NOAA-EDAB / ecodata

A data package for reporting on Northeast Continental Shelf ecosystem status and trends.
https://noaa-edab.github.io/ecodata/
Other
28 stars 11 forks source link

Bottom temperature maps #119

Closed khyde closed 5 months ago

khyde commented 5 months ago

For the bottom temp maps here? 1) Extend the northern range to include all of the GOM 2) Consider a different color scale so that the temperatures are more discernible. I find it difficult to see the temperature differences in the current maps. 3) I don't know if it belongs here or as a catalog issue, but it would be very helpful to also include bottom temp anomaly maps on this page.

BBeltz1 commented 5 months ago

@jcaracappa1 any input on this before I make changes?

jcaracappa1 commented 5 months ago
  1. Agree to extend max latitude
  2. Agreed. color scale should either be white to red or blue to red
  3. We decided to add anomaly plots but not for this year's report
BBeltz1 commented 5 months ago

I will get on these changes. Thanks.

BBeltz1 commented 5 months ago

@khyde @jcaracappa1 I've changed the color scale of the bottom temp seasonal gridded maps. Let me know your thoughts.

As for the change to the northern limit, is this something we want to do? It will essentially turn this map into a shelfwide map instead of being separated by report.

Currently, ecodata::plot_bottom_temp_seasonal_gridded(report = "MidAtlantic") plots this: image

And ecodata::plot_bottom_temp_seasonal_gridded(report = "NewEngland") plots this: image

jcaracappa1 commented 5 months ago

since this isn't going the report, we might just want to plot to be shelf wide with an option for selected one of the EPUs

khyde commented 5 months ago

I agree that it should be a shelfwide map and that we don't need EPU specific maps in the catalog. If anything, I would suggest including the offshore data as well and just make the EPU outlines a little thicker so you can really see the boundary. We often talk about offshore influences so I think it is important to show that data as well.

For the color scale, I think we need something that is more dynamic. It is very hard to see the differences in a monochromatic scale. This is what I am using for the summary pages and I think you can see the different temperatures so much better in something with more colors. D_20231008_20231014-ACSPO-V2 81-L3B2-NWA_SUBSET-PXY_1_1211676-SST-STACKED_STATS

jcaracappa1 commented 5 months ago

I did not supply gridded bottom temperature for outside the EPUs

jcaracappa1 commented 5 months ago

I like that scale, but we don't want to confuse it for the color scale used in the gridded anomaly plots

khyde commented 5 months ago

True, maybe one that goes from navy to green to yellow? There are a few here that would work. Maybe Inferno or Viridis https://jmsallan.netlify.app/blog/the-viridis-palettes/

khyde commented 5 months ago

Yellow-orange-red would work too

jcaracappa1 commented 5 months ago

I like the viridis inferno

BBeltz1 commented 5 months ago

yeah I can implement viridis inferno. i'll post new plots when that's done so you can take a look.

BBeltz1 commented 5 months ago

ecodata::plot_bottom_temp_seasonal_gridded(), now in viridus inferno. Thoughts?

image

khyde commented 5 months ago

This looks better. What is the temperature range being plotted? Maybe extend the min temp to 0 and max at 25 to allow for more dynamics in the lower temps since that is where the majority of the data are.