Split cui:LDCCodeSimpleType codes into separate types

cdmgtri commented 3 years ago

Opening an issue based on a new comment submitted for issue #156

I have some questions concerning the CUI schema and the simpleType “LDCCodeSimpleType”.

The simpleType "LDCCodeSimpleType" contains two different types of CVEs.

Some of the CVEs are for use only with "DocumentMarkingMetadata"
- Attorney-Client, Attorney-WP, Deliberative, DISPLAY ONLY, NOFORN
Some of the CVEs are for use only with "PortionMarkingMetadata"
- AC, AWP, DELIB, DL ONLY, NF,
Other CVEs may be used in both
- FED ONLY. FEDCON, NOCON, REL TO

By having all of these values defined in a single simpleType, the only way to perform accurate validation is thru the use of Schematron rules.

Would you consider separating these into two separate simpleTypes?

one that only contained the permissible CVEs for LDCCode within the "DocumentMarkingMetadata" structure?
and one that only contained the permissible CVEs for LDCCode within the "PortionMarkingMetadata" structure?

myergens commented 3 years ago

Thank-you. - David Y.

cdmgtri commented 2 years ago

Updated in NIEM 5.1 RC1.

NIEM / NIEM-Releases