search

NCAR / ucomp-pipeline

Data processing pipeline for UCoMP
Other
6 stars 3 forks source link

Verify more level 1 results against Steve's results #99

Open mgalloy opened 1 year ago

mgalloy commented 1 year ago

I can pick sample dates and images to compare. I only need final level 1 results (hopefully) to match against.

mgalloy commented 1 year ago

For an image later in the comparison date, 20220901, at 20220902.020742:

xoffset0: mike: -13.907, steve: -13.896, mike-steve: -0.011
yoffset0: mike: -2.465, steve: -2.468, mike-steve: 0.003
xoffset1: mike: -15.554, steve: -15.563, mike-steve: 0.009
yoffset1: mike: -3.786, steve: -3.782, mike-steve: -0.004

Which shows fairly good agreement on centering still. This was an image that doesn't have a good center finding, but Steve and the pipeline both find the same artifact.

The difference image for center line intensity:

20220902 020742 ucomp final diff

The percent difference image for center line intensity:

20220902 020742 ucomp final perdiff
mgalloy commented 1 year ago

The following is a table of all the 1074 nm files for 20220901 with the XOFFSET0, YOFFSET0, XOFFSET1, and YOFFSET1 for the pipeline, for Steve's results, and then difference.

Image time      |--- pipeline offsets ----| |----- Steve offsets -----| |---- pipeline - Steve ---|
20220901.182014 -1.226 -0.898 -2.037 -2.214 -1.215 -0.897 -2.024 -2.215 -0.011 -0.001 -0.013  0.001
20220901.182246 -1.245 -0.889 -2.059 -2.202 -1.259 -0.906 -2.043 -2.202  0.014  0.017 -0.016  0.000
20220901.185824 -1.526 -0.694 -2.390 -2.006 -1.515 -0.692 -2.381 -2.000 -0.011 -0.002 -0.009 -0.006
20220901.190056 -1.537 -0.685 -2.415 -2.001 -1.526 -0.685 -2.403 -1.991 -0.011 -0.000 -0.012 -0.010
20220901.193635 -1.875 -0.575 -2.790 -1.857 -1.863 -0.572 -2.773 -1.856 -0.012 -0.003 -0.017 -0.001
20220901.193908 -1.894 -0.567 -2.804 -1.852 -1.885 -0.564 -2.789 -1.848 -0.009 -0.003 -0.015 -0.004
20220901.200958 -2.564 -0.579 -3.512 -1.863 -2.551 -0.578 -3.497 -1.857 -0.013 -0.001 -0.015 -0.006
20220901.201032 -2.555 -0.587 -3.498 -1.856 -2.544 -0.582 -3.482 -1.852 -0.011 -0.005 -0.016 -0.004
20220901.201106 -2.557 -0.542 -3.498 -1.820 -2.538 -0.545 -3.482 -1.816 -0.019  0.003 -0.016 -0.004
20220901.201139 -2.544 -0.501 -3.492 -1.784 -2.527 -0.499 -3.474 -1.780 -0.017 -0.002 -0.018 -0.004
20220901.201213 -2.538 -0.461 -3.475 -1.723 -2.532 -0.466 -3.464 -1.714 -0.006  0.005 -0.011 -0.009
20220901.201246 -2.513 -0.475 -3.465 -1.735 -2.510 -0.474 -3.440 -1.727 -0.003 -0.001 -0.025 -0.008
20220901.201320 -2.497 -0.465 -3.436 -1.713 -2.485 -0.467 -3.424 -1.708 -0.012  0.002 -0.012 -0.005
20220901.201354 -2.480 -0.449 -3.417 -1.707 -2.467 -0.449 -3.402 -1.698 -0.013 -0.000 -0.015 -0.009
20220901.201427 -2.473 -0.434 -3.398 -1.682 -2.458 -0.427 -3.385 -1.674 -0.015 -0.007 -0.013 -0.008
20220901.201501 -2.479 -0.437 -3.400 -1.689 -2.463 -0.437 -3.392 -1.686 -0.016 -0.000 -0.008 -0.003
20220901.201534 -2.468 -0.419 -3.398 -1.665 -2.453 -0.413 -3.380 -1.670 -0.015 -0.006 -0.018  0.005
20220901.201608 -2.458 -0.359 -3.385 -1.651 -2.446 -0.355 -3.373 -1.648 -0.012 -0.004 -0.012 -0.003
20220901.201642 -2.427 -0.351 -3.359 -1.621 -2.421 -0.364 -3.353 -1.608 -0.006  0.013 -0.006 -0.013
20220901.201715 -2.442 -0.392 -3.355 -1.630 -2.425 -0.393 -3.356 -1.615 -0.017  0.001  0.001 -0.015
20220901.201749 -2.408 -0.341 -3.352 -1.622 -2.402 -0.347 -3.338 -1.628 -0.006  0.006 -0.014  0.006
20220901.201822 -2.419 -0.354 -3.313 -1.667 -2.402 -0.358 -3.321 -1.627 -0.017  0.004  0.008 -0.040
20220901.201856 -2.419 -0.414 -3.335 -1.590 -2.400 -0.404 -3.319 -1.583 -0.019 -0.010 -0.016 -0.007
20220901.201930 -2.401 -0.361 -3.323 -1.598 -2.387 -0.355 -3.316 -1.598 -0.014 -0.006 -0.007  0.000
20220901.202003 -2.389 -0.366 -3.326 -1.600 -2.372 -0.359 -3.311 -1.591 -0.017 -0.007 -0.015 -0.009
