NightscoutFoundation / xDrip

Nightscout version of xDrip+
https://jamorham.github.io/#xdrip-plus
GNU General Public License v3.0
1.4k stars 1.14k forks source link

Force collection on smartwatch does not work on any watch except Sony Smartwatch 3 #149

Closed Vaughanabe13 closed 3 years ago

Vaughanabe13 commented 7 years ago

Based on my own experience with 5 android wear watches and everyone else's experience documented in the facebook group, I have come to the conclusion that there is only one single watch that works when running the collector service, and that is the Sony SW3. I have also tried the original Moto 360, Moto 360 Sport, Moto 360 v2, Zenwatch 2, Zenwatch 3, and Zenwatch 3 after upgrading to Android Wear 2.0. Other reports say that it does not work on the huawei, the nixon, LG sport, urbane, etc.

While they all work with xdrip as a regular watchface viewer, none of them except the SW3 will get readings at all. Every indication on my ZW3 right now shows that it is working - watch is listed correctly in the xdrip app settings, force collection is enabled, location permissions are enabled on the watch, all the settings between the phone and watch match up, Dexcom shows up in the bluetooth settings menu of the watch, Android Wear is listed as the collector both on the watch and phone, etc. But no readings ever come in, even after hours of waiting. Tried multiple restarts of both phone and watch, tried leaving the phone off or in airplane mode. Tried toggling scan constantly and wake screen before reading options. Tried toggling aggressive service restarts. Tried manually restarting the collector. I even factory reset the watch twice. Nothing works.

I am hoping someone working on the code can work on this further because to me, being able to run the collector service on my watch is the single most important thing about the app and I know others feel the same way. Apple/Dexcom is now catching up because the Apple Watch will be able to function as a standalone collector with the G5 now. For now I will continue using the Smartwatch 3 but I don't think it is a good solution for the future since the SW3 can only be bought through ebay and old stock that is quickly running out, and there are other issues with that watch such as the nasty battery drain bug.

I understand this will probably be a challenge to figure out why the other watches aren't working. I would even be willing to send my zenwatch 3 to a developer who is serious about working on it. I think it is that important for the future of the G5 and xdrip.

kskandispersonal commented 7 years ago

Thanks for the feedback. Yes, each wear device seems to use a different BLE implementation. There are a few other watches that seem to work well as the collector, including the LG Urbane and the original Zenwatch. I haven't tried them myself though. I agree, support for the newer watches, esp w/ Wear 2.0, should be added. It is a TODO but unfortunately, I am not able to address it right now. If other dev members have time and would like to investigate the issues, maybe they can contact you if you are still willing to provide the Zenwatch 3 temporarily for dev. I, myself, only have the SW3 (two of them) but to find workarounds for a specific watch, I do think the watch will be required as a lot of debugging will most likely be required.

Vaughanabe13 commented 7 years ago

You say the Urbane works, but I see reports in the xdrip G5 facebook community that say the LG Urbane does not work as the collector. Multiple reports say it doesn't work if you search the group. I'm hearing the LG Urbane 2nd edition doesn't work either: " I'm using the Urbane 2nd edition paired with phone as collector, but I've not been able to "connect" directly from watch to transmitter. Bluetooth report on watch shows Dexcom as "disconnected"." Another post on March 31 from Richard Sample has multiple people confirming the LG Urbane 2nd edition doe not work. I don't see any comments at all on the group about the zenwatch (original), only the zenwatch 2 and 3 which both don't work. It could be that these posts were all from a time when the software was immature, I don't know. But there isn't a single post I can find from anyone who had success on any watch except the Smartwatch 3.

I'm willing to send the zenwatch 3 or an original moto 360 that I have laying around and can't use (since only my SW3 works) if anyone wants to work on it. Just send me a message and I'll ship it to you.

