NetAppDocs / storagegrid-116

https://docs.netapp.com/us-en/storagegrid-116/
5 stars 7 forks source link

SNMPv3 Suggestion for INFORM destinations #70

Open ashleyjNA opened 11 months ago

ashleyjNA commented 11 months ago

Page URL

https://docs.netapp.com/us-en/storagegrid-116/monitor/configuring-snmp-agent.html

Page title

Configure the SNMP agent

Summary

The SNMPv3 INFORM destination could be improved as there has been some confusion around where the Authoritative EngineID is generated.

From my understanding, in typical communication between an agent (GRID in this case) and a management station (external SNMP server/application), where the agent receives SNMP queries such asGETorSETthat require a response, the agent is the authoritative engine because it must reply to the message. However, if the agent sends the management station an Inform, the management station becomes the authoritative engine because it must reply to the Inform.

I believe our documentation could be more clear about the Authoritative EngineID needing to be from the user configured on the external management station, as we don't generate the unique EngineID for INFORMs.

Public issues must not contain sensitive information

netapp-maireadn commented 11 months ago

Hi @ashleyjNA, Thanks for providing feedback. I will liaise with the StorageGrid team and respond to your query as soon as possible. Mairead

netapp-pcarriga commented 7 months ago

Reassigning to pcarriga who has previously worked in a similar issue.