20220901.202037 -2.385 -0.355 -3.324 -1.625 -2.378 -0.354 -3.317 -1.642 -0.007 -0.001 -0.007  0.017
20220901.202110 -2.376 -0.349 -3.308 -1.604 -2.366 -0.342 -3.299 -1.599 -0.010 -0.007 -0.009 -0.005
20220901.202144 -2.404 -0.416 -3.298 -1.619 -2.383 -0.403 -3.305 -1.606 -0.021 -0.013  0.007 -0.013
20220901.202218 -2.389 -0.399 -3.318 -1.673 -2.367 -0.400 -3.313 -1.664 -0.022  0.001 -0.005 -0.009
20220901.202251 -2.377 -0.395 -3.304 -1.627 -2.369 -0.380 -3.293 -1.623 -0.008 -0.015 -0.011 -0.004
20220901.202325 -2.380 -0.385 -3.316 -1.631 -2.368 -0.371 -3.298 -1.627 -0.012 -0.014 -0.018 -0.004
20220901.202358 -2.386 -0.406 -3.302 -1.614 -2.367 -0.400 -3.294 -1.604 -0.019 -0.006 -0.008 -0.010
20220901.202432 -2.369 -0.381 -3.313 -1.675 -2.355 -0.380 -3.306 -1.668 -0.014 -0.001 -0.007 -0.007
20220901.202505 -2.363 -0.393 -3.299 -1.628 -2.350 -0.389 -3.288 -1.620 -0.013 -0.004 -0.011 -0.008
20220901.202539 -2.356 -0.382 -3.294 -1.629 -2.346 -0.376 -3.289 -1.628 -0.010 -0.006 -0.005 -0.001
20220901.202613 -2.367 -0.415 -3.300 -1.629 -2.353 -0.404 -3.282 -1.619 -0.014 -0.011 -0.018 -0.010
20220901.202646 -2.364 -0.437 -3.309 -1.703 -2.350 -0.425 -3.291 -1.684 -0.014 -0.012 -0.018 -0.019
20220901.202720 -2.363 -0.423 -3.306 -1.669 -2.354 -0.414 -3.293 -1.659 -0.009 -0.009 -0.013 -0.010
20220901.202753 -2.367 -0.398 -3.302 -1.656 -2.349 -0.396 -3.291 -1.649 -0.018 -0.002 -0.011 -0.007
20220901.202827 -2.377 -0.394 -3.313 -1.651 -2.363 -0.404 -3.291 -1.643 -0.014  0.010 -0.022 -0.008
20220901.202901 -2.381 -0.409 -3.300 -1.642 -2.363 -0.405 -3.294 -1.651 -0.018 -0.004 -0.006  0.009
20220901.202934 -2.379 -0.404 -3.319 -1.710 -2.364 -0.391 -3.301 -1.696 -0.015 -0.013 -0.018 -0.014
20220901.203008 -2.385 -0.378 -3.315 -1.634 -2.372 -0.379 -3.309 -1.621 -0.013  0.001 -0.006 -0.013
20220901.203041 -2.359 -0.402 -3.312 -1.638 -2.353 -0.390 -3.304 -1.632 -0.006 -0.012 -0.008 -0.006
20220901.203115 -2.349 -0.405 -3.326 -1.656 -2.340 -0.399 -3.311 -1.639 -0.009 -0.006 -0.015 -0.017
20220901.203149 -2.353 -0.437 -3.295 -1.681 -2.337 -0.429 -3.284 -1.675 -0.016 -0.008 -0.011 -0.006
20220901.203222 -2.384 -0.443 -3.319 -1.676 -2.370 -0.438 -3.305 -1.675 -0.014 -0.005 -0.014 -0.001
20220901.203256 -2.373 -0.431 -3.346 -1.663 -2.359 -0.422 -3.319 -1.664 -0.014 -0.009 -0.027  0.001
20220901.203329 -2.368 -0.436 -3.338 -1.655 -2.350 -0.438 -3.322 -1.653 -0.018  0.002 -0.016 -0.002
20220901.203403 -2.379 -0.413 -3.336 -1.658 -2.363 -0.414 -3.323 -1.651 -0.016  0.001 -0.013 -0.007
20220901.203436 -2.398 -0.417 -3.337 -1.649 -2.377 -0.436 -3.318 -1.641 -0.021  0.019 -0.019 -0.008
20220901.203510 -2.378 -0.451 -3.339 -1.682 -2.357 -0.454 -3.322 -1.678 -0.021  0.003 -0.017 -0.004
20220901.203544 -2.370 -0.457 -3.339 -1.673 -2.354 -0.459 -3.321 -1.683 -0.016  0.002 -0.018  0.010
20220901.203617 -2.357 -0.451 -3.325 -1.681 -2.349 -0.454 -3.310 -1.676 -0.008  0.003 -0.015 -0.005
20220901.203651 -2.385 -0.434 -3.338 -1.684 -2.370 -0.441 -3.326 -1.670 -0.015  0.007 -0.012 -0.014
20220901.203724 -2.356 -0.450 -3.335 -1.684 -2.348 -0.443 -3.322 -1.680 -0.008 -0.007 -0.013 -0.004
20220901.203758 -2.377 -0.456 -3.346 -1.680 -2.358 -0.461 -3.319 -1.677 -0.019  0.005 -0.027 -0.003
20220901.203832 -2.384 -0.461 -3.347 -1.693 -2.370 -0.452 -3.337 -1.683 -0.014 -0.009 -0.010 -0.010
20220901.203905 -2.388 -0.456 -3.346 -1.682 -2.367 -0.446 -3.328 -1.671 -0.021 -0.010 -0.018 -0.011
20220901.203939 -2.398 -0.438 -3.366 -1.666 -2.377 -0.448 -3.352 -1.678 -0.021  0.010 -0.014  0.012
20220901.204012 -2.385 -0.444 -3.384 -1.666 -2.375 -0.438 -3.356 -1.662 -0.010 -0.006 -0.028 -0.004
20220901.204046 -2.385 -0.436 -3.361 -1.680 -2.369 -0.440 -3.347 -1.667 -0.016  0.004 -0.014 -0.013