On Sun, Jul 23, 2017 at 5:06 PM, kskandispersonal notifications@github.com wrote:

Thanks for the feedback. Yes, each wear device seems to use a different BLE implementation. There are a few other watches that seem to work well as the collector, including the LG Urbane and the original Zenwatch. I haven't tried them myself though. I agree, support for the newer watches, esp w/ Wear 2.0, should be added. It is a TODO but unfortunately, I am not able to address it right now. If other dev members have time and would like to investigate the issues, maybe they can contact you if you are still willing to provide the Zenwatch 3 temporarily for dev. I, myself, only have the SW3 (two of them) but to find workarounds for a specific watch, I do think the watch will be required as a lot of debugging will most likely be required.

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-317285669, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOJ6QnN9GN2mHqCeyr1ksL_pwh4UHOHZks5sQ8PcgaJpZM4OgNLz .

jamorham commented 7 years ago

I've tried a number of things with the zenwatch 2 including even changing the bluetooth chip firmware but I haven't been able to resolve the core problem yet which is that after bonding the g5 transmitter doesn't agree with the bonding parameters.

The next steps are to look at the really low level bluetooth data exchanges, but its rather complicated and even if that shows why its not working it may still not allow it to be fixed. I am expecting if it is fixable then it may require for example a custom modified rom being flashed to the watch to make it work.

It might work with pre-nov-2016 g5 transmitters which were less strict about the bonding but I don't have one of those to test with.

Vaughanabe13 commented 7 years ago

Thanks so much for working on it. I personally wouldn't have a problem loading a custom ROM on my watch if that's the only way to make it work. At least a working solution could be explored and ported to other watches and potentially updated over time.

On Sat, Oct 28, 2017 at 3:32 PM, Jamorham notifications@github.com wrote:

I've tried a number of things with the zenwatch 2 including even changing the bluetooth chip firmware but I haven't been able to resolve the core problem yet which is that after bonding the g5 transmitter doesn't agree with the bonding parameters.

The next steps are to look at the really low level bluetooth data exchanges, but its rather complicated and even if that shows why its not working it may still not allow it to be fixed. I am expecting if it is fixable then it may require for example a custom modified rom being flashed to the watch to make it work.

It might work with pre-nov-2016 g5 transmitters which were less strict about the bonding but I don't have one of those to test with.

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-340217958, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOJ6Qij1YzbJ_YC2AwZmBrjiTpC6xFzxks5sw49YgaJpZM4OgNLz .

jamorham commented 6 years ago

Okay, I have produced a rom patch for the Zenwatch 2 which makes it work with the G5. I may well be able to repeat this process for other smart watches but it is fiddly and I only have a Zenwatch to experiment with at the moment.

lskeele1 commented 6 years ago

How would one get the rom patch for ZW2? I have one, and I'm very eager to make it work as an independent collector from the phone. I love this project!

jamorham commented 6 years ago

Patching the Zenwatch2 to work with the G5, PDF guide -> https://drive.google.com/open?id=1lPpjkiyiASLThoYFDpL9Pfor4fW3-4OK

All the required files in a care package zip file: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1Gk_Fbi98AkjLmSBTmVJ7_pq9dy7xF7Ld

Please let me know how you get on with this. If you're using windows instead of Linux then you will need to get set up with the ADB and FASTBOOT tools there as well as probably get universal adb drivers installed. I am slightly hazy on this process and it needs documenting in the guide.

jamorham commented 6 years ago

Oh and you should use any xDrip+ from the 23rd Nov nightly onwards as this has the updated wear component which can take advantage of the system level permissions on the patched zenwatch.

lskeele1 commented 6 years ago

Thanks! Traveling now, but will give it a try when I get home and let you know how it goes.

jamorham commented 6 years ago

I've also now produced a patch for the LG G Watch (W100)

Patching the LG Watch PDF Guide: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1pgabdYX-vMjSjyb0G5jbgoTko9gJxxCT

