going to cause all cave generators from any mod to run on air, which is likely causing a massive hit to performance (i.e. all cave carvers are not only running underground, but in mid-air as well, even though you can't see their effects as easily as the marble cave carvers).

[vizthex123]

I am still unable to repro this, even with the given seed (-8817395866575381316). Could be an interaction with another mod that is screwing up world-gen.

Can you run the following command in your world and get me the output?

/forge tags minecraft:block get minecraft:overworld_carver_replaceables

Once you run it, you'll see the first page of values. You can then press the chat keybind again and click on the green Elements: # text to copy all pages to the clipboard.

Tested with Exploration v4.19.0-beta+11

I think one of the biome mods does it? I have both BoP and Regions Unexplored installed, just like the other guy's list.

ad_astra:glacio_iron_ore
ad_astra:glacio_stone
ad_astra:mars_iron_ore
ad_astra:mars_sand
ad_astra:mars_stone
ad_astra:mercury_iron_ore
ad_astra:mercury_stone
ad_astra:moon_iron_ore
ad_astra:moon_sand
ad_astra:moon_stone
ad_astra:permafrost
ad_astra:venus_sand
ad_astra:venus_stone
ad_astra_proxima_plus:proxima_b_sand
ad_astra_proxima_plus:proxima_b_sandstone
ad_astra_proxima_plus:proxima_b_stone
ad_astra_proxima_plus:vicino_sand
ad_astra_proxima_plus:vicino_stone
alexscaves:galena_iron_ore
biomesoplenty:black_sand
biomesoplenty:glowing_moss_block
biomesoplenty:mossy_black_sand
biomesoplenty:orange_sand
biomesoplenty:origin_grass_block
biomesoplenty:white_sand
essentials:fertile_soil_acacia
essentials:fertile_soil_birch
essentials:fertile_soil_brown_mushroom
essentials:fertile_soil_dark_oak
essentials:fertile_soil_jungle
essentials:fertile_soil_oak
essentials:fertile_soil_red_mushroom
essentials:fertile_soil_spruce
excavated_variants:andesite_copper_ore
excavated_variants:andesite_iron_ore
excavated_variants:argillite_copper_ore
excavated_variants:argillite_iron_ore
excavated_variants:basalt_copper_ore
excavated_variants:basalt_iron_ore
excavated_variants:biomesoplenty_black_sandstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:biomesoplenty_black_sandstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:biomesoplenty_orange_sandstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:biomesoplenty_orange_sandstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:biomesoplenty_white_sandstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:biomesoplenty_white_sandstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:calcite_copper_ore
excavated_variants:calcite_iron_ore
excavated_variants:chalk_copper_ore
excavated_variants:chalk_iron_ore
excavated_variants:chalkstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:chalkstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:chert_copper_ore
excavated_variants:chert_iron_ore
excavated_variants:diorite_copper_ore
excavated_variants:diorite_iron_ore
excavated_variants:dripstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:dripstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:granite_copper_ore
excavated_variants:granite_iron_ore
excavated_variants:kivi_copper_ore
excavated_variants:kivi_iron_ore
excavated_variants:marble_copper_ore
excavated_variants:marble_iron_ore
excavated_variants:mudstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:mudstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:pastel_pink_salt_copper_ore
excavated_variants:pastel_pink_salt_iron_ore
excavated_variants:pink_salt_copper_ore
excavated_variants:pink_salt_iron_ore
excavated_variants:quark_jasper_copper_ore
excavated_variants:quark_jasper_iron_ore
excavated_variants:quark_limestone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:quark_limestone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:quark_shale_copper_ore
excavated_variants:quark_shale_iron_ore
excavated_variants:red_sandstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:red_sandstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:rose_pink_salt_copper_ore
excavated_variants:rose_pink_salt_iron_ore
excavated_variants:sandstone_copper_ore
excavated_variants:sandstone_iron_ore
excavated_variants:smooth_basalt_copper_ore
excavated_variants:smooth_basalt_iron_ore
excavated_variants:tuff_copper_ore
excavated_variants:tuff_iron_ore
galosphere:lichen_moss
minecraft:air
minecraft:andesite
minecraft:black_terracotta
minecraft:blue_ice
minecraft:blue_terracotta
minecraft:brown_terracotta
minecraft:calcite
minecraft:coarse_dirt
minecraft:copper_ore
minecraft:cyan_terracotta
minecraft:deepslate
minecraft:deepslate_copper_ore
minecraft:deepslate_iron_ore
minecraft:diorite
minecraft:dirt
minecraft:dripstone_block
minecraft:granite
minecraft:grass_block
minecraft:gravel
minecraft:gray_terracotta
minecraft:green_terracotta
minecraft:ice
minecraft:iron_ore
minecraft:light_blue_terracotta
minecraft:light_gray_terracotta
minecraft:lime_terracotta
minecraft:magenta_terracotta
minecraft:moss_block
minecraft:mud
minecraft:muddy_mangrove_roots
minecraft:mycelium
minecraft:orange_terracotta
minecraft:packed_ice
minecraft:packed_mud
minecraft:pink_terracotta
minecraft:podzol
minecraft:powder_snow
minecraft:purple_terracotta
minecraft:raw_copper_block
minecraft:raw_iron_block
minecraft:red_sand
minecraft:red_sandstone
minecraft:red_terracotta
minecraft:rooted_dirt
minecraft:sand
minecraft:sandstone
minecraft:snow
minecraft:snow_block
minecraft:stone
minecraft:suspicious_gravel
minecraft:suspicious_sand
minecraft:terracotta
minecraft:tuff
minecraft:void_air
minecraft:water
minecraft:white_terracotta
minecraft:yellow_terracotta
quark:jasper
quark:limestone
quark:shale
regions_unexplored:alpha_grass_block
regions_unexplored:argillite
regions_unexplored:argillite_grass_block
regions_unexplored:ash
regions_unexplored:ashen_dirt
regions_unexplored:chalk
regions_unexplored:chalk_grass_block
regions_unexplored:deepslate_grass_block
regions_unexplored:deepslate_prismoss
regions_unexplored:deepslate_viridescent_nylium
regions_unexplored:mossy_stone
regions_unexplored:peat_coarse_dirt
regions_unexplored:peat_dirt
regions_unexplored:peat_farmland
regions_unexplored:peat_grass_block
regions_unexplored:peat_mud
regions_unexplored:peat_podzol
regions_unexplored:prismoss
regions_unexplored:silt_coarse_dirt
regions_unexplored:silt_dirt
regions_unexplored:silt_farmland
regions_unexplored:silt_grass_block
regions_unexplored:silt_mud
regions_unexplored:silt_podzol
regions_unexplored:stone_grass_block
regions_unexplored:viridescent_nylium
regions_unexplored:volcanic_ash
thermal:phytosoil
xycraft_machines:planter```

[Sgt1miler]

I fin one of the mods bug the generation "Ad Astra Extra"

[vizthex123]

I don't have that installed, so perhaps something else does it too?

[MrTJP]

@vizthex123 Yea and in your case, it is also adding minecraft:void_air. Both are incorrect as far as I understand. I'll add a workaround to ignore these tags. But it really should be fixed in whatever mod is adding these.