20220901.204120 -2.379 -0.450 -3.360 -1.664 -2.368 -0.447 -3.351 -1.667 -0.011 -0.003 -0.009  0.003
20220901.204153 -2.374 -0.466 -3.354 -1.689 -2.362 -0.461 -3.342 -1.692 -0.012 -0.005 -0.012  0.003
20220901.204227 -2.372 -0.450 -3.349 -1.686 -2.366 -0.448 -3.342 -1.677 -0.006 -0.002 -0.007 -0.009
20220901.204300 -2.389 -0.431 -3.379 -1.663 -2.378 -0.436 -3.366 -1.653 -0.011  0.005 -0.013 -0.010
20220901.204334 -2.392 -0.452 -3.374 -1.682 -2.383 -0.444 -3.363 -1.672 -0.009 -0.008 -0.011 -0.010
20220901.204408 -2.381 -0.458 -3.369 -1.680 -2.372 -0.457 -3.356 -1.666 -0.009 -0.001 -0.013 -0.014
20220901.204441 -2.386 -0.468 -3.361 -1.669 -2.374 -0.462 -3.340 -1.669 -0.012 -0.006 -0.021  0.000
20220901.204515 -2.382 -0.460 -3.361 -1.662 -2.374 -0.463 -3.349 -1.660 -0.008  0.003 -0.012 -0.002
20220901.204548 -2.388 -0.442 -3.384 -1.673 -2.376 -0.445 -3.368 -1.671 -0.012  0.003 -0.016 -0.002
20220901.204622 -2.393 -0.437 -3.379 -1.660 -2.381 -0.444 -3.371 -1.660 -0.012  0.007 -0.008  0.000
20220901.204656 -2.403 -0.442 -3.394 -1.650 -2.396 -0.446 -3.380 -1.654 -0.007  0.004 -0.014  0.004
20220901.204729 -2.398 -0.438 -3.406 -1.658 -2.377 -0.440 -3.395 -1.656 -0.021  0.002 -0.011 -0.002
20220901.204803 -2.424 -0.445 -3.380 -1.664 -2.396 -0.433 -3.363 -1.668 -0.028 -0.012 -0.017  0.004
20220901.204836 -2.397 -0.440 -3.386 -1.640 -2.377 -0.428 -3.371 -1.633 -0.020 -0.012 -0.015 -0.007
20220901.204910 -2.412 -0.446 -3.394 -1.668 -2.405 -0.446 -3.383 -1.659 -0.007 -0.000 -0.011 -0.009
20220901.204944 -2.408 -0.449 -3.391 -1.657 -2.384 -0.449 -3.387 -1.663 -0.024  0.000 -0.004  0.006
20220901.205017 -2.396 -0.461 -3.403 -1.671 -2.389 -0.461 -3.392 -1.655 -0.007  0.000 -0.011 -0.016
20220901.205051 -2.397 -0.448 -3.386 -1.676 -2.384 -0.443 -3.374 -1.672 -0.013 -0.005 -0.012 -0.004
20220901.205124 -2.420 -0.438 -3.424 -1.652 -2.410 -0.442 -3.413 -1.660 -0.010  0.004 -0.011  0.008
20220901.205158 -2.435 -0.468 -3.426 -1.655 -2.416 -0.454 -3.412 -1.645 -0.019 -0.014 -0.014 -0.010
20220901.205232 -2.422 -0.443 -3.425 -1.684 -2.405 -0.443 -3.418 -1.672 -0.017  0.000 -0.007 -0.012
20220901.205305 -2.388 -0.450 -3.397 -1.677 -2.378 -0.467 -3.390 -1.672 -0.010  0.017 -0.007 -0.005
20220901.205339 -2.409 -0.473 -3.411 -1.691 -2.390 -0.477 -3.389 -1.680 -0.019  0.004 -0.022 -0.011
20220901.205412 -2.404 -0.484 -3.402 -1.704 -2.386 -0.480 -3.393 -1.701 -0.018 -0.004 -0.009 -0.003
20220901.205446 -2.430 -0.457 -3.398 -1.680 -2.415 -0.454 -3.385 -1.668 -0.015 -0.003 -0.013 -0.012
20220901.205520 -2.421 -0.466 -3.433 -1.711 -2.410 -0.463 -3.442 -1.686 -0.011 -0.003  0.009 -0.025
20220901.205553 -2.434 -0.455 -3.436 -1.685 -2.415 -0.467 -3.420 -1.672 -0.019  0.012 -0.016 -0.013
20220901.205627 -2.417 -0.469 -3.442 -1.685 -2.401 -0.475 -3.437 -1.679 -0.016  0.006 -0.005 -0.006
20220901.205700 -2.414 -0.483 -3.425 -1.719 -2.400 -0.486 -3.417 -1.702 -0.014  0.003 -0.008 -0.016
20220901.205734 -2.406 -0.436 -3.435 -1.690 -2.396 -0.433 -3.416 -1.680 -0.010 -0.003 -0.019 -0.010
20220901.205808 -2.456 -0.491 -3.420 -1.678 -2.437 -0.485 -3.406 -1.665 -0.019 -0.006 -0.014 -0.013
20220901.205841 -2.407 -0.476 -3.459 -1.682 -2.412 -0.484 -3.428 -1.672  0.005  0.008 -0.031 -0.010
20220901.205915 -2.414 -0.487 -3.435 -1.701 -2.403 -0.484 -3.419 -1.694 -0.011 -0.003 -0.016 -0.007
20220901.205948 -2.407 -0.450 -3.430 -1.701 -2.397 -0.452 -3.417 -1.691 -0.010  0.002 -0.013 -0.010
20220901.210022 -2.486 -0.493 -3.434 -1.681 -2.472 -0.508 -3.426 -1.672 -0.014  0.015 -0.008 -0.009
20220901.210056 -2.447 -0.487 -3.478 -1.689 -2.427 -0.485 -3.457 -1.691 -0.020 -0.002 -0.021  0.002
20220901.210129 -2.446 -0.463 -3.473 -1.683 -2.441 -0.487 -3.457 -1.686 -0.006  0.024 -0.016  0.003
20220901.210203 -2.442 -0.485 -3.473 -1.694 -2.431 -0.487 -3.456 -1.699 -0.011  0.002 -0.017  0.005
