NASA-IMPACT / admg-casei

ADMG Inventory
https://impact.earthdata.nasa.gov/casei/
Apache License 2.0
1 stars 0 forks source link

Data Product View - Minor Improvements to MVP #548

Closed smwingo closed 1 year ago

smwingo commented 1 year ago

ticket with some initial notes on MVP iteration of CASEI data product view, eg: image

are we using the GCMD KWs as in CMR now? -- Tammo confirmed this is YES today.

result list:

filters:

heidimok commented 1 year ago

Hey @smwingo After discussion some of these bullets with @Tammo-Feldmann here is what I am proposing we can change more immediately to try and address feedback. It's not 1:1 for each bullet because I think some solutions can tackle multiple concerns?

Proposed changes

1. Instead of the DOI name, use the longer written name of the data product like the mockup below. If the name is too long, we can cut it off and use the hover tooltip to expose the full text. This is a bit more human-readable. image

2. Prototyping the variables in a column, but only for evaluation. I think we keep coming back to this and the challenge of continuously extending table columns on limited space. Especially with gcmd names, I feel that the ask is simple but it's not a simple solution. But it's easy to prototype and Tammo can play with a version with another variables column and paste visually for us to evaluate.

3. Adjusting filters:

  1. Info icon link out to GCMD keywords dictionary. This takes users away from CASEI to reference the full GCMD keyword list. image

Questions for @smwingo

  1. Fill in empty fields - This wasn't in the list above but in my notes that the empty cells can be confusing. What could be a placeholder for them? @smwingo
    image
smwingo commented 1 year ago

@heidimok thank you!!!!!

My Comments on Proposed Changes:

1 - yes - i like it all, and understand the sorting issue - data prod name will help and be more human readable/intelligable

2 - sounds good - will look fwd to what Tammo comes up with and happy to iterate as we all have time

3 - this all sounds reasonable

4 - i prefer a tool tip to give a short/clarification text to user. text can use:

"Data produt variables in CASEI and NASA's CMR are represented by GCMD Earth Science Keywords. For a full list of the heirarchical GCMD Earth Science Keywords available, please refer to [ the GCMD keyword viewer ] " with the text in the [ ] as the link to the viewer

and yes, link to the GCMD kw viewer, but instead of the "all" default, let's send users to JUST THE EARTH SCIENCE part of the tree -- I know there's a way to give URL for that, atm the one i have looks messy but does seem to work ( https://gcmd.earthdata.nasa.gov/KeywordViewer/scheme/all/e9f67a66-e9fc-435c-b720-ae32a2c3d8f5?gtm_keyword=EARTH%20SCIENCE&gtm_scheme=Earth%20Science )

5 - think it would also be good to ask some others on the team -- my initial idea is to give a "see landing page for details" kind of message-- don't know about how that would fit in the available space, or if some sort of "tool tip" kind of text over a "---" would suffice... @deborahUAH @cw0045 @EJwalker13 @als0076 @rwyatt19 what are yall's thoughts on this one??

rwyatt19 commented 1 year ago

for 5: I like the hover "tool tip" text over "---". Only exposes info if a user is interested.