search

My-Little-Forum / mylittleforum

A simple PHP and MySQL based internet forum that displays the messages in classical threaded view (tree structure)
GNU General Public License v3.0
122 stars 48 forks source link

No hand cursor when hovering buttons #639

Closed auge8472 closed 2 years ago

auge8472 commented 2 years ago

When hovering over buttons, the cursor should be displayed as hand, like when hovering over links. This might be especially an issue of the HTML-element button.

loesler commented 2 years ago

I think, this is not a bug, it is the normal behaviour of the button element.

auge8472 commented 2 years ago

You are right. The cursor for buttons is, what the browser manufacturers decide. So that's not a bug in itself. But in the meaning of accessibility it is IMHO a bad decision, to display the mouse cursor as the "normal" arrow and to show the interactivity of the button only with the colour change during hovering.

For signalling links there is the rule of showing it with more than one CSS-"feature". Showing a link not only with a different text colour than plain text but also with an underline and/or with a background (colour) is common for developers who want make websites to include all audience (as far as possible). It's (meanwhile) also common practice to show the interactivitiy of HTML-elements label with another cursor pointer and in some cases a changing background when focussed or hovered.

So why not also showing the interactivitiy of buttons with more than one CSS-"feature"? Moreover it's a simple task to add cursor: pointer; for button as well as input[type="submit"] and input[type="reset"] (until their complete replacement with button everywhere).

loesler commented 2 years ago

So why not also showing the interactivitiy of buttons with more than one CSS-"feature"?

There is no reason, not to style any HTML element, and I have no problem to add the pointer property. However, styling cannot be classified in right and wrong. Thus, I wonder that you label this issue as bug.

auge8472 commented 2 years ago

Thus, I wonder that you label this issue as bug.

IMHO it is a usability bug (in the meaning of a non-optimal behaviour), but it is not a bug in itself (in the meaning of an error). I removed the tag bug and added frontend instead.