20220901.210236 -2.456 -0.486 -3.459 -1.697 -2.445 -0.482 -3.447 -1.700 -0.011 -0.004 -0.012  0.003
20220901.210310 -2.443 -0.503 -3.462 -1.711 -2.433 -0.503 -3.454 -1.704 -0.010  0.000 -0.007 -0.007
20220901.210344 -2.446 -0.519 -3.458 -1.731 -2.429 -0.515 -3.446 -1.723 -0.017 -0.004 -0.012 -0.008
20220901.210417 -2.455 -0.499 -3.455 -1.706 -2.441 -0.492 -3.445 -1.703 -0.014 -0.007 -0.010 -0.003
20220901.210451 -2.461 -0.447 -3.458 -1.672 -2.451 -0.448 -3.456 -1.669 -0.010  0.001 -0.002 -0.003
20220901.210524 -2.485 -0.473 -3.474 -1.669 -2.477 -0.462 -3.467 -1.666 -0.008 -0.011 -0.007 -0.003
20220901.210558 -2.476 -0.475 -3.488 -1.684 -2.467 -0.468 -3.487 -1.672 -0.009 -0.007 -0.001 -0.012
20220901.210631 -2.491 -0.481 -3.505 -1.678 -2.482 -0.455 -3.496 -1.673 -0.009 -0.026 -0.009 -0.005
20220901.210705 -2.471 -0.449 -3.523 -1.678 -2.458 -0.454 -3.507 -1.683 -0.013  0.005 -0.016  0.005
20220901.210739 -2.475 -0.467 -3.503 -1.676 -2.456 -0.456 -3.493 -1.663 -0.019 -0.011 -0.010 -0.013
20220901.210812 -2.465 -0.442 -3.527 -1.664 -2.459 -0.442 -3.501 -1.664 -0.006 -0.000 -0.026 -0.000
20220901.210846 -2.475 -0.453 -3.512 -1.654 -2.466 -0.458 -3.499 -1.644 -0.009  0.005 -0.013 -0.010
20220901.210919 -2.469 -0.443 -3.509 -1.662 -2.464 -0.446 -3.497 -1.656 -0.005  0.003 -0.012 -0.006
20220901.210953 -2.494 -0.442 -3.498 -1.662 -2.477 -0.443 -3.485 -1.651 -0.017  0.001 -0.013 -0.011
20220901.211027 -2.499 -0.448 -3.513 -1.683 -2.475 -0.453 -3.504 -1.663 -0.024  0.005 -0.009 -0.020
20220901.211100 -2.521 -0.461 -3.526 -1.670 -2.489 -0.455 -3.521 -1.674 -0.032 -0.006 -0.005  0.004
20220901.211134 -2.490 -0.458 -3.521 -1.671 -2.463 -0.450 -3.521 -1.674 -0.027 -0.008  0.000  0.003
20220901.211207 -2.494 -0.451 -3.529 -1.670 -2.481 -0.465 -3.518 -1.663 -0.013  0.014 -0.011 -0.007
20220901.211241 -2.484 -0.450 -3.510 -1.686 -2.474 -0.446 -3.495 -1.680 -0.010 -0.004 -0.015 -0.006
20220901.211315 -2.489 -0.439 -3.503 -1.682 -2.477 -0.444 -3.488 -1.669 -0.012  0.005 -0.015 -0.013
20220901.211348 -2.523 -0.449 -3.539 -1.663 -2.508 -0.443 -3.528 -1.649 -0.015 -0.006 -0.011 -0.014
20220901.211422 -2.545 -0.443 -3.538 -1.655 -2.537 -0.456 -3.532 -1.647 -0.008  0.013 -0.006 -0.008
20220901.211455 -2.553 -0.463 -3.591 -1.720 -2.547 -0.476 -3.605 -1.716 -0.006  0.013  0.014 -0.004
20220901.211529 -2.506 -0.464 -3.531 -1.673 -2.500 -0.463 -3.523 -1.669 -0.006 -0.001 -0.008 -0.004
20220901.211602 -2.513 -0.453 -3.537 -1.670 -2.502 -0.439 -3.527 -1.661 -0.011 -0.014 -0.010 -0.009
20220901.211636 -2.511 -0.453 -3.535 -1.666 -2.502 -0.457 -3.526 -1.658 -0.009  0.004 -0.009 -0.008
20220901.222919 -3.337 -0.476 -4.425 -1.657 -3.329 -0.486 -4.416 -1.660 -0.008  0.010 -0.009  0.003
20220901.223152 -3.301 -0.513 -4.433 -1.705 -3.266 -0.502 -4.394 -1.694 -0.035 -0.011 -0.039 -0.011
20220901.232814 ******  4.066 ******  2.920 ******  4.072 ******  2.913  0.001 -0.006  0.000  0.007
20220901.233046 ******  3.989 ******  2.844 ******  4.048 ******  2.846  0.151 -0.059  0.009 -0.002
20220902.004837 ****** -2.272 ****** -3.485 ****** -2.267 ****** -3.489  0.006 -0.005  0.006  0.004
20220902.005109 ****** -2.299 ****** -3.517 ****** -2.288 ****** -3.507  0.028 -0.011 -0.023 -0.010
20220902.020509 ****** -2.471 ****** -3.808 ****** -2.473 ****** -3.795  0.047  0.002  0.002 -0.013
20220902.020742 ****** -2.465 ****** -3.786 ****** -2.468 ****** -3.782 -0.011  0.003  0.009 -0.004
20220902.024313 ****** -2.552 ****** -3.884 ****** -2.539 ****** -3.879 -0.008 -0.013 -0.013 -0.005
20220902.024545 ****** -2.551 ****** -3.869 ****** -2.550 ****** -3.859  0.004 -0.001 -0.003 -0.010
20220902.032124 -4.821 -0.963 -6.816 -2.280 -4.793 -0.961 -6.802 -2.269 -0.028 -0.002 -0.014 -0.011
20220902.032356 -4.837 -0.938 -6.737 -2.247 -4.820 -0.928 -6.726 -2.230 -0.017 -0.010 -0.011 -0.017

