NeonKnightOA / oacmpvol1

OpenArena Community Mappack Vol. 1 Repository
GNU General Public License v2.0
6 stars 1 forks source link

OACMPDM5 small texture issues #27

Open The-Gig opened 2 years ago

The-Gig commented 2 years ago

I sent z_oacmp1v4_beta-220322.pk3 to a friend for testing, and he provided me some feedback.

Is that the "default missing texture", maybe? shot0179

Do you think that pitch black (instead of dark gray) part inside the recess is intentional? shot0178

In that place the texture seems to not be completely aligned: shot0177

Things seem to be a little messy there: shot0176 shot0094

NeonKnightOA commented 1 year ago

https://mega.nz/file/bMZkRJBa#J_rUm2nz2SpiMFl6kBY0eMceeCLOJ1PLfnz_-CQRzCw New test version. I think some of those were on purpose. Nevertheless, needs testing.

The-Gig commented 5 months ago

Tested version 230430 of the map. Trying to revisit all the places of the opening post, one by one:

I see this one uses a texture named "white", with an end result being shades of gray maybe a bit strange, but probably fitting. I guess this is OK. shot0029

This one looks a bit better now: not pitch black anymore, although one part is still darker than the other one. But in the editor I see it's the same texture (dirty_pweter_big), so probably it's the bezier curve part which for some reason gets lit differently than the standard brush part and fixing that might be complicated (or may just require tweaking/adding one light?). Maybe not perfect, but I guess we may also go on "as is". shot0030 shot0031

This one is strange. I mean, apart the opening thread post which is that the texture of the narrow (lower) part of the wall (which is a bit sloped) might be better aligned with the texture of the big wall (which is straight), looking at it more closely now I see some flickering, like the sloped part and the straight part overlap a little. But in-editor it doesn't look so! shot0034 shot0032 shot0033 shot0037

About this, maybe one might fix by stretching a little that patch? shot0035 Like from this immagine to this? immagine