Open AlexLakatos opened 7 years ago
I don't agree with this. All commands should be usable, and seeing as people will forget if it's number:list or numbers:list, it's useful for both to exist.
As a comparison, Heroku is strict about this and it's a good CLI.`
nexmo-cli/ on develop
› heroku apps
=== phil@leggetter.co.uk Apps
vs.
nexmo-cli/ on develop
› heroku app
▸ app is not a heroku command.
▸ Perhaps you meant apps?
▸ Run heroku _ to run heroku apps.
▸ Run heroku help for a list of available commands.
@leggetter sure, so the 2 options are to either support multiple commands for one action, or to be strict and have decent fallback. We've gone the former way so far and we shouldn't drop it without understanding why it's there.
I'm all open to the latter option, but this means adding some graceful fallback for these kind of typos, as well as bumping the major version for removing so much backwards compatibility.
we shouldn't drop it without understanding why it's there
Agreed.
To be clear: Reason for this issue are:
nexmo help
shows apps:list
and app:create
. Is this more intuitive or should be be consistent with singular/plural the prefix?It could be that we were just unlucky with the recent numbers:list
problem and it could be better fixed by actually getting a fix (or workaround) for alias
https://github.com/tj/commander.js/issues/531
For a workaround we could potentially just create our own helper function wrapper.
@AlexLakatos just wanted to apologise for possibly being short and grumpy, no such thing was intended. I was at a conference abroad and answering quickly and to the point and I just realised I might have sounded a bit rude. I totally love that someone is trying to improve things, and all I wanted to do was provide some background.
The original spec had number
and numbers
as an alias, because depending on what you are doing the plural makes sense to read the command so number:update
but numbers:search
however it shouldn't matter if you use number
or numbers
in any command, same for apps
It might make the code more complex but it makes the product more usable IMO
This is a meta issue, tracking conventions for the CLI
:list
to the default single word command