The mean absolute value of differences:

0.0146988   0.00643222    0.0125228   0.00778015

The median absolute value of differences:

0.0129199   0.00493902    0.0121801   0.00716007
mgalloy commented 1 year ago

@detoma says:

This is good and tells us your pipeline is consistent with Steve. It seems to me we can now work with only your pipeline, at least for 1074. Joan and Mike: Do you agree?

We need to look at different days and test if the center is a good center. For the days with intermediate products you did for me I do not think the centering was always good. 20220901 was the best day.

The fact that the two pipelines agree does not mean we find the right center. Both pipelines could fail on certain images. It may be tricky to find a metric to evaluate the goodness of the centering. Looking at the alignment of the images in the two cameras is one way. Plotting a circle around the occulter is another, not very quantitative, way. Any suggestions on how to validate the centering?

mgalloy commented 1 year ago

The same values for 20210817:

20210817.182724 17.048  6.035 17.598  5.688 17.042  6.029 17.605  5.687  0.006  0.006 -0.007  0.001
20210817.184601 17.217  6.143 17.804  5.804 17.176  6.126 17.793  5.790  0.041  0.017  0.011  0.014
20210817.200828 16.566  7.221 17.127  6.889 16.561  7.213 17.132  6.884  0.005  0.008 -0.005  0.005
20210817.202715 16.855  7.095 17.412  6.777 16.859  7.087 17.355  6.745 -0.004  0.008  0.057  0.032

    0.0140748   0.00948000    0.0199752    0.0129625
   0.00609970   0.00779963    0.0106010    0.0139198
mgalloy commented 1 year ago

For 20220225:

20220225.181823 -1.490 ****** -0.923 ****** -1.482 ****** -0.915 ****** -0.008  0.022 -0.008  0.005
20220225.182056 -1.499 ****** -0.916 ****** -1.493 ****** -0.912 ****** -0.006  0.024 -0.004 -0.017
20220225.184602 -1.719 ****** -1.139 ****** -1.707 ****** -1.127 ****** -0.012  0.022 -0.012  0.014
20220225.184835 -1.731 ****** -1.144 ****** -1.721 ****** -1.137 ****** -0.010  0.022 -0.007  0.020
20220225.191401 -1.950 ****** -1.374 ****** -1.933 ****** -1.373 ****** -0.017  0.025 -0.001  0.006
20220225.191634 -1.983 ****** -1.392 ****** -1.968 ****** -1.383 ****** -0.015  0.026 -0.009  0.014
20220225.194219 -2.222 ****** -1.670 ****** -2.214 ****** -1.649 ****** -0.008  0.023 -0.021 -0.012
20220225.194253 -2.198 ****** -1.645 ****** -2.193 ****** -1.650 ****** -0.005  0.017  0.005  0.006
20220225.194327 -2.190 ****** -1.649 ****** -2.167 ****** -1.636 ****** -0.023  0.035 -0.013  0.014
20220225.194400 -2.153 ****** -1.600 ****** -2.141 ****** -1.591 ****** -0.012  0.007 -0.009  0.026
20220225.194434 -2.141 ****** -1.568 ****** -2.121 ****** -1.559 ****** -0.020  0.008 -0.009  0.012
20220225.194508 -2.124 ****** -1.547 ****** -2.112 ****** -1.545 ****** -0.012  0.018 -0.002 -0.021
20220225.194541 -2.091 ****** -1.534 ****** -2.075 ****** -1.518 ****** -0.016  0.021 -0.016  0.008
20220225.194615 -2.008 ****** -1.528 ****** -2.037 ****** -1.536 ******  0.029 -0.008  0.008  0.028
20220225.194648 -2.053 ****** -1.493 ****** -2.045 ****** -1.495 ****** -0.008  0.011  0.002  0.017
20220225.194722 -2.041 ****** -1.484 ****** -2.037 ****** -1.480 ****** -0.004  0.016 -0.004  0.003
20220225.194756 -1.992 ****** -1.484 ****** -2.007 ****** -1.478 ******  0.015  0.006 -0.006 -0.008
20220225.194829 -1.998 ****** -1.459 ****** -1.991 ****** -1.457 ****** -0.007  0.020 -0.002 -0.024
20220225.194903 -1.985 ****** -1.427 ****** -1.951 ****** -1.428 ****** -0.034  0.016  0.001  0.021
20220225.194936 -1.916 ****** -1.488 ****** -1.903 ****** -1.354 ****** -0.013  0.036 -0.134  0.039
20220225.195010 -1.955 ****** -1.401 ****** -1.950 ****** -1.399 ****** -0.005  0.012 -0.002  0.005
20220225.195044 -1.918 ****** -1.368 ****** -1.914 ****** -1.378 ****** -0.004  0.025  0.010  0.009
20220225.195117 -1.943 ****** -1.374 ****** -1.938 ****** -1.382 ****** -0.005  0.010  0.008  0.011
20220225.195151 -1.946 ****** -1.392 ****** -1.945 ****** -1.388 ****** -0.001  0.015 -0.004 -0.004
20220225.195224 -1.915 ****** -1.391 ****** -1.933 ****** -1.386 ******  0.018  0.020 -0.005  0.004
20220225.195258 -1.933 ****** -1.393 ****** -1.929 ****** -1.374 ****** -0.004  0.019 -0.019  0.010
20220225.195332 -1.935 ****** -1.398 ****** -1.922 ****** -1.394 ****** -0.013  0.024 -0.004 -0.019
20220225.195405 -1.927 ****** -1.398 ****** -1.934 ****** -1.393 ******  0.007  0.017 -0.005 -0.007
20220225.195439 -1.936 ****** -1.417 ****** -1.925 ****** -1.417 ****** -0.011  0.017  0.000  0.035
20220225.195512 -1.928 ****** -1.392 ****** -1.924 ****** -1.392 ****** -0.004  0.012 -0.000  0.033
20220225.195546 -1.955 ****** -1.400 ****** -1.936 ****** -1.338 ****** -0.019  0.022 -0.062  0.019
20220225.195619 -1.927 ****** -1.401 ****** -1.914 ****** -1.389 ****** -0.013  0.022 -0.012  0.023
20220225.195653 -1.913 ****** -1.362 ****** -1.902 ****** -1.355 ****** -0.011  0.014 -0.007 -0.012
20220225.195726 -1.876 ****** -1.308 ****** -1.891 ****** -1.298 ******  0.015  0.000 -0.010  0.008
20220225.195800 -1.885 ****** -1.329 ****** -1.893 ****** -1.329 ******  0.008  0.020  0.000  0.024
20220225.195834 -1.913 ****** -1.378 ****** -1.869 ****** -1.338 ****** -0.044  0.036 -0.040  0.014
20220225.195907 -1.822 ****** -1.294 ****** -1.850 ****** -1.319 ******  0.028  0.013  0.025  0.012
20220225.195941 -1.888 ****** -1.345 ****** -1.884 ****** -1.337 ****** -0.004  0.015 -0.008  0.016
20220225.200014 -1.913 ****** -1.347 ****** -1.903 ****** -1.357 ****** -0.010  0.020  0.010  0.014
20220225.200048 -1.903 ****** -1.341 ****** -1.891 ****** -1.336 ****** -0.012  0.025 -0.005  0.013
20220225.200122 -1.897 ****** -1.375 ****** -1.889 ****** -1.376 ****** -0.008  0.021  0.001  0.019
20220225.200155 -1.891 ****** -1.360 ****** -1.887 ****** -1.353 ****** -0.004  0.008 -0.007  0.009
20220225.200229 -1.869 ****** -1.350 ****** -1.867 ****** -1.341 ****** -0.002  0.011 -0.009  0.011
20220225.200302 -1.894 ****** -1.332 ****** -1.884 ****** -1.324 ****** -0.010  0.012 -0.008  0.006
20220225.200336 -1.896 ****** -1.375 ****** -1.829 ****** -1.370 ****** -0.067  0.020 -0.005  0.035
20220225.200410 -1.883 ****** -1.332 ****** -1.862 ****** -1.299 ****** -0.021  0.011 -0.033  0.021
20220225.200443 -1.881 ****** -1.362 ****** -1.875 ****** -1.336 ****** -0.006  0.018 -0.026  0.020
20220225.200517 -1.866 ****** -1.312 ****** -1.876 ****** -1.320 ******  0.010  0.016  0.008  0.005
20220225.200550 -1.895 ****** -1.341 ****** -1.901 ****** -1.362 ******  0.006  0.021  0.021 -0.023
20220225.200624 -1.884 ****** -1.347 ****** -1.906 ****** -1.359 ******  0.022  0.014  0.012 -0.018
20220225.200657 -1.909 ****** -1.384 ****** -1.905 ****** -1.391 ****** -0.004  0.020  0.007 -0.008