All the required files for the LG g in a care package zip file: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1z2ovSF66V_k7H49Wi_VHuBqPi0_2xpwk

lskeele1 commented 6 years ago

Reporting success on patching the Zenwatch 2! @JamorHam, you’re amazing! Here’s my report, in case you find anything helpful. First the good: My watch (I have the smaller version of the ZW2) has a near 100% collection rate. I initially tried to patch with Windows, but couldn’t seem to find the right drivers, so I switched to my RPi3. (I had previously manually updated to Wear 2.0 on Windows, but something was not working right on this one. As far as instructions go, though, I found this to be helpful in terms of getting ADB and Fastboot to work with Windows: https://www.androidsage.com/2016/03/04/install-marshmallow-ota-for-asus-zenwatch-2/.) Anyway, back to my update. Using my RPi3, I followed JamorHam’s instructions, and the patch worked well. A few notes: First, I used the command line rather than the swipe to boot into Fastboot mode. When I did, the watch said, “Fastboot Mode” rather than “Fastboot CSC.” Not sure, but I think this may be a difference in the international version of the watch. When I tried to unlock the bootloader, it told me that the bootloader was already unlocked. (Maybe this was from sideloading the OTA update to Wear 2.0?) I did not get a message on the watch screen about unlocking the bootloader, and the watch did not do a factory reset during this process – it retained my data. Everything else went according to the instructions. I uninstalled and reinstalled xDrip+ on the watch, and on the phone. The only other difference (related to not doing a factory reset) was that my watch didn’t do a fifteen-minute initial boot – it was a normal restart.

Now, the minor inconveniences. After one day of use, I’ve had very significant decrease in battery life on the watch. It hopefully won’t be a huge deal, because I plan to use my phone as the primary collector, and the watch only as a backup. But the other problem is that I can’t seem to get the phone to be the collector. My Sony SW3 shifts back and forth seamlessly between the watch and phone. But, when I try to make the phone (Moto G4) the collector, it just misses readings until I set the watch to be the collector again. Also, it appears to be draining my phone battery. Note that, when I patched the ZW2, I also updated to the Nov. 24 nightly build. I’ve noticed that, in this build, some of the Bluetooth settings are checked that I don’t think were checked before (though I’m not sure): Bluetooth Wakelocks and Close GATT. I’m going to play around with these settings, and also “Try the new OB1 G5 Collector” to see if I can get this solved. Thanks again for your work on this!

Vaughanabe13 commented 6 years ago

I would love to know what settings you have on your ZW2 that may be impacting battery life. For example, do you have gestures and tilt to wake? Do you have ambient display enabled? Brightness? Etc.

Great work, I think this is awesome progress! Unfortunately I think battery life will always be a concern but with improvements in the new processors and hardware configurations that might be partially mitigated.

On Mon, Nov 27, 2017 at 9:06 AM, lskeele1 notifications@github.com wrote:

Reporting success on patching the Zenwatch 2! @JamorHam, you’re amazing! Here’s my report, in case you find anything helpful. First the good: My watch (I have the smaller version of the ZW2) has a near 100% collection rate. I initially tried to patch with Windows, but couldn’t seem to find the right drivers, so I switched to my RPi3. (I had previously manually updated to Wear 2.0 on Windows, but something was not working right on this one. As far as instructions go, though, I found this to be helpful in terms of getting ADB and Fastboot to work with Windows: https://www.androidsage.com/2016/03/04/install-marshmallow-ota-for-asus- zenwatch-2/.) Anyway, back to my update. Using my RPi3, I followed JamorHam’s instructions, and the patch worked well. A few notes: First, I used the command line rather than the swipe to boot into Fastboot mode. When I did, the watch said, “Fastboot Mode” rather than “Fastboot CSC.” Not sure, but I think this may be a difference in the international version of the watch. When I tried to unlock the bootloader, it told me that the bootloader was already unlocked. (Maybe this was from sideloading the OTA update to Wear 2.0?) I did not get a message on the watch screen about unlocking the bootloader, and the watch did not do a factory reset during this process – it retained my data. Everything else went according to the instructions. I uninstalled and reinstalled xDrip+ on the watch, and on the phone. The only other difference (related to not doing a factory reset) was that my watch didn’t do a fifteen-minute initial boot – it was a normal restart.

