NRC-Research / SNAP-issues

This repository was created to provide a public location to record and display the status of "issues" for the SNAP application. The SNAP developers will acknowledge, provide (and maybe request) feedback on the reported issues, and in general use the information to improve SNAP code.
3 stars 0 forks source link

TRACE plugin 'GRIDTYPES' problem - Spacer Grids #21

Closed MightyRonbo closed 2 years ago

MightyRonbo commented 2 years ago

TRACE has models for special treatment of Spacer Grids (also known as Grid Spacers). SNAP does seem to currently be able to support use of these models. The first step in the process is to change the namelist variable GRIDTYPES to something larger than 0. After that several additional inputs are needed. If SNAP were to work well, as it does for many other input parameters, the interface cells for the user to enter these additional inputs would appear after GRIDTYPES is changed to something greater than zero. Unfortunately, SNAP offers no way to change GRIDTYPES and there does not appear to be anywhere to enter the other inputs either. Please fix. I have done the calculations to obtain the inputs necessary to utilize the spacer gird models in my calculations. Alas, I cannot use them. Spacer Grids can enhance heat transfer significantly for certain reactor plant transients. So this is a feature of TRACE which should be used consistently. Thanks.
-Ronald Harrington ronald.harrington@nrc.gov

NRCgg commented 2 years ago

This was addressed in an email chain internal to the NRC TRACE group. Here is the resolution from Chris Murray:

First you define a custom grid type – there is a selection called “Spacer Grids” in the navigator. Add whatever grids with custom geometries your bundles use.

In the VESSEL or PIPE component, you then can add those custom grid types to specific locations up the bundle using the GRIDTYPES input parameter. As a namelist option, GRIDTYPES is irrelevant from SNAP’s view, and in my model editor, it does not even appear as an option. It should get automatically set based on how many custom grid types you define in step 1.

I tested using TRACE plugin 4.2.7 for SNAP.