20220225.200731 -1.881 ****** -1.370 ****** -1.882 ****** -1.345 ******  0.001  0.022 -0.025  0.036
20220225.200805 -1.882 ****** -1.347 ****** -1.878 ****** -1.343 ****** -0.004  0.019 -0.004  0.005
20220225.200838 -1.920 ****** -1.361 ****** -1.908 ****** -1.364 ****** -0.012  0.019  0.003  0.027
20220225.200912 -1.906 ****** -1.383 ****** -1.903 ****** -1.378 ****** -0.003  0.020 -0.005  0.009
20220225.200945 -1.903 ****** -1.363 ****** -1.904 ****** -1.364 ******  0.001  0.018  0.001  0.004
20220225.201019 -1.881 ****** -1.378 ****** -1.878 ****** -1.375 ****** -0.003  0.018 -0.003  0.038
20220225.201052 -1.869 ****** -1.368 ****** -1.862 ****** -1.344 ****** -0.007  0.018 -0.024 -0.014
20220225.201126 -1.909 ****** -1.345 ****** -1.894 ****** -1.344 ****** -0.015  0.009 -0.001 -0.017
20220225.201200 -1.899 ****** -1.369 ****** -1.900 ****** -1.377 ******  0.001  0.021  0.008  0.022
20220225.201233 -1.935 ****** -1.365 ****** -1.918 ****** -1.398 ****** -0.017  0.019  0.033  0.005
20220225.201307 -1.901 ****** -1.409 ****** -1.895 ****** -1.407 ****** -0.006  0.015 -0.002  0.021
20220225.201341 -1.823 ****** -1.369 ****** -1.889 ****** -1.378 ******  0.066 -0.015  0.009  0.006
20220225.201414 -1.875 ****** -1.359 ****** -1.875 ****** -1.341 ******  0.000  0.023 -0.018  0.021
20220225.201448 -1.879 ****** -1.364 ****** -1.890 ****** -1.366 ******  0.011  0.013  0.002  0.027
20220225.201521 -1.899 ****** -1.368 ****** -1.880 ****** -1.360 ****** -0.019  0.023 -0.008  0.004
20220225.201555 -1.830 ****** -1.363 ****** -1.867 ****** -1.371 ******  0.037  0.004  0.008  0.008
20220225.201629 -1.887 ****** -1.356 ****** -1.887 ****** -1.372 ******  0.000  0.016  0.016  0.008
20220225.201702 -1.903 ****** -1.384 ****** -1.894 ****** -1.379 ****** -0.009  0.021 -0.005  0.006
20220225.201736 -1.889 ****** -1.373 ****** -1.894 ****** -1.380 ******  0.005  0.021  0.007  0.023
20220225.201809 -1.940 ****** -1.397 ****** -1.921 ****** -1.418 ****** -0.019  0.022  0.021  0.037
20220225.201843 -1.891 ****** -1.347 ****** -1.873 ****** -1.370 ****** -0.018  0.025  0.023 -0.010
20220225.201917 -1.904 ****** -1.398 ****** -1.894 ****** -1.382 ****** -0.010  0.019 -0.016  0.005
20220225.201950 -1.894 ****** -1.378 ****** -1.891 ****** -1.381 ****** -0.003  0.013  0.003  0.019
20220225.202024 -1.908 ****** -1.405 ****** -1.895 ****** -1.407 ****** -0.013  0.021  0.002 -0.016
20220225.202057 -1.904 ****** -1.337 ****** -1.897 ****** -1.397 ****** -0.007  0.021  0.060 -0.012
20220225.202131 -1.942 ****** -1.413 ****** -1.920 ****** -1.405 ****** -0.022  0.024 -0.008  0.010
20220225.202205 -1.916 ****** -1.412 ****** -1.915 ****** -1.400 ****** -0.001  0.019 -0.012  0.016
20220225.202238 -1.940 ****** -1.438 ****** -1.927 ****** -1.428 ****** -0.013  0.013 -0.010  0.012
20220225.202312 -1.929 ****** -1.415 ****** -1.917 ****** -1.408 ****** -0.012  0.019 -0.007  0.018
20220225.202346 -1.927 ****** -1.434 ****** -1.915 ****** -1.419 ****** -0.012  0.029 -0.015  0.014
20220225.202419 -1.916 ****** -1.395 ****** -1.896 ****** -1.383 ****** -0.020  0.018 -0.012  0.015
20220225.202453 -1.939 ****** -1.425 ****** -1.929 ****** -1.419 ****** -0.010  0.026 -0.006  0.011
20220225.202526 -1.934 ****** -1.462 ****** -1.927 ****** -1.444 ****** -0.007  0.019 -0.018  0.020
20220225.202600 -1.939 ****** -1.445 ****** -1.934 ****** -1.443 ****** -0.005  0.007 -0.002  0.008
20220225.202633 -1.957 ****** -1.426 ****** -1.936 ****** -1.441 ****** -0.021  0.017  0.015  0.004
20220225.202707 -1.965 ****** -1.455 ****** -1.946 ****** -1.457 ****** -0.019  0.025  0.002  0.012
20220225.202741 -1.974 ****** -1.450 ****** -1.964 ****** -1.448 ****** -0.010  0.018 -0.002  0.018
20220225.202814 -1.929 ****** -1.522 ****** -1.956 ****** -1.489 ******  0.026  0.018 -0.033  0.021
20220225.202848 -1.959 ****** -1.456 ****** -1.958 ****** -1.446 ****** -0.001  0.028 -0.010  0.007
20220225.202922 -1.963 ****** -1.469 ****** -1.947 ****** -1.452 ****** -0.016  0.025 -0.017  0.016
20220225.202955 -1.962 ****** -1.472 ****** -1.965 ****** -1.466 ******  0.003  0.016 -0.006  0.011
20220225.203029 -1.970 ****** -1.511 ****** -1.971 ****** -1.500 ******  0.001  0.020 -0.011  0.007
20220225.203103 -1.962 ****** -1.490 ****** -1.957 ****** -1.473 ****** -0.005  0.018 -0.017  0.006
20220225.203136 -1.981 ****** -1.486 ****** -1.972 ****** -1.476 ****** -0.009  0.024 -0.010  0.017
20220225.203210 -2.006 ****** -1.531 ****** -1.997 ****** -1.524 ****** -0.009  0.020 -0.007  0.010
20220225.203244 -1.993 ****** -1.513 ****** -1.978 ****** -1.507 ****** -0.015  0.022 -0.006  0.006
20220225.203317 -2.008 ****** -1.526 ****** -1.986 ****** -1.519 ****** -0.022  0.018 -0.007  0.010
20220225.203351 -1.987 ****** -1.517 ****** -1.965 ****** -1.507 ****** -0.021  0.023 -0.010  0.014
20220225.203425 -2.000 ****** -1.509 ****** -2.001 ****** -1.495 ******  0.001  0.021 -0.014  0.014
20220225.203458 -2.029 ****** -1.532 ****** -2.008 ****** -1.544 ****** -0.021  0.022  0.012  0.013
20220225.203532 -2.025 ****** -1.538 ****** -2.007 ****** -1.537 ****** -0.018  0.021 -0.001  0.007