Now, the minor inconveniences. After one day of use, I’ve had very significant decrease in battery life on the watch. It hopefully won’t be a huge deal, because I plan to use my phone as the primary collector, and the watch only as a backup. But the other problem is that I can’t seem to get the phone to be the collector. My Sony SW3 shifts back and forth seamlessly between the watch and phone. But, when I try to make the phone (Moto G4) the collector, it just misses readings until I set the watch to be the collector again. Also, it appears to be draining my phone battery. Note that, when I patched the ZW2, I also updated to the Nov. 24 nightly build. I’ve noticed that, in this build, some of the Bluetooth settings are checked that I don’t think were checked before (though I’m not sure): Bluetooth Wakelocks and Close GATT. I’m going to play around with these settings, and also “Try the new OB1 G5 Collector” to see if I can get this solved. Thanks again for your work on this!

From: JamOrHam [mailto:notifications@github.com] Sent: Friday, November 24, 2017 11:23 AM To: NightscoutFoundation/xDrip xDrip@noreply.github.com Cc: lskeele1 laynekeele@hotmail.com; Comment comment@noreply.github.com

Subject: Re: [NightscoutFoundation/xDrip] Force collection on smartwatch does not work on any watch except Sony Smartwatch 3 (#149)

I've also now produced a patch for the LG G Watch (W100)

Patching the LG Watch PDF Guide: https://drive.google.com/open? id=1pgabdYX-vMjSjyb0G5jbgoTko9gJxxCT

All the required files for the LG g in a care package zip file: https://drive.google.com/open?id=1z2ovSF66V_k7H49Wi_VHuBqPi0_2xpwk

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHubhttps://github.com/ NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-346872529, or mute the threadhttps://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AalcHXNUD_ NVhGJ0vdXcSCSrFCtItyjxks5s5vtzgaJpZM4OgNLz.

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-347209941, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOJ6QhR_uOIwJOW9YRAtK-05DirNiY4iks5s6s_7gaJpZM4OgNLz .

Vaughanabe13 commented 6 years ago

Just an update: I sent jamorham 4 more watches to patch. He is doing great work.

Zenwatch 3 Fossil Q Founder 2.0 Polar M600 Moto 360

jamorham commented 6 years ago

@lskeele1 great to hear that you've been able to repeat my process and apply the patch to the zenwatch. I recommend using the OB1 collector and I would hope that this would use less battery than that classic collector

lskeele1 commented 6 years ago

OB1 Collector is working better. After most of a day, battery life is much better than before, and the phone and watch are now switching properly when I check/uncheck the "force wear" box. (It usually misses about two readings during the transition, but that's no big deal to me.) Both watch and phone look as if they will easily make it one full day, which is all that I'm looking for. @Vaughanabe13, I keep ambient display on because I want to view my glucose level quickly, and I've found that waking the screen takes a half second or so. Other than that, normal settings: brightness 3, no gestures, but yes tilt to wake.

Vaughanabe13 commented 6 years ago

Very interesting, thanks. Yes I agree that it's helpful to have ambient display on. I was hoping that was the case and that you weren't getting terrible battery life with the display off. It sounds like the OB1 is working great. Very excited to try another watch finally!

