search

NRC-Research / SNAP-issues

This repository was created to provide a public location to record and display the status of "issues" for the SNAP application. The SNAP developers will acknowledge, provide (and maybe request) feedback on the reported issues, and in general use the information to improve SNAP code.
3 stars 0 forks source link

MELCOR Models in SNAP 4.1.4 - SNAP reports having issues with the CCFNUM in CCF cards #56

Closed evgeni-borisov closed 8 months ago

evgeni-borisov commented 9 months ago

Hello, When FL_CCF card is entered then the following SNAP error messages appear (it should be noted that these are SNAP message only (not relevant for MELGEN)):

image

Here, only a section of the card is shown for brevity: FL_CCF 59 ! n name num fp1 fp2 clen c_d flood c_nc rev vol1 vol2 1 'RPV_HL1' 2 '092-100-1' '092-100-2' 0.85 0.09
2 'RPV_HL2' 2 '092-200-1' '092-200-2' 0.85 0.09
3 'RPV_HL3' 2 '092-300-1' '092-300-2' 0.85 0.09
4 'HL1_1_HL1_2' 2 '100-101-1' '100-101-2' 0.85 0.09
5 'HL2_1_HL2_2' 2 '200-201-1' '200-201-2' 0.85 0.09
6 'HL3_1_HL3_2' 2 '300-301-1' '300-301-2' 0.85 0.09
7 'HL4_1_HL4_2' 2 '400-401-1' '400-401-2' 0.85 0.09
8 .......

The above messages do not interfere starting MELCOR from SNAP, but are always present. It seems that SNAP does not allow repeating CCFNUM (that is not an input error for MELGEN).

Kind regards, Evgeni

WDunsford commented 8 months ago

This will be resolved in MELCOR plug-in version 2.8.1. The CCF Model # uniqueness will be an error for code flavor 1.8.6, but will only be a warning for MELCOR 2.2. Really these should be unique as MELCOR 2.2 supports reference by number.

evgeni-borisov commented 8 months ago

The issue is still present in SNAP 4.2.0 (this time as a warning): image