search

NikolayXHD / Mtgdb

Mtgdb.Gui - desktop app to search MTG cards and build decks
https://www.slightlymagic.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=62&t=19299
Other
63 stars 10 forks source link

Release a Linux AppImage #60

Closed TeamLinux01 closed 1 year ago

TeamLinux01 commented 4 years ago

Bug report

Mtgdb.Gui version

Steps to reproduce the bug

Actual result (the bug)

Expected result

Feature request

description, importance statement

Possibly an easier way to support Linux users.

suggested solution

Look into packaging the application up as an AppImage, that way the AppImage can be executed to launch the GUI app, instead of having to extract all the files and run start.sh in a terminal. https://docs.appimage.org/packaging-guide/index.html

As an example of another application that uses mono that ships an AppImage, maybe take a look at OpenRA's github with this issue (Bundle Mono inside AppImage): https://github.com/OpenRA/OpenRA/issues/15965 Not bundling Mono is fine with me, just having it request it needing to be downloaded and installed is OK.

Thank you for taking my suggestions into consideration and I appreciate your hard work making and maintaining Mtgdb.Gui.

NikolayXHD commented 4 years ago

I want to thank you in return for your suggestions to be concrete and easy to follow. Also, being novice in Linux I found following your tip beneficial for my literacy.

Will see about AppImage the coming weekend.

probonopd commented 4 years ago

If you need some help, I know everything about AppImage but practically nothing about Mono...

NikolayXHD commented 4 years ago

AppImage requires that application does not touch the application directory - when AppImage gets mounted, it is a temporary read-only mount point. I find it 100% reasonable, but currently Mtgdb.Gui does a many different things that result in writes to app directory, including self-update.

Probably any reasonable packaging system would require or suggest a similar approach, so this needs to be fixed. Thus the issue is becoming long term.

Filed #61

TeamLinux01 commented 4 years ago

I was thinking that if the program is made to be AppImage friendly, then it could probably also be bundled better as a Windows portable executable instead of a zip file. If I find some good documentation on how to make a read-only, self-contained folder structure, .NET compiled executable, I will more than likely open another issue to help with that tracking.

If I can help out in other ways, please let me know.