NonlinearFruit / Creeds.json

Structured copies of Reformed creeds, confessions and catechisms. Readily useful for software applications.
15 stars 5 forks source link

Henry Catechism Q94.2d-e vs Q94.3b-c #42

Closed NonlinearFruit closed 2 years ago

NonlinearFruit commented 2 years ago

These appear to be duplicates. Which is correct?

        {
          "Number": "2d",
          "Question": "Are we thereby entered into Christ's school?",
          "Answer": "Yes: Jesus made and baptized disciples, John 4:1."
        },
        {
          "Number": "2e",
          "Question": "And listed under his banner?",
          "Answer": "Yes: As good soldiers of Jesus Christ, 2 Tim. 2:3."
        }

vs

        {
          "Number": "3b",
          "Question": "Are we thereby entered into Christ's school?",
          "Answer": "Yes: Jesus made and baptized disciples, John 4:1."
        },
        {
          "Number": "3c",
          "Question": "And listed under his banner?",
          "Answer": "Yes: As good soldiers of Jesus Christ, 2 Tim. 2:3."
        }

source: https://github.com/NonlinearFruit/Creeds.json/blob/master/creeds/matthew_henrys_scripture_catechism.json#L12671

NonlinearFruit commented 2 years ago

It is duplicated in the source document (source).

The source needs to be fixed or we need a better source document

NonlinearFruit commented 2 years ago

Reached out to the Blue Letter Bible team so fix it and asked about original sources

NonlinearFruit commented 2 years ago

This could be a better source: https://archive.org/details/westminsterassem00west/mode/2up

Published in 1846

NonlinearFruit commented 2 years ago

2 only has 3 parts (not 5) and these questions belong to 3

image