search

Nokorbis / ar-command-signs

Minecraft (Spigot) plugin that allows to transform some blocks (Signs, plates and buttons) into a Commands executor
https://www.spigotmc.org/resources/command-signs.10512/
Apache License 2.0
13 stars 10 forks source link

Some suggestions #33

Open mareksipos93 opened 5 years ago

mareksipos93 commented 5 years ago

Hello,

first of all - Iam really happy that this plugin exists. I have been using old Command Signs for a long time so I was really glad when I saw this.

I have some suggestions for further improvements: ✘ Allow to make command sign of every block (like green wool for example) ✓ Make commands for every option in menu, using your menu is very frustrating... using commands directly is faster. ✓ Make it possible to exit creation menu without creating sign. When I change my mind I cannot simply leave the menu. It says 'You need to register a block to save a new command block.'. ✓ Add new plugin alias /cmds ✓ Add "raw message" as option for executors... it will simply output message to player.

Thank you for your hard work

Nokorbis commented 5 years ago

Hello, Thanks for your suggestions. 1) What aliases would you like to see ? Currently, the available possibilities are : commandsigns, commandsign, cmdsign, arcs, ahcs, ncs I didn't use "cs" because I know some major plugins use it too (but I can't remember which one) and I don't want some undefined behavior caused by that. 2) I don't think I would do it. I think the tellraw command is the best option you have. It is much more customizable than what I would be willing to do. 3) This point I'm not sure. That gets quite far from what I was intended to do with my plugin. 4) Yeah, thought about that. Would need some work though. 5) Same

mareksipos93 commented 5 years ago

  1. Just add alias cmds please, because it was used in legacy Command Signs and its confusing to not have it in successor plugin.

  2. Okay, it was just suggestion, but writing JSON everytime is SO MUCH PAIN Example: I made random TP sign which was using spreadplayers command... and I wanted to add simple message &aTeleporting to random location So instead of that simple text I was forced to actually use /tellraw %player% {"text":"Teleporting to random location","color":"green"}

  3. Would it be difficult to just allow clicking any block? Actually it may be quite useful and I don't see any reason for limitting it only to signs, levers, etc... Legacy Command Signs allowed it too and I have used it on many occassions.

  4. I understand that making so many commands is really exhausting (from the dev point of view).

  5. This is really needed though... I was surprised that there is no way to close menu after /cmdsign create if I want to cancel it... I'm forced to actually place some block and apply command sign and then delete it...

Nokorbis commented 5 years ago

Which version of minecraft are you using ?

mareksipos93 commented 5 years ago

This server is running CraftBukkit version git-Spigot-df0eb25-f2757f9 (MC: 1.14.2) (Implementing API version 1.14.2-R0.1-SNAPSHOT)

Nokorbis commented 5 years ago

You might want to look at the 2.1.3 beta version https://github.com/Nokorbis/ar-command-signs/releases/tag/2.1.3.Beta

mareksipos93 commented 5 years ago

Wow almost everything from the list is now in plugin, you did an amazing job. Going to try it out tomorrow!