NOAA-OWP / inundation-mapping

Flood inundation mapping and evaluation software configured to work with U.S. National Water Model.
Other
95 stars 30 forks source link

[5pt] Alaska CatFIM segments seem to be shorter in length than CONUS CatFIM segments #1344

Open EmilyDeardorff opened 1 week ago

EmilyDeardorff commented 1 week ago

Looking over CatFIM 4.5.11.1, it is evident that the stream segments inundated in Alaska flow-based CatFIM seem to be much shorter, in general, than the CatFIM segments in other parts of the country. In the screenshots below, I've included some measured comparisons between CatFIM outputs in Alaska and CatFIM outputs in Washington State (a hydrologically-similar landscape).

Once I get the stage-based CatFIM outputs to download properly, I will add information on whether I am seeing this issue in stage-based as well.

Screenshots

Each screenshot includes a rough measurement of the flow length that seems to be inundated. The total (roughly) measured length is listed under Path Net Distance.

Alaska sites:

Alaska flow-based CatFIM, LID: clta2 image

Alaska flow-based CatFIM, LID: suna2 image

Alaska flow-based CatFIM, LID: lsoa2 image

Alaska flow-based CatFIM, LID: apta2 image

In comparison, CONUS sites in Washington:

Washington flow-based CatFIM, LID: sakw1 image

Washington flow-based CatFIM, LID: elww1 image

Washington flow-based CatFIM, LID: issw1 image

CarsonPruitt-NOAA commented 1 week ago

We've traced this back to WRDS not having stream tracing data for Alaska. We'll have to wait until they are able to get that running unless we decide to do the tracing ourselves.