On Mon, Nov 27, 2017 at 5:45 PM, lskeele1 notifications@github.com wrote:

OB1 Collector is working better. After most of a day, battery life is much better than before, and the phone and watch are now switching properly when I check/uncheck the "force wear" box. (It usually misses about two readings during the transition, but that's no big deal to me.) Both watch and phone look as if they will easily make it one full day, which is all that I'm looking for. @Vaughanabe13 https://github.com/vaughanabe13, I keep ambient display on because I want to view my glucose level quickly, and I've found that waking the screen takes a half second or so. Other than that, normal settings: brightness 3, no gestures, but yes tilt to wake.

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-347366971, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOJ6Qv-yKMRPXfEazClt1KzhoVD_1g1Hks5s60m2gaJpZM4OgNLz .

Shuralon commented 6 years ago

Can i help somehow to get the Huawei Watch Active working?

jamorham commented 6 years ago

@Shuralon can you give the exact watch model number?

Shuralon commented 6 years ago

In the settings it just says "Huawei Watch " (can't find any specific model number), so i guess the first gen all have the same hardware just the style is different. It has Android Wear 2 installed. https://www.gsmarena.com/huawei_watch-7687.php

jamorham commented 6 years ago

@shuralon is there anything written on the back? How technical are you, do you have access to a linux device like a Linux PC or Raspberry Pi? Would you be confident to do some guided investigative work to examine its internals using android development tools?

Shuralon commented 6 years ago

In the back its just "Huawei Watch" again. I'm studying Computer Engineering so I have access to a linux PC and a RPi. Would like to do that, just tell me what to do.

jamorham commented 6 years ago

@Shuralon ok drop me an email jamorham at gmail or do a private chat on gitter and I can give you more detailed instructions without cluttering this issue ticket

jamorham commented 6 years ago

List of watches currently supported: https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/wiki/Patching-Android-Wear-devices-for-use-with-the-G5

I have recently added the ZenWatch3 and Polar M600

kretch commented 6 years ago

Which watch ( except sw3) with lte connectivity works with xdrip+ as standalone collector and nightscout uploader?

Vaughanabe13 commented 6 years ago

kretch, developer jamorham has been working on adding additional watches that work as the standalone collector with xdrip+, however the other watches do require some work to patch the bluetooth. If you go to the post above yours you will see he added a link with the supported watches that he was able to get working so far. I hope that helps.

kretch commented 6 years ago

Thanks! I looked at the list but didn't see any watch there that has Cellular connectivity

Vaughanabe13 commented 6 years ago

At this point I believe you are correct, but in theory a patch could be developed for those watches if he had the physical watch to work on. I was able to ship some of the other watches to him but I don't own one of the cellular connectivity watches. I can't speak for jamorhamor the other developers but maybe if you had a watch you were willing to ship he/they might be willing to work on a patch. However, I think it's too soon to tell how these patches will hold up over time with android wear updates/security updates/ etc. planned in the future.

On Mon, Dec 11, 2017 at 10:21 AM, kretch notifications@github.com wrote:

Thanks! I looked at the list but didn't see any watch there that has Cellular connectivity

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-350774879, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AOJ6QiRQBluu9oi2_Z2Xt00QCfKKfk1aks5s_VadgaJpZM4OgNLz .

jamorham commented 6 years ago

@kretch is there a particular watch you would like it to work with?

kretch commented 6 years ago

@jamorham Either the huawei 2 with 4g,or the LG urbane 2 with 4g- both use the Snapdragon 2100 soc

On Tue, Dec 12, 2017, 07:21 JamOrHam notifications@github.com wrote:

@kretch https://github.com/kretch is there a particular watch you would like it to work with?

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-351083211, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AHXFMMCbFCQJQ24NIyRp5VeYmIWALYhzks5s_poSgaJpZM4OgNLz .