20220225.203606 -1.963 ****** -1.558 ****** -1.986 ****** -1.518 ******  0.023 -0.001 -0.040  0.008
20220225.203639 -2.032 ****** -1.540 ****** -2.016 ****** -1.531 ****** -0.016  0.023 -0.009  0.006
20220225.203713 -2.039 ****** -1.589 ****** -2.056 ****** -1.557 ******  0.017  0.022 -0.032  0.009
20220225.203747 -2.062 ****** -1.573 ****** -2.042 ****** -1.569 ****** -0.020  0.025 -0.004  0.013
20220225.203820 -2.049 ****** -1.593 ****** -2.065 ****** -1.607 ******  0.016  0.008  0.014  0.012
20220225.203854 -2.082 ****** -1.609 ****** -2.056 ****** -1.562 ****** -0.026  0.021 -0.047  0.019
20220225.203928 -2.056 ****** -1.600 ****** -2.050 ****** -1.588 ****** -0.006  0.015 -0.012  0.006
20220225.204001 -2.081 ****** -1.606 ****** -2.058 ****** -1.597 ****** -0.023  0.026 -0.009  0.009
20220225.204035 -2.027 ****** -1.588 ****** -2.008 ****** -1.588 ****** -0.019  0.021 -0.000  0.013
20220225.204108 -2.040 ****** -1.558 ****** -2.017 ****** -1.533 ****** -0.023  0.017 -0.025  0.018
20220225.204142 -1.996 ****** -1.558 ****** -2.000 ****** -1.550 ******  0.004  0.017 -0.008  0.012
20220225.204216 -2.010 ****** -1.556 ****** -1.999 ****** -1.540 ****** -0.011  0.017 -0.016  0.020
20220225.204249 -2.013 ****** -1.574 ****** -2.008 ****** -1.563 ****** -0.005  0.021 -0.011  0.013
20220225.204323 -2.016 ****** -1.556 ****** -2.003 ****** -1.548 ****** -0.013  0.024 -0.008  0.012
20220225.204356 -2.038 ****** -1.570 ****** -2.021 ****** -1.563 ****** -0.017  0.023 -0.007  0.010
20220225.204430 -2.053 ****** -1.597 ****** -2.012 ****** -1.586 ****** -0.041  0.021 -0.011  0.009
20220225.204504 -2.060 ****** -1.584 ****** -2.049 ****** -1.563 ****** -0.011  0.024 -0.021  0.019
20220225.204537 -2.041 ****** -1.612 ****** -2.037 ****** -1.587 ****** -0.004  0.018 -0.025  0.017
20220225.204611 -2.072 ****** -1.605 ****** -2.052 ****** -1.591 ****** -0.020  0.028 -0.014  0.009
20220225.204644 -2.044 ****** -1.604 ****** -2.040 ****** -1.596 ****** -0.004  0.019 -0.008  0.016
20220225.204718 -2.091 ****** -1.598 ****** -2.080 ****** -1.578 ****** -0.011  0.020 -0.020  0.014
20220225.204752 -2.063 ****** -1.650 ****** -2.050 ****** -1.614 ****** -0.013  0.025 -0.036  0.014
20220225.204825 -2.062 ****** -1.614 ****** -2.051 ****** -1.600 ****** -0.011  0.014 -0.014  0.023
20220225.204859 -2.056 ****** -1.622 ****** -2.056 ****** -1.605 ****** -0.000  0.010 -0.017  0.016
20220225.210717 -2.237 ****** -1.828 ****** -2.218 ****** -1.812 ****** -0.019  0.018 -0.016 -0.003
20220225.210950 -2.257 ****** -1.849 ****** -2.238 ****** -1.838 ****** -0.019  0.016 -0.011 -0.002
20220225.215045 -4.494 ****** -4.192 ****** -4.476 ****** -4.180 ****** -0.018  0.017 -0.012  0.004
20220225.215318 -4.490 ****** -4.188 ****** -4.478 ****** -4.176 ****** -0.012  0.011 -0.012  0.002
20220225.221826 -4.729 -9.616 -4.482 ****** -4.716 -9.625 -4.470 ****** -0.013  0.009 -0.012  0.001
20220225.222058 -4.774 -9.544 -4.530 ****** -4.758 -9.562 -4.516 ****** -0.016  0.018 -0.014  0.002
20220225.224606 -7.223 -7.725 -7.038 -8.597 -7.199 -7.731 -7.016 -8.583 -0.024  0.006 -0.022 -0.014
20220225.224838 -7.200 -7.674 -7.026 -8.548 -7.089 -7.582 -6.999 -8.527 -0.111 -0.092 -0.027 -0.021
20220225.235725 ****** -7.046 ****** -7.850 ****** -7.054 ****** -7.846 -0.001  0.008 -0.015 -0.004
20220225.235957 ****** -7.069 ****** -7.867 ****** -7.075 ****** -7.845  0.004  0.006 -0.035 -0.022
20220226.002505 ****** -7.530 ****** -8.192 ****** -7.543 ****** -8.205  0.013  0.013 -0.031  0.013
20220226.002738 ****** -8.561 ****** -9.349 ****** -8.561 ****** -9.328  0.003 -0.000 -0.033 -0.021
20220226.010833 -2.904 -9.046 -3.146 -9.929 -2.900 -9.040 -3.155 -9.935 -0.004 -0.006  0.009  0.006
20220226.011106 -2.402 -8.781 -2.668 -9.713 -2.405 -8.796 -2.657 -9.710  0.003  0.015 -0.011 -0.003
20220226.013622 -1.644 -8.191 -1.918 -9.020 -1.617 -8.197 -1.903 -9.021 -0.027  0.006 -0.015  0.001
20220226.013855 -1.530 -8.117 -1.750 -8.975 -1.508 -8.131 -1.745 -8.971 -0.022  0.014 -0.005 -0.004
20220226.020413 -2.846 -9.160 -3.206 ****** -2.838 -9.177 -3.204 ****** -0.008  0.017 -0.002  0.007
20220226.020645 -2.844 -9.062 -3.155 -9.931 -2.842 -9.065 -3.158 -9.932 -0.002  0.003  0.003  0.001
20220226.024740 -3.562 -9.886 -4.185 ****** -3.556 -9.887 -4.184 ****** -0.006  0.001 -0.001  0.003
20220226.025012 -3.636 -9.912 -4.241 ****** -3.632 -9.916 -4.242 ****** -0.004  0.004  0.001  0.007

    0.0134259    0.0181133    0.0131334    0.0134252
    0.0112500    0.0185995   0.00939000    0.0123997
mgalloy commented 1 year ago

Steve does not have processed results for 20221125 copied over to corona3.

mgalloy commented 1 year ago

For a centering metric, I am now recording four values in the extension header of a test annulus (1.03 - 1.13 Rsun) of each image just before combining the camera images:

  1. CAMCORR — the correlation between camera images
  2. CAMDIFF — median of absolute difference between camera images
  3. RCAMMED — median value in test annulus in RCAM
  4. TCAMMED — median value in test annulus in TCAM

These values are not very good right now and needs some fixes, but is this a good approach?