IslePilot commented 6 years ago

@jamorham Do you know if the Fossil Gen 3 Q Venture will ever be on the list? I just got one for my wife and I would love to get it set up for her. Thanks.

kellestyle commented 6 years ago

@jamorham I second the question on the fossil gen 3... I'm "following" dex running from android wear app on iPhone and it says "this device isn't supported" when i try to download the app to the watch I thought all android wear devices can run the apps from google play store, but apparently not fossil. I love the watch-but need the thing to work with nightspot or follow. help!?

jamorham commented 6 years ago

@IslePilot @kellestyle I only have a Fossil DW2e to work with at the moment - I am assuming this is a different watch? If someone is willing to send me a watch to work with (which I will send back when complete) then there is a chance I can produce patches for it as has been done with other watches.

I have absolutely no idea what would happen with running xDrip watch face on android wear connected to iphone. I think you can run the watch stand-alone if it is sometimes near to an android wear device (or using wifi/cloud connection) but I don't know how you'd side-load xdrip on to a watch connected to apple device and crucial features - eg calibration are not present on the watch-face and it needs a companion handset somewhere to achieve that.

ldkbyj commented 6 years ago

@jamorham Thank you for your effort. Do you have a plan for LG Watch Sports (androind wear 2.0) ?

kellestyle commented 6 years ago

I returned it, just too much trouble! Thank you for the kind reply!

Kelle Carthey, RN Director of Nursing Services Brothers Healthcare

On Jan 4, 2018, at 10:33 PM, ldkbyj notifications@github.com wrote:

@jamorham Thank you for your effort. Do you have a plan for LG Watch Sports (androind wear 2.0) ?

— You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or mute the thread.

siblues commented 6 years ago

Please excuse my very simple question but when you are talking about force collection on the watch does that mean the watch is receiving the G5 readings on it's own without the phone?I need a watch that can receive the readings without needing the phone nearby.I am unable to have my phone on me at work and I may need to resign if I can't find a work around.Thanks

ldkbyj commented 6 years ago

@siblues I think you need Sony Smartwatch 3 or below watches. https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/wiki/Patching-Android-Wear-devices-for-use-with-the-G5

Klaus3d3 commented 6 years ago

Hi guys,

can anyone of you having a pazched watch other than th sony, can tell me if the collector is reliable with the blukon? I can't get my Sony to work properly. Only in forced mode, it collects sometimes something. If it's in the "Phone out of range" mode, it just does nothing.

jamorham commented 6 years ago

@keencave any reports about blucon with patched watch? for @Klaus3d3

no1jeeves commented 6 years ago

Hi ladies and Gents, Does anyone know if the Nixon Mission SS watch is compatable as a collector?, it is as far as I have found the only one with 10ATM water resistance, and recommended for swimming and surfing, others that are IPX8, or IP68, are not recommended for these activities as per the standards they are tested too, Thanks

borijess commented 6 years ago

I have a Polar M600 that I patched. Was working great but I rebooted and factory reset watch. My question is do we have to patch every single time I reboot watch or factory reset? Or is the patch permanent?

lskeele1 commented 6 years ago

I just bought a Verizon Wear24 because it was cheap on major clearance. Has anybody tried using one as a forced collector (I just got it today, and no luck so far)?

Vaughanabe13 commented 6 years ago

Personally I wouldn't even bother with the wear24, it's a highly flawed watch that's already on its way out and won't be available soon.

JimZam commented 6 years ago

Good evening from Spain. I have several questions that probably you can answer...

Thank you so much in advance Regards

Vaughanabe13 commented 6 years ago

Pebble does not work as the collector, nor do watches from other manufacturers like Garmin, unfortunately. The Pebble can be used as a secondary display for glucose but you would still need a collection device (phone or watch or receiver).

Currently I am using the Zenwatch 3 as my main collector device and I would say it's not quite the best experience, but it's probably good enough in most scenarios. The collection rate is pretty good, battery life is pretty good and easily lasts a whole day, screen quality is nice and the watch has AW2.0. I don't use my watch a lot except for basic notifications and texting, and I end up with about 30-50% battery at the end of a long day when running the collector all day. I then charge my watch on the night stand while I'm sleeping and then use my Pebble for vibration alerts while I'm sleeping (if BG gets out of range). So for me the battery life on the ZW3 is good enough with the screen always on, but if I were using the watch heavily all day, battery life might drop more and I would be less comfortable making it through a whole day without charging.

Comparing the ZW3 and the Sony SW3, I think the Sony probably does a better job functioning as the collector. It works out of the box without any modifications, the collection rate is higher than the ZW3 and very stable with very few dropouts, and because of that it feels more reliable. I also like that you can leave the display always on but disable the backlight. I think my battery life ends up being about equivalent to the ZW3, however in bright sunlight the SW3 is much more readable thanks to the transflective display. With my ZW3 on auto-brightness, I have to tap the screen to wake it up so the display can brighten enough where I can actually see it in daylight. That backlight usage can drain battery quickly if you are in the sun all day, so the SW3 wins that battle. However, the SW3 screen quality is not very good indoors and has an ugly yellow tint to it, compared to the beautiful AMOLED display on the ZW3. Also the SW3 has better waterproofing, although I wouldn't consider it a waterproof watch because the screen has been known to leak when fully submerged. But I would trust it more than I would trust the ZW3, which is not waterproof at all.

I would not suggest the moto 360 if you want a watch that you can leave the display always on. The processor is slow and the battery is bad.

So I guess my current recommendation would be go with the SW3 if you are primarily outdoors or near water, and go with the ZW3 if you spend more time indoors or in an office environment. In theory the Nixon Mission should be a better watch if you really need waterproofing, however I don't own that watch and I don't know if it has collector support yet.

JimZam commented 6 years ago

Thank you so much for your quick and really enlightening answer, Vaughanabe13. Kind regards

lskeele1 commented 6 years ago

@jamorham I originally used the smaller ZW2 (without the speaker) for this process. I recently got the larger version (with the speaker), and was able to modify it to work as the collector, but during the process, I lost the ability to use the watch as a speakerphone. The speaker on the watch still plays media (e.g., Pandora), but, during a call, the microphone and speaker do not work. Any thoughts on why this would be the case or how to remedy it? As always, thanks!

cybernissart commented 6 years ago

Have a smartphone running nightly build 190318, and a SW3 running 10.0.84 GPS version. Collector on smartwatch does not work, when phone is out of range or off.

Don't know if it was broken by an interim build somewhere, as it was working previous weeks ago somehow.

Would you have troubleshooting steps/method to address it on watch?

How to check if BT binding and association password if correctly pushed from phone to watch? Can we connect through BT association menu perhaps (it fails in my case)?

Is adb the only method to check for this?

ralf-ms commented 6 years ago

I can't get my Huawei Watch 2 working with Libre Blucon (force wear collection service). Is this also caused by incompatible bluetooth implementations/versions or is this an entirely different issue?

paaascal commented 6 years ago

Hello i Do water sports and need a watch that can collect freestyle libre data WITHOUT the phone around. I happen to be on the ocean for long hours and simply need to see my bs and go to shore if it starts dropping... Is the swr50 the only one that can do this WITHOUT the phone or are there others?

When I have. The phone around I use xdrip...

Thanks

no1jeeves commented 6 years ago

Hi, the libre freestyle is an NFC device, not a transmitter, I don't think that anyone makes a watch with NFC,

On Sun, Apr 8, 2018, 5:50 AM paaascal notifications@github.com wrote:

Hello i Do water sports and need a watch that can collect freestyle libre data WITHOUT the phone around. I happen to be on the ocean for long hours and simply need to see my bs and go to shore if it starts dropping... Is the swr50 the only one that can do this WITHOUT the phone or are there others?

When I have. The phone around I use xdrip...

Thanks

— You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/NightscoutFoundation/xDrip/issues/149#issuecomment-379520169, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AiRfwvduuOiILg5nWJIooZmYysh9PPUNks5tmZcKgaJpZM4OgNLz .